Menu w/CY Young Tris Speaker etc Good?
 

Were these good, the ballplayers that is?

http://www.ebay.com/itm/Toots-Shor-M...vip=true&rt=nc

Toots Shore menu
 

The BB players are no good IMO

Definitely not even close.
My guess would be that someone from the era of the menu just wrote in the names of the players to help ID them.
Just the sale price tells you it is not authentically signed, sometimes things slip through the cracks on the bay but IMHO this one would not have.

A nice piece trashed.

well. I still think its cool. They were obviously "identifying" marks and such. Any attempt at outright forgeries is not evident. Still, I still think it went too high, evenif the celebs are good.

Again tho, if some bid it up based on the baseball, their fault too for not knowing what they are evne looking at. its called. KNOWING WHAT SOMEONE"S SIGNATURE Looks like.