1956 Mantle
 

Legit??? Hard to tell from pictures.

http://www.ebay.com/itm/330985923591...84.m1423.l2648

Well...certainly a poor 53...haha. I would say its a good looking card...a bit banged up, but the thickness and the rest look good to me. Not a bad price even in that shape. I come from the school ALL Mantles are cool...even the loved ones...

Hard to tell by the scan. You should be able to tell better in person.

Definitely hard to tell from the scans. I am always hesitant about stuff in those holders, but nothing about this screams fake from the pictures.

Probably too beat up to be fake but it does look a bit too white.....My vote would be "good" but not positive....

I don't like how white it looks....like a fake smile...