Net54baseball.com Forums

Net54baseball.com Forums (http://www.net54baseball.com/index.php)
-   Net54baseball Vintage (WWII & Older) Baseball Cards & New Member Introductions (http://www.net54baseball.com/forumdisplay.php?f=2)
-   -   Baseball Is Dying (http://www.net54baseball.com/showthread.php?t=317835)

Hankphenom 04-15-2022 07:25 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by D. Bergin (Post 2215723)
There's been untold numbers of studies done on the effectiveness of starting pitchers in the early, the middle, and the late innings, and outside of a few anecdotal outliers it's pretty cut and dry. As far as the "Old-Timers", it was a completely different game, with different ballparks, equipment, circumstances, and strategies. You may not like present day strategy, but they wouldn't do it if it didn't work.

Here's the question I would like answered, and it shouldn't take much to come with the answer, but I didn't when I googled it: Since the advent of the short starters and multiple relief pitchers, are fewer runs being scored in the later innings?

jingram058 04-16-2022 02:40 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by sreader3 (Post 2215727)
"Metrics-driven": I love it. I am a stats geek.

"Corporate": Not sure what this means. Most private enterprise these days involves corporations. Hell, I was a one-person corporation for 18 years while I was practicing law. Perhaps you would prefer that baseball be run by the federal government? They do such a great job! I can only imagine the new regs.

"Robotic": Again, not sure what this means. Last time I checked, there were no robots on the MLB diamond. Just flesh and bones fielders, batters, umps and coaches with all of their human foibles.

"Bernie Madoff": I never rooted for Bernie Madoff. The guy made-up stats and defrauded his clients of hundreds of millions of dollars. I haven't seen that in baseball. In baseball, you can watch the game and track the stats. No fraud so far as I can tell. Just big business, big contracts, big money--which you perhaps don't like.

Baseball is rather like our country. Fundamentally sound and flawed; worth preserving and improving.

For all your puffed-up enthusiasm, baseball is still undeniably dying.

Snapolit1 04-16-2022 05:40 AM

As I sat in the Citifield parking lot yesterday for an hour after the game ended waiting to move my car a few more inches I stayed calm by just repeated to my self over and over “baseball is dying ….. baseball is dying ….. baseball is dying”.

jingram058 04-16-2022 07:42 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Snapolit1 (Post 2215815)
As I sat in the Citifield parking lot yesterday for an hour after the game ended waiting to move my car a few more inches I stayed calm by just repeated to my self over and over “baseball is dying ….. baseball is dying ….. baseball is dying”.

How much was your ticket(s)? How much did you pay to park? Did you purchase beer, soda, peanuts, hot dogs, or any of that? Was it a sellout on a Friday night? How long did the game last? Was it fun? Finally, I haven't checked, did the Mets win?

Snapolit1 04-23-2022 07:50 AM

Even with the disaster that is the Oakland As, baseball attendance in April up meaningfully from 2019 levels, last full season before covid.

Baseball is dying . . .baseball is dying. . . .baseball is dying . . . .

jingram058 04-23-2022 08:03 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Snapolit1 (Post 2217916)
Even with the disaster that is the Oakland As, baseball attendance in April up meaningfully from 2019 levels, last full season before covid.

Baseball is dying . . .baseball is dying. . . .baseball is dying . . . .

Keep on drinking that Kool Aid, brother!

John1941 04-23-2022 09:16 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jingram058 (Post 2217919)
Keep on drinking that Kool Aid, brother!

You seem overly invested in this, to be honest. I think baseball could be a lot better, but it's not dying, at least not yet.

GeoPoto 04-23-2022 09:30 AM

Your apparent dissatisfaction with the expense and crowds involved in attending the games, would appear inconsistent with your premise that the game is dying. Kinda like "Nobody goes there anymore, it's too crowded!" Unless you are making a long-run prediction.

Quote:

Originally Posted by jingram058 (Post 2215838)
How much was your ticket(s)? How much did you pay to park? Did you purchase beer, soda, peanuts, hot dogs, or any of that? Was it a sellout on a Friday night?


jingram058 04-23-2022 09:44 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by John1941 (Post 2217936)
You seem overly invested in this, to be honest. I think baseball could be a lot better, but it's not dying, at least not yet.

