Question on Reprint - 1940 Play Ball Jackson
 

I checked "Search" and couldn't find anything on this:

A friend recently sent a 1940 Play Ball Joe Jackson to PSA. It was returned ungraded by PSA with no real reason as to why. I've seen the card and it looks good. Nonetheless, we agree that it is probably a reprint. What are the indicators that tell us a Play Ball is fake?
Thanks, John