Top 5 Rare T206 Southern Leaguers
 

First, I know everybody will be coming out of the woodwork and telling me to reference previous threads and that this has been discussed many times before. To them, just ignore this thread.

Below are my top-5 for rarest, hardest-to-find T206 Southern Leaguers. Which do you think should stay, go, or be replaced and by who? Thanks!!

In no particular order:

-Harry Bay
-Roy Ellam
-Dom Mullaney
-Arch Persons
-Ed Reagan

I would replace Ed Reagan with Ed Foster and then your list would be good. The only other "Top 5" that I might add would be Sid Smith.

I actually have Dom Mullaney at #6 on my list, so that is not bad.

it's funny that Bay-Nashville is on your list. I have recently gotten back into collecting my set and out of the approximately 600 T206's I have with duplicates - I only have 2 southern leaguers. and Bay is one of them.

While I have you - if you have any Southern Leaguers gd+ or better for trade for other t206's commons or HOFers - please let me know.

I think the top 9-10 SL'ers probably slip into a different order depending upon individual experience but some do seem a bit tougher than others. Foster seems tough right now, Persons at one point was toughest SL'er on Scot's list.

My list is a bit different. I have found Cranston, and Revelle and Shaughnessey to be difficult. Bay and Mullaney were never a problem to find for me or my brother. 2007 was when I could last afford to buy a Shaughnessey card. Foster might be pretty tough as I have only ever had 2 of his card.

Is Shaughnessey that tough or just overbid/overrated lately..?

Is the Old Mill back more common than Piedmont on the Soutern Leagueres? On certain cards, more Piedmonts seem to be available.

I would like to get back to scarcity, but I have found Piedmont-to-Old Mill Sl'ers to be about 60-40, favoring Piedmont backs.