I am no way invested. But to say there is nothing wrong or imply everything is wonderful I just do not understand. The OP was not written by me, and I have read many other similar viewpoints. Of course I understand MLB isn't going to talk about any sort of decline; neither are those who make their living talking about it. My grandfather, dad, and I used to attend, watch on TV and listen on radio to countless games. I don't do that anymore. There are many reasons why. That's just me. No one I know, other than my overly positive wife, does to any degree either. Baseball didn't change that much, relatively speaking, over the decades. But in the last 20 or 25 years it sure has. And to just about everyone I know, and quite a few people I read, the changes compared with all the various outlets available to entertain with the advent of the internet and smartphones, just aren't good. At first I thought perhaps it was just me. That is not the case.

Eric72 10-03-2022 09:37 PM

The quote below is from a post I made in April. My passion for the game of baseball is as strong as ever. My beloved Phillies just clinched their first playoff berth since 2011. They went into the game with a Magic Number of 1 and took care of business. They got a home run on the very first pitch of the game. As it turned out, that was all they would need, as they shut out the Astros, 3-0.

Can the Phillies win the World Series? Perhaps not; however, baseball is often all about the thrill of possibility. They're in the playoffs. Starting Friday, a championship will be a mere thirteen wins away. It's October and anything is possible.

Man, I love this game.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Eric72 (Post 2214423)
For a sport that’s supposedly dying, it sure was lively this evening; at least from where I sit.

While getting some work done on the computer tonight, I listened to the Phillies game on the radio. For the majority of the game, it was a one-sided affair. Three first-inning runs and a lone marker for insurance had the Mets comfortably in control. However, the Phils broke out with five runs in the eighth and made the game suddenly theirs for the taking. In the ninth, they shut down New York with a 1-2-3 inning for a win which seemed improbable moments before.

I’ve always loved baseball. Tonight was the type of game that keeps me coming back for more.


Orioles1954 10-04-2022 05:32 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Eric72 (Post 2269841)
The quote below is from a post I made in April. My passion for the game of baseball is as strong as ever. My beloved Phillies just clinched their first playoff berth since 2011. They went into the game with a Magic Number of 1 and took care of business. They got a home run on the very first pitch of the game. As it turned out, that was all they would need, as they shut out the Astros, 3-0.

Can the Phillies win the World Series? Perhaps not; however, baseball is often all about the thrill of possibility. They're in the playoffs. Starting Friday, a championship will be a mere thirteen wins away. It's October and anything is possible.

Man, I love this game.


My 2022 Baltimore Orioles also pulled off a miracle of sorts. They became the first team since 1900 to lose 110+ games the previous season then to have a winning season the next and were actually in playoff contention until last week. With a young core of talent, the #2 farm system in baseball and only $20 million committed to payroll next year, the future is so so so bright in Charm City!

BCauley 10-04-2022 05:40 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Orioles1954 (Post 2269879)
My 2022 Baltimore Orioles also pulled off a miracle of sorts. They became the first team since 1900 to lose 110+ games the previous season then to have a winning season the next and were actually in playoff contention until last week. With a young core of talent, the #2 farm system in baseball and only $20 million committed to payroll next year, the future is so so so bright in Charm City!

As my wife is an Orioles fan (I'm a Red Sox fan), we have the majority of Orioles games on the television each year. I will say that this year's Orioles team has been, by far, one of the most fun teams I've ever watched play.

scotgreb 10-04-2022 10:16 AM

My 2022 perspective on the overall health of baseball . . .

The LLWS was awesome (as usual) -- regionally expanded bracket -- great viewership and attendance.

I attended several high school playoff games. Attendance was impressive. Full venues everywhere I went.

Attended my first CWS regional. Expanded seating at the venue essentially sold out every day. Tickets were bringing premiums.

Attendance weak at my local AA affiliate (only attended one game this year) but late season.

Saw my beloved Bucs a few times at PNC. Experience was as great as ever and attendance was surprisingly strong given their late season standing.

mr2686 10-04-2022 10:39 AM

I've pretty much stopped going to MLB games in person since they've pretty much priced me out of going (I could, but would have less money towards any of my hobbies). I should be able to watch several games on my big screen tv, but my cable provider has done away with the MLB channel and there are very few games that they put on the tele...and when they do they're teams I don't care about. With all that said, I will be glued to the TV starting Friday when the wildcard games start.

ullmandds 10-04-2022 11:25 AM

baseball is dying...just like the rest of us are dying...a slow death!

