For Sale: 1887 N172 Old Judge O'Day
 

For Sale is an 1887 N172 Hank O'Day. It is my only Old Judge and I am selling some cards off to buy some memorabilia. I know GAI isn't the authenticator of choice, but it is GAI graded 2, Good. The back is very clean, and you can see the front from the picture.
$125 Shipped

http://i623.photobucket.com/albums/t...dJudgeODay.jpg

Sold

Damn.

super card
 

should be in the hall of fame

O'Day? According to baseball-reference he's got a lifetime 73-110 record.

(Unless that was sarcasm and I missed it, which happens often hee hee)

Rob
:)

HOF for Umpiring. He also called the first world series!

Boston won BTW :)

oday
 

Steve, you are right. Not sure he will make it but he has a shot
t

Ditto.

http://photos.imageevent.com/kawika_...size/ODay1.jpg http://photos.imageevent.com/kawika_...size/ODay2.jpg

I think his chance came and went. Didn't something change regarding the Veteran's Committee?

I really tried to just not say anything here but I just can't help it... didn't anyone happen to notice that the card graded a "2" is trimmed at the bottom. I don't mean just a little trim. The words "Goodwin & Co, New York" are completely missing. Am I wrong here? Does anyone want to confirm or dispute this? Sorry, I'm not trying to start anything, I'm just bringing up a point - the grade is not correct (in my opinion).

Yes Fred, the card is trimmed.