Now that I have finished reading..

I agree with Leon, they are only guilty of small scans.

If I am buying a group of cards that are in PSA/SGC 1 (I used to buy bulk t206 cards in low grade back in the day). I generally expect every single card to be mangled and I bid accordingly.

By SGC's grading criteria, a "1" designation is in "poor" condition. You received cards that were in poor condition. You shouldn't have expected anything better.

On a side note, if this happened to me and it legitimately upset me I would have asked for a $50 refund, not $260. $260 seems like you are trying to pull a fast one on them. The cards aren't worth $260 less because they are a low end 1 instead of a high end 1. They are worth virtually the same.

Why did you expect they would offer you the buyers AND sellers premium back?

The scanner doesn't work on the new computer. I need to move it over to another computer and get this done. Sorry for being a flake about this.

I didn't "expect" anything, which is good, because I received nothing. I asked for them to take the lot back, but I would have at least grudgingly "settled" for them refunding my buyer's premium.

And your assertion that "They are worth virtually the same" is just silliness. I have two people on this board who made offers on the Alexanders. Should I anonymously contact them back and see if they agree with you?

What was the conclusion to this exciting thread?
 

Inquiring Minds Wants to Know

I was reminded of this thread by the Dean's Card thread

we're still waiting for scans, due by noon :)