Kzoo 10-04-2022 11:50 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ullmandds (Post 2269968)
baseball is dying...just like the rest of us are dying...a slow death!

LOL.....maybe if you lived near Detroit, as it felt like that being a Tiger fan this year. Now we have a new GM and we'll get 'em next year.....or maybe the year after that.:rolleyes:

67airborne 10-04-2022 01:40 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Kzoo (Post 2269976)
LOL.....maybe if you lived near Detroit, as it felt like that being a Tiger fan this year. Now we have a new GM and we'll get 'em next year.....or maybe the year after that.:rolleyes:


Matt
We will need to make it through the lions season before that can happen,
so a slow death is still a possibility. Lol

Ray Van 10-04-2022 02:42 PM

I've observed an interesting demographic shift in Toronto over the last few years. More and more young people are going to games, making it a social experience for groups of friends. 10 years ago the average age of attendee was 50+ (or so it seemed), but lately it's been much younger. Lots of potential factors causing this but definitely the state of the game is healthy up north. Having a playoff team doesn't hurt, as many younger people are bandwagon jumpers or just want to post their experience on social media.

CurtisFlood 10-04-2022 03:06 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Rich Klein (Post 2212863)
The real issue is lack of accessibility to average people.

If you have cable (I know many people have switched to streaming but cable is still the major factor) and my situation is not unique

We are still on Frontier and frankly if a family friend of my wife's was not able to put us on top of any customer service needs. we'd be gone so fast it would like as Quick Draw McGraw was in slow motion.

1) Fox Sports Sold Fox Southwest to Sinclair who renamed it Bally's. Now when the network was Fox many carriers did not want to upset Fox in any way. Sinclair asked the carriers for a lot more money and Frontier said no way. This affects me from watching almost any local DFW sport

2) This one I get a bit more on a business level. on July 1, 2020 during the pandemic and before baseball announced they would have a truncated 2020 season the MLB Network was gone. Now this one I get on the business level since there was no guarantee baseball would even be played in 2020. It's not come back to Frontier since then

3) Not related to Frontier but one reason I was happy to have a Sirius/XM sub was the baseball package was part of what I paid. Last year if we wanted to have baseball on Sirius/XM there was an extra charge.

4) I just read some Sunday games are going tp be streamed and here is an article with more details

https://www.engadget.com/mlb-latest-...215545375.html

5) One key reason the NFL is even bigger than ever is they have not forsaken the free TV (available on Local stations) broadcasts. Being a baseball fan is getting to be well nigh impossible in today's world and you want to make it easier to see games, not harder.

Regards
Rich

You are right Rich. They made it tough to figure out where the playoff games were being shown years ago, and change it around from one cable channel to another. I dislike football and basketball with a purple passion and won't waste any of my time watching those sports no matter how easy they are to find.

SteveWhite 10-04-2022 07:54 PM

Baseball is Dying
 
Just watched my Reds win against the Cubs. Can't believe the season only has one game to go. The Reds have to win, or they lose 100 games. Go Reds!

jamest206 10-05-2022 09:05 AM

I will go to a game at Coors Field every day of the week vs an NBA game. The disgrace of a “National Anthem” on tv during Covid, explaining to my wife (who was a veteran as a Marine AND Army, Kosovo conflict) that we will never watch this, and the audacity of doing something like that with no in person crowd.

Met my wife three years ago. Took her to opening weekend of Rockies/Dodgers and she fell in love. Going to a game vs watching on television are two different animals. She loved being at the game, and I made sure we sat 10 rows back, dead center behind home plate. They also honor the veterans during the game. Sure, the cost is up there, but not nearly as close as sitting at the top of Mile High in January for a meaningless game. I can go on and on about how television can make something look so different in person vs football. QB’s so inaccurate, the standards are different.

Everything is dying, they say. Baseball changes with the time, and we are coming out of two years with Covid, and the cost of everything going up sky high once things opened up this year. I worked in printing during my 20’s, and that industry on big Heidelbergs is dead, along with skewed newspapers, gas powered cars (they say), and so on.

