Nothing against the dealer, but PSA 4 VG-EX?
 

That's a lot of paper loss/shriveling on the top of the front. Any chance some water got in once it was sealed by PSA?

Do you know how many cards they handle a day? This isbound to happen occasionally. (Sorry I could not locate my sarcasm font).

Holder
 

Looks funky. Probable reseal. A problem that has been addressed with the new holder but I know some of you would never give them any credit. No way that was graded as a 4.

I give them plenty of credit, they're excellent marketeers.

Water damage.

It looks more like a bug ate some vintage cardboard for lunch. Go figure... only a 4? :confused: Go PSA!!!!

I thought termite gnawing received 3s ?