Luke Appling Rookies
 

I would like to get a concensus of opinion on what everyone thinks Luke Appling's Rookie (notice I did not say Rookie Card) should be amongst the above three options

I voted for the Exhibit.

I think a true rookie card should be the first card that a player appears on, not just the first time he appears in a major set.

I voted for the Exhibit. 1931 came before those other years...

I've always kinda liked the Diamond Star card of his... maybe it should have been a poll choice. I'd have still voted for the Exhibit.