Sure, the current commissioner is a hypocrite, and not well liked. I expect the game to look a little different next year, but not too much. I recommend watching Ken Burns original Baseball documentary from time to time. It never gets old, and is a friendly reminder of the way things were, are, and will be.

philo98 10-05-2022 09:14 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by scotgreb (Post 2269941)
My 2022 perspective on the overall health of baseball . . .

The LLWS was awesome (as usual) -- regionally expanded bracket -- great viewership and attendance.

I attended several high school playoff games. Attendance was impressive. Full venues everywhere I went.

Attended my first CWS regional. Expanded seating at the venue essentially sold out every day. Tickets were bringing premiums.

Attendance weak at my local AA affiliate (only attended one game this year) but late season.

Saw my beloved Bucs a few times at PNC. Experience was as great as ever and attendance was surprisingly strong given their late season standing.

Im a season ticket holder for the Pirates and what Ive found this 2nd half of the year is attendance is strong on Firework or Bobblehead night, but the other games, paid attendance is around 8K to 13K or so, take away the Yankee and Philly series. The actual people that show up compared to paid attendance is anywhere from 50-80%. Some games, there may have only been 1-2K in the stands and the number of foul balls I have got is well over 15 which rarely ever happens. Im not a Pirate fan per se, I just live in Pittsburgh for the time being and I prefer a poor team to get ticket prices cheap and attendance down, but what Im seeing is a fan base that is sick and tired of how the team has been managed. In 2032, it wouldnt surprise me if the Pirates left the city, unless things change soon.

BCauley 10-05-2022 10:02 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by philo98 (Post 2270308)
Im not a Pirate fan per se, I just live in Pittsburgh for the time being and I prefer a poor team to get ticket prices cheap and attendance down, but what Im seeing is a fan base that is sick and tired of how the team has been managed. In 2032, it wouldnt surprise me if the Pirates left the city, unless things change soon.

One of my good friends is the grandson of Danny Murtaugh. Actually has his last game used jersey framed and on his living room wall.

I'd say about once a year he and his mother, Danny's daughter, go up to Pittsburgh for some sort of celebration of the Pittsburgh old timers. This year, they were up there for the inaugural induction of the Pirates HoF though I can't believe it's taken this long to do that for a team with so much history.

Back on track, my friend was telling me how so many of even the former players and family members are sick and tired of this owner and what he has done to the organization. It would do wonders for him to sell to someone who cares about the actual product on the field. My friend's mother wouldn't even talk to him during the ceremony and follow up gatherings that were held.

LEHR 10-05-2022 03:10 PM

Baseball is dying?

While I didn't make it out to a major league park this year I went to 10 Salt Lake Bees (AAA Angels affiliate) games and had a great time every game.
If the games dying you could have fooled me.

BobbyStrawberry 10-05-2022 04:03 PM

Baseball will continue to thrive despite Manfred's attempts to kill it! :)

perezfan 10-05-2022 04:28 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by BobbyStrawberry (Post 2270494)
Baseball will continue to thrive despite Manfred's attempts to kill it! :)

+1

egri 10-05-2022 04:49 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by BobbyStrawberry (Post 2270494)
Baseball will continue to thrive despite Manfred's attempts to kill it! :)

I never thought we would have a worse commissioner than Bud Selig, but Rob Manfred has proved me wrong. For all his faults, Selig loved the game.

drmondobueno 10-05-2022 05:04 PM

Baseball is dying....
 
I live 270 miles from the closest major league park, Dodger Stadium. If MLB moves to Las Vegas I will be around 260 miles.

The last professional game I watched in person? The Reno Aces in 2016, about 185 miles from home.

I watch an average of three games a day., and with the “cable” ageeements of the Dodgers and Angels, I watch 40 times as many Yankee and Pirate games as I do the “local” Socal teams.

At my age and with mobility issues, money is just not a primary reason to attend. I have never enjoyed the mess of getting to a game in Southern California.
To be honest I’d rather watch my boys play in their high-end beer leagues than burn time getting to and from a congested overpriced hostile bad beer sometimes dangerous park.

Our local high school took out the baseball diamond to put in a dog park. And that’s because attendance at the school is half what it was ten years ago. But there are still little league teams playing everywhere.

