Jeter or henderson?
 

Looking at purchasing a 93 sp jeter bgs 8.5 or 80 Topps Henderson PSA 8...Which would you go with?

I would go with the post-war forum.

Great minds think alike. Done.

Jeter is a more valuable card that will only increase when he retires and gets inducted. Henderson is way past it's peak until he passes away, then within 24hrs of his death will be his peak.

The SP is an insanely sensitive card, which makes it quite pricey. You have more potential in reselling Jeter for a profit no doubt.

I'd go with a Jeter 8.5 over the Rickey.
But, I'd take a 9 Rickey over the Jeter.
Not sure how those 2 compare price wise, an 8.5 Jeter vs a 9 Rickey.

Edit: Guess there's roughly $175 difference in the Jeter 8.5 vs a Rickey 9. I'd definitely take the Jeter 8.5 over a Rickey 8 then.

I'd go with Jeter, but he is already priced based on an expectation of HOF induction.

Jeter
 

Jeter all the way. That cards tough and will only go up with value post retirement