Sweet Caporal Pins -- Red or Black Backs?
 

What is the incidence of black backs compared to red? Clearly red is the minority but anyone have an idea how much of a minority?

<a href="http://www.flickr.com/photos/calvindog/4679197415/" title="1910 Sweet Caporal Pin P2 (Large Letters) by calvindog65, on Flickr"><img src="http://farm5.static.flickr.com/4064/4679197415_44159ca8af_b.jpg" width="1024" height="681" alt="1910 Sweet Caporal Pin P2 (Large Letters)" /></a>

<a href="http://www.flickr.com/photos/calvindog/4504999865/" title="1910 Sweet Caporal Pin P2 (Large Letters) by calvindog65, on Flickr"><img src="http://farm3.static.flickr.com/2787/4504999865_77c01f0609_o.jpg" width="1120" height="746" alt="1910 Sweet Caporal Pin P2 (Large Letters)" /></a>

Jeff,

Not sure what the ratio for red-black is or if there is even a premium for the red. There was a Cobb LL with red backing on e-bay not too long ago, did you pick that one up? It was raw, but in pretty nice shape. I put in a bid, but didn't chase too hard for it.

Mike

Jeff-
I do not have an answer to your questions but the thread linked below has a little bit of information. As I indicated in the thead linked below, this set (as well as many others) would probably benefit from a survey thread similar to Ted Z's threads regarding T206s.
Alan
http://www.net54baseball.com/showthr...&highlight=P2s

I'm resurrecting this ancient thread to see if there's any updated info on the prevalence of backs with the red lettering. There was a large-letter Cobb with the red text in the Clean Sweep auction, and all the Cobbs I'd seen to that point have the black text. Are all the red ones Factory 42 with the scroll, like this Cobb?

https://i.ibb.co/0X8ymtq/Cobb-P2-LL-PSA-5-Back.jpg

I don't know the answer but that Cobby is cool. I always think that someone could easily replace one of those though backs....as I have seen done before.

I can offer observations from my set. I'm about 82% through the Sweet Cap Pin set. Of the 127 that I have, 6 have red letters. Besides the red lettering, there's different color backing papers.

Out of my 127 pins:

1. 28 have pink backing paper with black print(22%)
2. 31 have blue backing paper with black print (24%)
3. 6 have white backing paper with red print (5%)
4. 60 have white backing paper with black print (47%)
5. 2 have no backing paper (2%)

I haven't chased different backing papers and I haven't noticed premiums attached to different backing papers. But if I assume my set is a random collection (though not a big sample size), the red print is far rarer than the others.