Seems the OP may be getting caught up in pride of ownership of an opinion based on whatever seems an appropriate basis to confirm a bias.

Just watched the Yankees end their regular season. And Trout hit number 40. Cool as hell. I am ready for the playoffs and hockey season.

Just sayin’.

Peace out, and Go Kings Go (lol).

jamest206 10-06-2022 08:36 PM

Eventually we will all be old, and retirement will be spent watching a lot of baseball on television. The options are much better now, and boy would my grandma from Depression era Arkansas be jealous of the options now.

Salaries for baseball, an entire roster is how much a year? Granted there is the minor league system, but you have stadiums half to larger than NFL stadiums. Tickets for Rockies games are pretty cheap, the team always sucks or is sub par, but that stadium, built as a monument to the game when I was a kid never gets old going to. No bad seats, super cheap tickets, like any stadium. You only need X amount sellouts and concessions to match an NFL team who gets 8? Home games plus preseason.

It isn’t going anywhere, and looking forward to what the new era looks like next year!

richtree 10-07-2022 01:12 PM

I think baseball will hit the wall at some point.

There are so many things that baseball players and the culture of baseball do, that really are not necessary.

I always thought it would fall apart, but it was an opportunity to revive in a newer way that can last into the future.

Some thoughts I had after playing baseball in college and not really watching too often are:

1. Make all stadiums have retractable domes
2. Standardize the work week 5 games a week (all teams play on the same days) same amount of games in a month, etc... (this makes new records too)
3. Make fantasy sports friendly (the above will help it)
4. This one I am debating --- make a speed clock that if the teams are tied after 9 innings, the "faster" team wins
5. Let the teams use technology for signs (pitches, stealing, etc.) like a Bluetooth ear piece so there isn't all this looking at the 3rd base coach or stealing of signs
6. Shorten the season but allow ALL THE TEAMS INTO A GIANT PLAYOFF -- make the division winners get multiple byes, and much harder for the last team to get in, but all those games in August of 4place teams vs. 5th place teams mean nothing...



idk.....but me, personally, all the stats mean nothing --- lets have fun and make a new beginning......

*also that makes the historical greats more mythical

Tabe 10-08-2022 01:10 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by richtree (Post 2271149)
5. Let the teams use technology for signs (pitches, stealing, etc.) like a Bluetooth ear piece so there isn't all this looking at the 3rd base coach or stealing of signs

They already have this for pitchers.

Steve D 10-08-2022 02:49 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Aquarian Sports Cards (Post 2215007)
If you don't allow Clayton Kershaw to try and finish what was on pace to be possibly the greatest game ever pitched with only 80 pitches thrown through 7 innings, maybe baseball deserves to die...

Quote:

Originally Posted by Steve D (Post 2215018)
I Completely agree.

The reason I have always loved watching pitchers like Nolan Ryan, Steve Carlton, Roger Clemens, Randy Johnson, Max Scherzer, Justin Verlander, Clayton Kershaw.......... is that every time they took the mound, they had a chance to make History!; to elevate that particular game to immortality, instead of it being just another game to slog through.

Managers/Bean Counters have taken excitement, the chance to see something truly special, away from everyone; They've made every game basically the same; unmemorable; just another boring page in the book of a season.

Steve


Three times in Justin Verlander's last six starts, Dusty Baker pulled him with no-hitters in progress:

- Aug 23 - 6 innings, 91 pitches, 10 Ks, 0 walks. Only baserunner he allowed was on a 3rd strike-passed ball.

- Sep 16 - 5 innings, 79 pitches, 9 Ks, 1 walk.

- Oct 4 - 5 innings, 77 pitches, 10 Ks. Only baserunner allowed was on a walk leading off the 5th inning.

Also on Sep 19th, Buck Showalter pulled Max Scherzer after six innings, having thrown only 68 pitches. He had 9 K's, and was pitching a PERFECT GAME!!!!!

Steve

1952boyntoncollector 10-08-2022 03:18 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by richtree (Post 2271149)
I think baseball will hit the wall at some point.

There are so many things that baseball players and the culture of baseball do, that really are not necessary.

I always thought it would fall apart, but it was an opportunity to revive in a newer way that can last into the future.

