Is this scan big enough...
 

To get y'all's opinions?

http://i236.photobucket.com/albums/f...T/Dimaggio.jpg

I know I don't like the Mantle and am not too keen on the other two either.

I think it's good.

Agree, think it's good.

Looks good to me

The Mantle and Williams hold well against examples on eBay. Not an expert on DiMaggio so I won't comment.

The DiMaggio is perfect.

Good or bad why would you pay good money when you cant see the full autograph?:confused:

The answer is twofold: 1. My mother paid money for this at a baseball card show in the late 80s as a gift for my father. it has been framed on the wall of his home office since. 2. The Williams auto shows up much better in person

I have long told my father that I think these are real, because I do and I have gotten a lot better at judging Mantle autos. I thought I would get other opinions here.

Wayne, I was just giving my thoughts not trying to put anyone down. I hate that photo because it is almost impossible on and 8x10 to sign it without some of the ink going into the black.:)

Sure, I understand and didnt think you were putting anybody down. Any opinion on the autos themselves?

I just posted a Mantle auto gotten with my own (er, his own) hand on the "Mantle Ball Help Please" thread. Check it out.

Why would you need an opinion on something you got in person?

I think he's offering me an authentic example to compare this against.

Thanks Paul, but I actually have several IP Mantles myself. And I think the one I've shown here is authentic, but I thought getting opinions could be informative.

Thanks for clearing that up for me Wayne.