Net54baseball.com Forums - Ohtani CARDS are Mostly UNDERVALUED
Net54baseball.com Forums

Net54baseball.com Forums (http://www.net54baseball.com/index.php)
-   Net54baseball Vintage (WWII & Older) Baseball Cards & New Member Introductions (http://www.net54baseball.com/forumdisplay.php?f=2)
-   -   Ohtani CARDS are Mostly UNDERVALUED (http://www.net54baseball.com/showthread.php?t=352423)

jayshum 06-01-2025 09:00 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Peter_Spaeth (Post 2519416)
Even if it's to the detriment of the team and organization?

You don't think going back on a verbal agreement would be to the detriment of the team and organization?

Peter_Spaeth 06-01-2025 09:03 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jayshum (Post 2519420)
You don't think going back on a verbal agreement would be to the detriment of the team and organization?

Not nearly as much as risking your franchise player who has already undergone two Tommy John surgeries, no. He wasn't even that great a pitcher when he got hurt, he had been much better the prior year. I forget where Fangraphs had him but it wasn't all that high.

jayshum 06-01-2025 09:15 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Peter_Spaeth (Post 2519421)
Not nearly as much as risking your franchise player who has already undergone two Tommy John surgeries, no. He wasn't even that great a pitcher when he got hurt, he had been much better the prior year. I forget where Fangraphs had him but it wasn't all that high.

He was 10-5 with a 3.14 ERA in 23 starts in 2023 for a WAR of 3.9 so not too shabby. I actually agree that they shouldn't risk having him pitch, but it's not like they didn't know he had already undergone 2 TJ surgeries when they signed him. However, if the part of the deal to get him to sign was that he wanted to pitch, unless they can convince him otherwise, they have to let him. Teams don't want other players to think that they're not sure if the Dodgers are as good as their word when considering signing with them.

Aquarian Sports Cards 06-01-2025 09:40 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Peter_Spaeth (Post 2519410)
So he not only makes a billion dollars, he gets to dictate to the ownership and management? :eek: It might piss him off to take him out in the fourth inning too, or to limit his starts. Gee that might not go over well nobody's going to want to go there any more.

If they agreed to it when they signed him they should live up to it. You're setting up strawmen.

Aquarian Sports Cards 06-01-2025 09:41 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Peter_Spaeth (Post 2519416)
Even if it's to the detriment of the team and organization?

I keep my word to the detriment of my company on a somewhat regular basis.

Peter_Spaeth 06-01-2025 09:42 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Aquarian Sports Cards (Post 2519427)
If they agreed to it when they signed him they should live up to it. You're setting up strawmen.

It's not really a straw man. What does it mean to "let him pitch"? Do you think the parties defined it? What if the team's idea of when and how to use him is completely different from Ohtani's? What if the team envisions using him in low-pressure mop up stints?

bk400 06-01-2025 09:56 PM

The Dodgers are already playing with house money when it comes to Ohtani. He's already a bargain at present value $461mm.

Why not let him pitch if that's what he and the global Dodgers / baseball fan base wants? If he blows out his elbow and is out for a year, the Dodgers can say they at least tried. If they don't let him pitch and force him into a DH role, it's very franchise value destroying on so many levels.

Lucas00 06-15-2025 03:54 AM

Just saw Ohtanis 250th homer.. Looked and sounded like a deep fly AT BEST. How he pulled a very outside pitch with such a "weak" swing on a curveball 384ft is unreal.

https://youtu.be/2FBhWdUU_BM

bk400 06-15-2025 03:59 AM

Yeah, I saw that also. He's a bad bad man, even when he's off. I think The Athletic recently surveyed MLB players and asked which player they wanted to watch the most. Ohtani won in a landslide.

jayshum 06-15-2025 09:40 PM

Ohtani is scheduled to be starting pitcher on Monday against the Padres.

Balticfox 06-16-2025 08:40 AM

"Ohtani CARDS are Mostly UNDERVALUED"

I fully disagree!

1. I share the opinion of most MLB players. Sure Ohtani is very good. But he's not 10x or 50x as good as the average player which his salary indicates.

2. His cards are correspondingly overvalued. They're all just pieces of cardboard like any other from the set. Shohei Ohtani and Joe Shlobatnik cards are fundamentally near identical. Why some collectors choose to chase/covet just certain cards from a set and drive their prices to nosebleed levels is beyond me.

:rolleyes:

Balticfox 06-16-2025 09:36 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Exhibitman (Post 2455690)
Wrong board, my dude. This is a pre-1945 board. Your topic belongs in the post-1980 section of the Postwar Cards area.

While we often disagree, here I'm in full agreement. Yet this thread remains in an entirely inappropriate forum.

:(

Balticfox 06-16-2025 09:44 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by BioCRN (Post 2455861)
Whether he's the best or not, if Ohtani isn't in your top-5 hitters in all of baseball anywhere on the planet I don't know what to say.

MVP caliber hitter. CY caliber pitcher. Unless one wants to pick on Ohtani's ability to pitch 200-ish IP as a pitcher, both stand strong.

Guy is about to hit 40+ homers for the 3rd time in 4 years. He's going to join the 40-40 club. He's recovering from Tommy John surgery while doing it. wtf...

3.01 ERA, 1.08 WHIP over 481.2ip

It's easy to ignore his pitching based on injury, but based on results when healthy it isn't.

His biggest knock is he doesn't play the field and if he did, it would most likely be below average.

Long story short...I've never seen anyone like him in my lifetime with skills this elevated and I'm not sure anyone else here has, either.

He's not a rare player, he's not a generational player, he's only being compared to Ruth because who else are you going to compare a guy with his skill set to that played in 1900+? He's a very unique player.

All very nice but entirely irrelevant. The question is about the pricing of his card. And even were I to concede the point that a player's card prices should reflect that player's relative performance on the field (which is a debateable assumption), Ohtani is not 10x or 100x better than the average Dodger. Ask any of his former teammates.

molenick 06-16-2025 10:14 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Balticfox (Post 2522075)
"Ohtani CARDS are Mostly UNDERVALUED"

2. His cards are correspondingly overvalued. They're all just pieces of cardboard like any other from the set. Shohei Ohtani and Joe Shlobatnik cards are fundamentally near identical. Why some collectors choose to chase/covet just certain cards from a set and drive their prices to nosebleed levels is beyond me.

:rolleyes:

I essentially agree with this, when you get right down to it, it makes no sense. Based on the raw material involved, almost all baseball cards have equal value, which is next to nothing.

But coveting certain cards is the basis of pricing for the entire hobby, not just Shohei Ohtani cards. Why does Babe Ruth cost more than Marv Throneberry? Why does T208 cost more than T207? Why does PSA 8 cost more than PSA 7? Why does the first card of a player cost more than the last card?

Hobby pricing is just supply and demand and right now there is high demand for Ohtani cards. Whether that demand will continue and thus maintain his card prices is unknown.

[By the way, don't stop too long to think about why we pay money for cardboard. If everyone does this, the entire hobby will collapse!]

Balticfox 06-16-2025 10:30 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by molenick (Post 2522113)
But coveting certain cards is the basis of pricing for the entire hobby, not just Shohei Ohtani cards. Why does Babe Ruth cost more than Marv Throneberry? Why does T208 cost more than T207? Why does PSA 8 cost more than PSA 7? Why does the first card of a player cost more than the last card?

I put the extreme range down to silliness. That though is because I'm not among the fortunate few for whom money is no object. I have to weigh the relative "merits" of any purchase.

Quote:

Originally Posted by molenick (Post 2522113)
Hobby pricing is just supply and demand and right now there is high demand for Ohtani cards. Whether that demand will continue and thus maintain his card prices is unknown.

[By the way, don't stop too long to think about why we pay money for cardboard. If everyone does this, the entire hobby will collapse!]

I long ago realized that my collecting is a compulsion, an addiction even. I keep telling myself that it's better (less pathetic) than being a smoker, alcoholic or drug addict but I may just be rationalizing and thus fooling myself.

:(

molenick 06-16-2025 01:45 PM

I know...every now and then I ask myself why I would rather have this card than the money I spend on it that could go towards literally anything else in the world *...and then I buy the card anyway.

And, yes, obviously we all know why certain cards cost a lot of money...it is the wide disparity in pricing that sometimes makes you go "woah".

* not "anything" but you get my drift

jboosted92 10-27-2025 10:35 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by BillyCoxDodgers3B (Post 2455761)
The hype machine needed to be turned way down for this guy. You just don't compare someone to Babe Ruth, plain and simple. The odds of living up to such expectations are practically nil. For me personally, all the hype turned me off from caring, but I don't follow modern baseball to begin with.

If the media had toned it down a few notches, far more people would be impressed by him. His stats are pretty nice. .667 PCT over 5 seasons? At this point, he's won exactly twice as many games as he's lost. When Babe Ruth is the bar you're expected to measure up to, you're basically left to twist in the wind if you can't prove you can walk on water.


ahem

icurnmedic 10-27-2025 12:14 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by molenick (Post 2522160)
I know...every now and then I ask myself why I would rather have this card than the money I spend on it that could go towards literally anything else in the world *...and then I buy the card anyway.

This is me exactly. Sometimes I wonder what makes my coveting of cards ticker tick?
Is it nostalgia? I can remember times when I could not have thought to own some of the cards I have today.
I think at the end of the day for me, I still like looking at them although I will not own them forever. Enjoy them while you can.

All cardboard is essentially worthless. But heck we buy it anyway.

Balticfox 10-27-2025 12:29 PM

I'd just like to add that I'm not disparaging Shohei Ohtani as a player. How many decades has it been since an effective pitcher could hit as well as Ohtani? More than a century perhaps?

:)

But what are the rarest Ohtani cards? Are any XX/10 rare?

:confused:

Peter_Spaeth 10-27-2025 01:02 PM

The Topps, Chrome, and Update cards and the more common variations (e.g. Refractors which have long since ceased to be anything special) seem to have been produced in huge quantities, but keep rising in price especially in PSA 10. What I find interesting, given that he obviously has become much more an elite hitter than elite pitcher, is that the cards showing him as a pitcher seem just as popular if not more so. Finally, with all the hoopla about him being a true two way player as a rookie, why are there so few RCs depicting him in both poses? You would think that would have been a natural choice for Topps etc.

packs 10-27-2025 01:07 PM

He has hitting and pitching variations of his flagship Topps rookies with one being rarer than the other depending on the set.

Peter_Spaeth 10-27-2025 01:53 PM

1 Attachment(s)
There may be others but I found only this one with both poses on one card.

Yoda 10-27-2025 02:21 PM

Peter, that is one great baseball card and captures the essence of Otani as a 2 way player. Not yours by any chance?

bk400 10-27-2025 06:17 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Peter_Spaeth (Post 2546634)
The Topps, Chrome, and Update cards and the more common variations (e.g. Refractors which have long since ceased to be anything special) seem to have been produced in huge quantities, but keep rising in price especially in PSA 10. What I find interesting, given that he obviously has become much more an elite hitter than elite pitcher, is that the cards showing him as a pitcher seem just as popular if not more so. Finally, with all the hoopla about him being a true two way player as a rookie, why are there so few RCs depicting him in both poses? You would think that would have been a natural choice for Topps etc.

His first card that depicts him both hitting and pitching is the 2013 Calbee D-07. It's also his first Calbee card and one of his earlier rookie cards from Japan.

https://japanesebaseballcards.blogsp...ology.html?m=1

bcbgcbrcb 10-27-2025 06:46 PM

In today’s game, 40/40 is barely meaningful. About 50% of MLB does 20/20. Pre-steroids, maybe one or two players a season did that and 30/30 was nearly unheard of outside a scant few such as Bonds/Bonds, etc. All the Judge 60 HR seasons are a joke and cannot be compared to historic greats when 20-30 players a season hit 30+ homers today.

Today’s players make enough money to pay personal trainers, dieticians, etc. 24 hours a day, 365 days a year to keep them in optimal playing condition. In Honus Wagner’s day, he had to be some rich person’s personal trainer during the off-season just to make enough money to survive on. My how times have changed, huh? Think about that before idolizing today’s athletes and the gaudy numbers they put up.

Casey2296 10-27-2025 06:46 PM

1 Attachment(s)
Quote:

Originally Posted by bk400 (Post 2546686)
His first card that depicts him both hitting and pitching is the 2013 Calbee D-07. It's also his first Calbee card and one of his earlier rookie cards from Japan.

https://japanesebaseballcards.blogsp...ology.html?m=1

-
Nice list. I only own a couple of Ohtani cards (for now), but I love the aesthetic appeal of this 2013 card I recently picked up.
-

theshowandme 10-27-2025 07:58 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by bcbgcbrcb (Post 2546694)
In today’s game, 40/40 is barely meaningful. About 50% of MLB does 20/20. Pre-steroids, maybe one or two players a season did that and 30/30 was nearly unheard of outside a scant few such as Bonds/Bonds, etc. All the Judge 60 HR seasons are a joke and cannot be compared to historic greats when 20-30 players a season hit 30+ homers today.

Today’s players make enough money to pay personal trainers, dieticians, etc. 24 hours a day, 365 days a year to keep them in optimal playing condition. In Honus Wagner’s day, he had to be some rich person’s personal trainer during the off-season just to make enough money to survive on. My how times have changed, huh? Think about that before idolizing today’s athletes and the gaudy numbers they put up.

If you were pumped full of steroids, given the dietitian and strength coaches, would you hit 60 homers in the bigs?

Exhibitman 10-27-2025 09:20 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by theshowandme (Post 2546719)
If you were pumped full of steroids, given the dietitian and strength coaches, would you hit 60 homers in the bigs?

Nope. Not even one. The hand-eye coordination to play ball is a genetic legacy and is beyond rare. About 10,000 men have played MLB. Only a few hundred well enough to last 10+ seasons and be good enough to get into the HOF. Same is true of most sports' elite performers. I knew a fellow who was a pretty good amateur boxer until he got into a local Golden Gloves and got destroyed by a buzzsaw named "Hagler."

As for Ohtani cards, they aren't undervalued even now. They trade so regularly and consistently, and are tracked on multiple indices that are real time reporting on sales, that they are never undervalued. Some of his cards, like some of any superstar's cards, may be better investments than others for future appreciation. Different question, really.

doug.goodman 10-27-2025 09:59 PM

They are plunging in value tonight

Balticfox 10-27-2025 10:24 PM

Ohtani is carrying the Dodgers!

:eek:

bcbgcbrcb 10-27-2025 10:57 PM

Ruth outhomered every TEAM in the American League TWICE! How many teams has Judge or Ohtani outhomered in their entire careers? ZERO!

Nuff said.

hammertime 10-27-2025 11:19 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Peter_Spaeth (Post 2546644)
There may be others but I found only this one with both poses on one card.

There's this one as well.
https://d1w8cc2yygc27j.cloudfront.ne...6735431736.jpg

hammertime 10-27-2025 11:25 PM

Here's another one from Japan.
https://d1htnxwo4o0jhw.cloudfront.ne...mUZ0vYNHFw.jpg

theshowandme 10-29-2025 06:25 AM

4-4 with 2 homers, 2 doubles, and 5 walks in a World Series game

https://media1.giphy.com/media/v1.Y2...wE3P/giphy.gif

Balticfox 10-29-2025 07:51 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by MLB
No player had ever reached base more than six times in a postseason game -- let alone a World Series game -- before Ohtani reached NINE times in an 18-inning marathon against the Blue Jays.

:eek:

Peter_Spaeth 10-30-2025 11:55 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by theshowandme (Post 2546856)
4-4 with 2 homers, 2 doubles, and 5 walks in a World Series game

https://media1.giphy.com/media/v1.Y2...wE3P/giphy.gif

If he goes hitless for a third straight game, he may be that kind of goat temporarily.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 03:03 PM.