Which would you pick
 

Which one world you keep for your set? Attachment 178300

hard to tell from that image - do you have a closer scan? also one for the backs?

Need a better photo and one of the back as well.

I actually like the '1' better for a multitude of reasons.

Allow me to help with a better angle to compare..The bottom pic is the PSA 1 .......(I deleted a few individual pics)...

It's hard to see why the 1 is deserving of that grade. From what I can see I prefer it to the 3.

I'd keep the 1. I don't care for the registration on the 3. Good luck!

I would also keep the 1.

I hate the rounded corners on that 3. How did that card ever grade a 3 anyway. :confused:

I like the three myself. I don't care for the caramel stains on the back of the 1 but I also like the sharpe corners of the 1 man tough one but I think the three is a nicer card.

The 1 looks alot nicer.

I like the 1 better as well..

Caramel stains don't really bother me (kinda adds character as to where it came from), but that registration on the 3 would drive me batty. Go with the 1.

I agree...the 3 is more appealing to me...the centering is better

Hard to tell why the "1" received a "1". Paper loss at lower left? If so, I think I would opt for the VG card.

Thanks guys I think that I will keep both for my set. Very hard to choose

I'd get the SGC encapsulated card (no, not because the other is in a PSA holder - the card in the SGC slab looks better to me).

Both in PSA holders

Is it just me or are the rounded corners a little too alike?

So you're basically just wasting everyone's time? ;)

No I wanted to sell one and keep one but varrying opinions have not convinced me on which one to keep.

It's a no brainer. Keep the one....it is a nicer card for the grade.

Tough choice IMO, but honestly, which one do you like? You have to have a slight preference. I believe you like the "1", but the slabs may be somewhat bothersome to you. Cover the slabs completely and ask yourself which one has better visual appeal...and don't lie to yourself! :p

Seriously, don't ask anyone their opinion, ask yourself...this way you'll be happy because it's your true decision and not what other's thought about it.

It would be interesting to post a thread like this but without the grading scores - just the cards.

Of course you could just switch the flips.:D:rolleyes:

Keep the one with the nicer corners; very nice visual appeal.

Occasionally... This has been done with great variety.

"Which one would you keep?"

Might even be a good search phrase to look back into the Archives...
Let uS know what Ya find!? ;)