Thinking of selling my dupes
 

Hi guys I am thinking of selling my dupe 1914 Cracker Jacks. Just wondering the best way to go about it. Robert

Here's a list of what I have. Bottom list are raw cards that I am taking to the card show in NY this weekend to have graded.
1. Otto Knabe PSA 1.5
4***Larry Doyle PSA 1
8***Rude Oldring SGC A
8***Rude Oldring SGC A
8***Rude Oldring PSA 1
9***Artie Hoffman PSA 1
11**George Stovall SGC 10
15**Reb Russell PSA 2
17**Roger Bresnahan PSA 1 nnob
21**Heinie Zimmerman BVG 1.5
23**Charles Comiskey SGC 10
24**George Mullen PSA 1
24**George Mullen**PSA 2
25**Michael Simon SGC 10
26**James Scott PSA 2.5
27**Bill Carrigan PSA 1
27**Bill Carrigan PSA 1
31**Heine Wagner PSA 1
33**Amos Strunk SGC 30
35**Harry Hooper PSA 1
41**Tommy Leach PSA A
46**Bob Groom PSA 2
51**Nap Rucker PSA A
51**Nap Rucker PSA 1
51**Nap Rucker PSA 1
51**Nap Rucker PSA 3
54**Marty O’Toole PSA 1
58**Wally Schang PSA 1
58**Wally Schang PSA 2
59**Harry Gessler PSA 2
59**Harry Gessler PSA 2
59**Harry Gessler GAI 1.5
63**Babe Adams BVG A
69**John Mc Graw PSA 1
72**Joe Boehling PSA 1
83**Russ Ford PSA 2
97**Rube Benton PSA A
100 Thomas Seton SGC 10
109 Fred Blanding PSA 1
121 Hub Perdue PSA 1
126 Walter Blair PSA 1
129 Ray Caldwell SGC 10
144 Jimmy Walsh PSA 1.5



1****Otto Knabe
5****Ward Miller
8****Rude Oldring
9****Artie Hoffman
11**George Stoval
11**George Stoval
16**Howard Camnitz
17**Roger Bresnahan
17**Roger Bresnahan
26**James Scott
27**William Carrigan
29**Vean Gregg
42**Albert Bridwell
42**Albert Bridwell
48**Harry Lord
49**John Miller
49**John Miller
50**John Hummel
53**Otto Miller
56**Clyde Milan
56**Clyde Milan
58**Walter Schang
59**Harry Gessler
64**James Archer
64**James Archer
64**James Archer
67**Doc Crandall
72**Joseph Boehling
75**Miller Huggins
84**Elmer Kretzer
84**Elmer Kretzer
96**Beals Becker
99**Frank Chance
99**Frank Chance
112 Edward Sweeney
117 Theodore Easterly
121 Hub Perdue
130 Ivy Wingo
132 Leslie Nunamaker
138 Henry Gowdy
140 Daniel Murphy
143 John Daubert

Posting this on the front page was not the way to sell them. I suggest putting prices next to them right where they are now (here). Good luck.

Thanks Leon but wasn't trying to sell them on here I just wanted opinions on if I should go with eBay like Pwcc or a big auction house like Heritage. I don't have scans of the cards otherwise I would have put them here. It is about 1/2 the set but don't know if it's better to sell them that way or one at a time. Just looking for opinions. Robert

1914 CJs
 

PM sent

I've sold cards through PWCC and have gotten good results. :)

Instead of listing each individually on the front page you could have asked the question something like "Hey guys, I have a bunch of lower grade 1914 CJs, what would be the best way to sell them?"

I think you would probably get a little more selling individually as opposed to a group. You know the normal venues already. Like I said, you might put prices on them right here and see if they sell, saving you some fees.

Prices
 

Agreed - I know many won't ask and ignore/move on if they don't see a price. Like seeing "market price" on a restaurant menu - how many times have you inquired about that in the past?

Robert - you may want to try the pricing/sales route here first then move whatever you don't sell to an AH like PWCC, Goodwin, LOTG, etc. I sold the 95-100 or so 1914 CJ's I had here a couple years ago w/great success. I had envisioned moving whatever didn't sell to an AH, but I was cleaned out here in no time (perhaps I priced too low :rolleyes:). I will say there seems to be more CJ's for sale (that I have noticed) of late, so not sure where the supply/demand model is at current? When I sold there didn't seem to be a lot for sale at that time .. or so I perceived.

Good luck w/whatever path you choose.

Went with Heritage