Nodgrass: Is this legit?
 

http://www.ebay.com/itm/400434030469...84.m1438.l2649

He keeps on saying PSA will not grade it, so I asked him if he would guarentee authenticity if I sent it to SGC. He said he would not.

I was under the impression that on the Nodgrass variation there is a little bit of the S remaining, where on this one it looks like it has been completely removed.

i got into a verbal jerk with him.

its definitely not. he keeps saying the same thing. he is basically saying the same thing over and over again because he can't say it any other way without admitting he knows he is selling an altered card.


its similiar to the mcdonalds gameboard game piece scam. where they clip the game board piece from the game board. its not really the game piece. its the piece from the gameboard. you have to be very careful of the wording. he is claiming it won't grade because of one reason when in reality he is already aware that it won't grade, but the reason is 100 percent completely different....



Dear buyoldercards,

hi,its tough for me to tell. is there still a remenant of the S in the name
or is it completely missing?can you give more details on PSA? i find it hard
to believe that they will not warrant a card as altered if the card has been modified.
do you warrant that its unaltered if sent to another grading company such as SGC?kevin


Hi:
Please let me try explaining this ONE MORE TIME. PSA stopped grading these cards, NODGRASS, about two years ago at least.
If you try sending one in they will return it and give you a credit for a free grade on another card.
DO NOT BID ON THIS CARD IF YOU ARE THINKING ABOUT GETTING IT GRADED!!
The card can be found without the S as well as with only a portion of the right side of the S present.
Bid on this card as a "spot" filler in your collection until you can pick up an
older graded copy if you need a graded card. This card does not come up for sale very often.



hi,

listen. im not trying to yell or argue with you about this. im simply trying to get more information...and im being quite nice in my email i think....so please calm down.

they have always told me that they recognize anything in the standard catalogue and what you are telling me is contradictory to that. im just trying to understand where you got that information from and how you got it.

additionally.you didn't really address what i asked you at all. maybe you only got half way through my questions before you decided to respond. im not really sure:

i specifically am asking:
if i plan to send this card in...will it be returned altered or with a numeric grade. do you stand behind the fact that the card is unaltered like you emphatically stand behind your other cards?

kevin



Hi Kevin:
My capital letters are not me yelling at you and I am quite calm as I reply to this email.
Since I posted your email for everyone to see I wanted to make sure bidders understand the" WILL NOT GRADE" part.
I have made it perfectly clear in the auction and in my responses that this card will not get slabbed/graded.
I know this from past experience with PSA. The bottom line is you are only interested in this card if it will grade.
My auction states it will not. I am informing you for the second time that it will not grade.
Therefore, you should no longer have any interest in this card.
Robert



hi,
i only have three questions:
question 1: is the card a reprint? yes, no or you are not surequestion
2: is the card altered? yes, no or you are not sure.
question 3: is the card trimmed? does it measure the proper height and width for other t206's
side note: you edited/clipped part of my email and then only answered part of it.
kevin


The card is original/authentic/NOT A REPRINT. #2 - Since the card will not grade you must treat it as altered. #3 - The card is the correct size dimensionally. It has not been trimmed.

Strange,
A 0 feedback bidder??:rolleyes:

Kevin, this guy sounds like Bill Clinton answering questions about Monica Lewinsky. "You must treat it as altered" is as close as you will get to him acknowledging that it is altered, and that he is aware of the alteration.:rolleyes:

lmao, treat it as altered, like if someone erased the N :)

Since he says to treat the item as altered can he be reported?

Jake...
 

all nody's have part of the "s" ....you are absolutely right....buyer beware

Opinions on this other T206 he is selling?
http://www.ebay.com/itm/T206-Clancy-...item5d3bba201d

Personally the Nodgrass variation means zero to me. Interesting, but no big deal. No interest in obtaining one.

The bids are now approaching $200 and there appears to be shilling.... The joys of eBay.

Something just doesn't smell right with that card. Look, description, questions answered, all of the above. I think the best advice would be just to stay away?

Rich

the zero feed back person is way shady....

eh. may just bid on it...then return it. no harm in that right. thats what credit cards are for.

don't think there are any rules against bidding on something you don't really want right?

i mean. if i don't....then someone else will get scammed.

besides. then i can put it under the loupe like he suggests.

kevin

"Nodgrass: Is this legit?"

No.

that Nodgrass is no good. The seller trying to sell that card should tell you enough to not buy anything at all from them.

hopefully you can see the partial S in this pic. All legit Nodgrass should have a partial S visable.


http://photos.imageevent.com/cfc1909...e/IMAG0192.jpg


http://photos.imageevent.com/cfc1909.../Snodgrass.jpg

this is the card I bought from ebay somewhere around 2002 or 2003 in the PSA holder. I gave it to SGC in the original PSA holder

http://photos.imageevent.com/cfc1909...e/Nodgrass.jpg

insanity
 

insanity. closed above 400. i decided not to waste anyones time.

i really feel bad for whoever actually bought this.

if they don't mind the headache....then i guess so. he has a return policy on it.

4 hondo.....that is insane.

kevin

How soon do we see it relisted with a BIN of $4k without any mention of it being altered? :eek: