34 Goudey Gehrig looks over graded
 

Do you agree that there is a hole in this card?

Centering looks a little less than 90/10 as well.

Not trying to say PSA blew this one - just trying to decide on whether to bid or not.

not sure about a hole...but definitely overgraded by the champs at PSA!!!

Def should have a qualifier as well.

Now I see the hole...should be graded 1...gotta love PSA...Kevin sure does!

I see what could be a hole on the back at the top at the U in "Lou". Not sure if it is or isn't as I can't locate a hole in front. Either way this is a pretty bad 3. Corners alone it is a 3. Crease is light but still is there. Centering is terrible. To me this is technically a 2 with nice eye appeal for a 2. Bad 3. Unless there really is a hole. Then it's a 1 no questions asked.

Tom C

All companies make mistakes.

Isn't the front of the hole directly to the right of the "NY" on his cap?

I was seeing the same thing; A hole in the hat

I saw that, but am not familiar enough with the 34 Gehrig to know if that was some sort of mark that was supposed to be there on his cap or not.

Tom C

No, it's not supposed to be there.

http://caimages.collectors.com/psace...0_598x1011.jpg

Def overgraded, however who's gonna complain about it? "Excuse me, Mr. PSA Grader, I believe there is a mistake in my cards grade, I think it should be a 1 instead of a 3 :D"

What's wrong with it? It looks like it might be more of a 50 than a 60, but that's a small subjective difference compared to calling a card with creases and a hole VG.

And yes, all companies make mistakes.

Steve B