Neilson's Chocolate Walter Johnson Type I PSA 10
 

What would you pay for this card? Looking at one. Just want a reference.

$50

Sorry PSA 1.

Any serious answers?

You went from a 10 to a 1. Let us get over the whiplash. Also, posting scans of the card would help in making a determination.

I am at a show I cant really get a pic.

OK. What are the flaws?

Nice front, paperloss on back which supposedly is typical. Paperloss is in an area with little to no writing.

Dealer is asking $425

LOL. Hilarious, Jeff.

I would think around half that would be about an auction price.....but who knows...

This. Ones should be around $200-225 or so I would think.

Tom C

I am shocked that a dealer at a show is asking 2x. LOL.

Just sold a real nice one with awesome eye appeal SGC 30 for $350. Hope that helps. It had awesome eye appeal.

Guys. Thanks so much. You just saved me money.

Correction mine was an SGC 20. I have scans of mine still if you want to see it. I got $350 in a private sale.

Jason

I would like to see it. Thanks

email address?

Oh, come on...we ALL want to see it.

Right guys?

For Sophomoric humor, all I have to say is; pull out your Johnson because everybody wants to see it.

David

(For this post, that may or may not be my real name).

I just knew I'd find the right time to use this:

Attachment 156809

Everyone enjoys a good Johnson pic now and then.

I was proud my my Johnson!

http://i135.photobucket.com/albums/q.../Card-0011.jpg
http://i135.photobucket.com/albums/q.../Card-0012.jpg

Nice - what's that mark down by his left foot?

Nice card

Here's the SGC 20
 

I was the buyer. I don't mind showing it, but I only have a camera phone snapshot, so it's not that great. I was happy to get it for $350 because I seriously don't understand why this isn't a 3 or 3.5. I have been buying WaJo's I like this year and can tell you, they are not going very cheap. I'm consistently having to pay higher than VCP pricing. Same with T206 Cobbs in 2-3 grade. However, I also look for cards that appear undergraded or strong for the grade.

Anyway, here it is:

http://i274.photobucket.com/albums/j...psfj8lwkvq.jpg

http://i274.photobucket.com/albums/j...pspcdkws9s.jpg

There is virtually no paper loss on the back - it has literally like one letter (the "y" in "player") that has a scuff on it. There really are no major flaws on the card. Faint hairline crease on the front that I can't even make out right now under my living room light. Way too harsh of a grade.

While I would not pay $425 on a PSA 1, I would agree that $200-$250 would be a good price, and if it is strong for the grade, up to $300.

Mark

JUst part of the image of his shoe. Not a flaw. I'm serious, all I can find on this card besides the teensy scuff on the back it a light wrinkle on the front, left to right, center of the card, that is just as invisible in person as it is in the scans we showed.

That is a really strong card. It is a prime example why any guide, online or written, is only a guide. More than ever cards are selling for what they should based upon eye appeal, not the technical grade. I would pay more than a 2 price for that one, all day long.....