100 Card Type Set - PSA or SGC
 

Let's try this again... if you were to assemble a pre-WW II Type Set, would you assemble it in PSA or SGC (sorry, raw is not an answer).

Let's try this with poll results only and no responses so we don't end up in a heated debate.

I guess I'm halfway there with half and half and this does not bother me at all, although some cards would look better in the other holder.

What would be interesting would be if people weighed in by listing a couple dozen issues with which holder they think makes them look best (ignore pricing concerns)--taking into account general look and how they are usually handled in the holder. For example, I would pick SGC over PSA for the Mayo Cut because PSA uses a baggy. PSA might be best for t207 because SGC makes the already dark card look even darker. And so on...take a shot.

I agree with GregMitch. Contrast between the card and holder is aesthetically pleasing, regardless of value.
--C.