1914 Cracker Jack toughest cards
 

Is it the following? These would be my toughest list

Matty
Cady
Pratt
No number 17 breshnahan

Fellow Cracker Jack collectors pls share your thoughts.

I don't collect the set so I can't provide an answer, but I am curious: doesn't Pratt sell for much more than Cady?

Yes
 

Yes but cady has lower combined psa and sgc pops I believe. It's the rarest of them all according to the current combined pops of sgc and psa.

IIRC, Matty is ctually one of the higher pops from the second series. No # Bresnahans also seem to be around, I don't think Id have either of those on the list. Shotten is also a tough card with the Pratt and Cady followed by a bunch of cards from the second series.

Its odd though, these cards all seemed much more rare 5 years ago than today, it seems like every card comes up f/s every few months now opposed to a few years ago when they actually had to be hunted down as they were sitting in private collections. The price boom seemed to end that...now theyre just expensive.

I would add Frank Chance to the list. Tough and expensive.