1895 N300 Mayo Wilbert Robinson POP Report
 

Greetings fellow collectors. I was wondering if anyone can give me a PSA pop report for the 1895 N300 Mayo Wilbert Robinson? It would be greatly appreciated.
Thank You

Mayo Robinson
 

There are only 4 graded by PSA. 3 of them are PSA 1 and 1 is a PSA Auth. Obviously a very tough card.

SGC shows 18 graded.

2 - A
1 - 10
2 - 30
5 - 40
4 - 50
4 - 60

BTW, do you ever think that PSA and SGC pop reports are missing cards that are graded? This might be more true of sets that aren't popular or are rare. For example, the 1935 Schutter Johnson "I'm Gonna Be..." set shows very few cards graded by SGC (and only 4 different cards). Yet the set registry for that set from RStuckemeyer shows more cards at grades that aren't on the pop report for SGC, and practically all cards from the set.

1895 N300 Mayo Wilbert Robinson POP Report
 

Greetings everyone. Many thanks for the replies to this question. Many more were graded by SGC then PSA. I wonder if this indicates that SGC is more popular then PSA when it comes to having 19th century cards graded?
Thanks much and Happy Collecting

I think you will find that SGC is more popular among vintage (pre wwii) collectors than is PSA..

FWIW: i have no preference...

1895 N300 Mayo Wilbert Robinson POP Report
 

Hi, anyone know why SGC is more popular then PSA for pre war graded cards? Maybe they have stricter guidelines then PSA? Is the card more valuable in SGC holder as opposed to PSA for pre war cards? An interestng discussion. I would be interested in the board consesus. I am sure that thread has been covered here before though. Also, I understand that this card is one of the more difficult N300 cards from the set. (W. Robinson) Do most agree on that?
Thanks

From what I've gathered from reading this board, it seems that SGC is more popular with prewar collectors, but PSA cards bring more cash at auction. It's kind of an oxymoron, but that's what I've read. I'm in the minority in that I collect PSA only.