Some thoughts I had after playing baseball in college and not really watching too often are:

1. Make all stadiums have retractable domes
2. Standardize the work week 5 games a week (all teams play on the same days) same amount of games in a month, etc... (this makes new records too)
3. Make fantasy sports friendly (the above will help it)
4. This one I am debating --- make a speed clock that if the teams are tied after 9 innings, the "faster" team wins
5. Let the teams use technology for signs (pitches, stealing, etc.) like a Bluetooth ear piece so there isn't all this looking at the 3rd base coach or stealing of signs
6. Shorten the season but allow ALL THE TEAMS INTO A GIANT PLAYOFF -- make the division winners get multiple byes, and much harder for the last team to get in, but all those games in August of 4place teams vs. 5th place teams mean nothing...



idk.....but me, personally, all the stats mean nothing --- lets have fun and make a new beginning......

*also that makes the historical greats more mythical

I always thought hitting contest to decide extra innings would be a good idea. or you get to pick your hitter and other team pitcher and whoever can hit the ball the farthest on 3 pitches.....if nobody gets a hit but one guy took a ball while the other one had 3 fouls/strikes then then the one that took at least one ball wins

could always do just a traditional home run hitting contest as well...

Hankphenom 10-08-2022 05:09 PM

The Washington Nationals are about to be sold, rumors are in the $2 billion range. They paid MLB $400 million for the franchise in 2006.

1952boyntoncollector 10-08-2022 06:15 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Hankphenom (Post 2271537)
The Washington Nationals are about to be sold, rumors are in the $2 billion range. They paid MLB $400 million for the franchise in 2006.

right the real value is in the franchise value, but there are billionares that love the idea of owning a team and dont care if 'overpaying' heck look whats going on with Twitter..

Tabe 10-08-2022 07:46 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Steve D (Post 2271299)

Also on Sep 19th, Buck Showalter pulled Max Scherzer after six innings, having thrown only 68 pitches. He had 9 K's, and was pitching a PERFECT GAME!!!!!

He was also making his first start in 16 days, coming back from an injury.

Hankphenom 10-08-2022 08:10 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by 1952boyntoncollector (Post 2271564)
right the real value is in the franchise value, but there are billionaires that love the idea of owning a team and dont care if 'overpaying' heck look whats going on with Twitter..

I don't know, between the owners and players there just seems to be so much more money in the game nowadays. If fan interest is deteriorating, who's paying for it all?

dfletch00 10-09-2022 11:49 AM

not this weekend in Cleveland
 
Just sat through about the shortest and one of the longest MLB playoff games in history - Its not dying .... 35,000 fans sat ... and mainly stood for 15 innings yesterday in Cleveland and game time was about 45F and windy...

Many families and more kids than I have ever seen ...and i've seen alot .

Its still fun - enjoy it ... see you next NYY!

(Kudos to my wife! spent her birthday at the game)

1952boyntoncollector 10-09-2022 07:05 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Hankphenom (Post 2271625)
I don't know, between the owners and players there just seems to be so much more money in the game nowadays. If fan interest is deteriorating, who's paying for it all?

right but movies make a ton of money, noone complains if tom cruise makes 300 million, it easier to have no talent to be an actor than a baseball player as you can lose your job much easier and higher risk of injury no matter what your name is.....certain movie names will continue to get work for far longer than if they were terrible hitters.

Hankphenom 10-09-2022 08:39 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by 1952boyntoncollector (Post 2271933)
right but movies make a ton of money, noone complains if tom cruise makes 300 million, it easier to have no talent to be an actor than a baseball player as you can lose your job much easier and higher risk of injury no matter what your name is.....certain movie names will continue to get work for far longer than if they were terrible hitters.

Not sure what your point is here. Just like the movies, in the end money=interest. If baseball was dying, the money would at least start to dry up, but it seems to be the opposite, everything just keeps going up and up and up.

1952boyntoncollector 10-09-2022 09:39 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Hankphenom (Post 2271962)
Not sure what your point is here. Just like the movies, in the end money=interest. If baseball was dying, the money would at least start to dry up, but it seems to be the opposite, everything just keeps going up and up and up.

