Jackie Robinson and Sandy Koufax, real or not?
 

I would greatly appreciate opinions on both these autographs I am looking to buy.

help on the robinson
 

anyone have an opinion on the Robinson autograph, I am skeptical but I have seen one similar that passed psa ( big deal).

From what I can see on the Jackie, the a looks off, and the baseline poor on both first and last name. The last five or six Jackie's I had all had a much more open "a"

Jackie
 

Looks like the Jackie has now hit ebay...




http://www.ebay.com/itm/Jackie-Robin...item3f20f59283

I copied it off ebay to get an opinion, I myself did not like the a but I did see one on ebay that appeared to by a early one with a closed a. I don't think I will bid on this one though.

You might compare your potential Jackie with this. I got it from him at the first Martin Luther King East-West All Star Classic at Chavez Ravine. Had to cut through a section that separated us due to an over-protective usher at the top of his aisle.