T206 scrap in goodwin?
 

Lot #56: 1910 Sweet Caporal 350 Subjects Factory 30 Jake Weimer Printer's Scrap SGC 1.5 Fair

Looks like someone spilled kool-aid on it... Maybe it happened at the factory :)

http://www.goodwinandco.com/mobile/L...entoryid=29674


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Right? Looks more like Crap than scrap to me...I'll reserve final judgment for the Freaks-perts!

scrap
 

at least the beginning price for a weimer 20 is just 500 dollars.

best,
barry

Scrap?
 

Ok, I'll bite.... I have never owned a scrap and I know a few of you guys have forgot more about scraps then I will ever know, but I don't see it.

This card doesn't appear hand cut. And I only see a stain.
Lastly, I thought one of the 'rules' was that a scrap could not achieve a numerical grade...?

I await the scrap experts before reaching a conclusion, but for now, in my amateur opinion, this is very creative marketing.

I wonder if this card were soaked the "scrap" would disappear?

+1 on the Kool Aid. I'll be surprised if it gets a bid.

Some other nice cards in the auction though!

Attachment 180111this is graded sgc60

It's not a scrap?

It must have made it into a cigarette pack

Would any of the three T206's in Legendary Lot 54 be considered scrap?

moran and blackburne look like scraps to me...the other may be...I'm no expert.

Yes

All three

+1

i was contacted last night about Weimer...
 

Weimer is NOT A SCRAP.....REPEAT NOT SCRAP..............

it is a common card with a stain and a slight color shift...$20.00 card....

ALL SCRAP ARE HAND CUT AND NOT to receive a numerical grade....those ghost backs are all factory issued and a sheet escaped.....

contact me...I will always clarify:)

Although I don't consider myself an expert, just one who is knowledgeable enough through the experience of handling quite a few of the oddities.

This card MiGHT be Unique iN the way of the additional Printer's mark above the "Y" oN Mr. Jake Weimer's shirt...

Any one have knowledge if this is an oddity like the Marquad hypotrophy?

Not a Scrap... the stain is questionable though!? Weather it's Kool aid or ink?
Who can tell from a scan?

As Always...

The card was just pulled from Goodwin's auction.

that card was not a scrap.. it commands no premium.. it only shows how the error market is in its infancy... when a well known auction house lists a bad card like that as being scrap...

Hey there Jamie, Johnny & Anyone else that MiGHT Know,

I'm wondering, This card MiGHT be Unique iN the way of the additional Printer's mark That's above the "Y" oN Mr. Jake Weimer's shirt...

Have Ya Ever SeeN one like this before?

Just Curious...

Denny.....
 

i just went to chk for you , but the lot closed.......from my memory I saw nothing "significant"....but I might have missed....send another scan to my email...

Repeat....ALL PRINTER'S SCRAP CANNOT RECEIVE A NUMERICAL GRADE....all were hand cut from scrap sheets and will not receive a designation of factory cut....

hence, ALL BLANK BACKS CANNOT RECEIVE A NUMERICAL GRADE either.....they are all printers scraps that were hand cut from scrap sheets also...


I really wish all auction houses would consult me before listing a "potential" rarity or printers scrap(t206)....

my services are FREE ....for now;):D

Johnny... I didn't think to save the Scan!

Anyone else think to SAVE a Picture of the Scan of Jake Weimer's T206 Scrap :rolleyes: from Mr. Goodwin's Auction?

IF SO... CAN YOU PLEASE POST IT HERE(Lot #56)!!!

oR

Maybe Even Mr. Bill's Associate who visit's Here...
Can You Please Post it So We Could View the "Possible Oddity" Above Mr. Jake Weimer's "Y" oN His Shirt!?!?