I think there is commentary that due to the all of the new online media sources that right now there is overpaying for sports content like Amazon etc, once this gets sorted out you would imagine money will go down to the leagues, also sports gambling is influencing is my guess as well, at least the potential is whats driving up speculative pricing..

HistoricNewspapers 10-10-2022 09:05 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by dfletch00 (Post 2271768)
Just sat through about the shortest and one of the longest MLB playoff games in history - Its not dying .... 35,000 fans sat ... and mainly stood for 15 innings yesterday in Cleveland and game time was about 45F and windy...

Many families and more kids than I have ever seen ...and i've seen alot .

Its still fun - enjoy it ... see you next NYY!

(Kudos to my wife! spent her birthday at the game)


Correct.

All one has to do is compare the Yankee average game attendance of 40,000 each of the last few non covid years and they dwarf the attendance numbers in Ruth's and Mantle's Yankee times. They aren't even close.

In the 1960's the Yankees outdrew the New York Rangers by only a few thousand fans a game.

Do the same for the Cubs. Not even a comparison. The NHL was more popular in the 1960's than the Cubs were. The Blackhawks outdrew the Cubs on a per game average.

So if these attendance numbers are considered as "baseball is dying" then what the heck was baseball when Hockey out-drew them? In a coma?

All these reasons given as to reasons of "baseball is dying" have been said for every generation when compared to the previous generation. Nothing new. Just a new generation of older people doing the same thing that was done/said to their own generation when THEY were younger.

It is more of a "get off my lawn' phenomenon than anything else.

Hankphenom 10-10-2022 09:07 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by 1952boyntoncollector (Post 2271980)
I think there is commentary that due to the all of the new online media sources that right now there is overpaying for sports content like Amazon etc, once this gets sorted out you would imagine money will go down to the leagues, also sports gambling is influencing is my guess as well, at least the potential is whats driving up speculative pricing..

Could be, but the "speculative pricing" in all things related to baseball has done nothing but increase dramatically for my entire lifetime, and I'm 76 years old. I remember when a consortium led by Edward Bennett Williams bought the Orioles in the 1970s for $10M, then sold it to in the mid-80s for $70M. How many billions would it go for today? Yes, much of this appreciation derives from new sources of revenue, but those seem to keep popping up, i.e. merchandising, cable TV, naming rights, now gambling, and doesn't that all boil down to consumer interest anyway, including the explosion of our hobby during this time? Even with live attendance, requiring enormous effort and expense on the part of multiple generations spoiled by the comforts and convenience of having every sport imaginable brought to them on large HD screens while they sit on the couch devouring delicious foods of all kinds delivered to their doors, they rouse themselves in numbers unheard of in my youth to freeze at ballgames in April and October. If this is all a bubble, as predicted by many for this entire time and continuing today, it sure is taking its time popping. At some point, and we're 150 years into it now, maybe it's time to attribute all of this to the fact that baseball is truly a great and fascinating game, so much so that no matter how hard they try, the idiots that run it can't seem to kill it off.

1952boyntoncollector 10-10-2022 11:16 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Hankphenom (Post 2272048)
Could be, but the "speculative pricing" in all things related to baseball has done nothing but increase dramatically for my entire lifetime, and I'm 76 years old. I remember when a consortium led by Edward Bennett Williams bought the Orioles in the 1970s for $10M, then sold it to in the mid-80s for $70M. How many billions would it go for today? Yes, much of this appreciation derives from new sources of revenue, but those seem to keep popping up, i.e. merchandising, cable TV, naming rights, now gambling, and doesn't that all boil down to consumer interest anyway, including the explosion of our hobby during this time? Even with live attendance, requiring enormous effort and expense on the part of multiple generations spoiled by the comforts and convenience of having every sport imaginable brought to them on large HD screens while they sit on the couch devouring delicious foods of all kinds delivered to their doors, they rouse themselves in numbers unheard of in my youth to freeze at ballgames in April and October. If this is all a bubble, as predicted by many for this entire time and continuing today, it sure is taking its time popping. At some point, and we're 150 years into it now, maybe it's time to attribute all of this to the fact that baseball is truly a great and fascinating game, so much so that no matter how hard they try, the idiots that run it can't seem to kill it off.


you make good points..at least baseball doesnt have the concussion and life altering injuries compared to football as well...


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 05:06 PM.