thoughts....goodwin 1880s piece
 

thoughts on this? legitimate, and if so value? thanks everyone!

http://i1031.photobucket.com/albums/..._48_Goodwi.jpg

Looks like a real page of a Goodwin A35, but the signatures look like they were done in sharpie, invented in 1964, 23 years after Mickey Welch died.

Looks legitimate. Signatures obviously not real.

First, obviously signatures are bogus. Second, no hole on left. Can't make determination from a scan but I think there is a good chance that the whole piece is bad.

Is that some kind of joke? Looks like it was signed with a black fine tip sharpie. Every signature looks pristine, as if they were made yesterday...which they were.

The "signatures" definitely look suspect( looks like crayon if you ask me) but was not sure about the rest of the piece's legitimacy.

I agree - plus it doesn't look to be a perfect circle (look at the wavy bottom). I think the whole piece is bad...

I didn't see this in Coach's Commodes latest craptastic auction. What lot number was it? Only they would have a piece signed by AlL FOUR of those greats!!!:):):):)

I noticed the waviness also. Could be why there is no hole for the string - it has been trimmed out of it. Still could be authentic (not the sigs), but a pretty poor example.