I didn't use WAR, I used my own judgement. WAR and JAWS values the two of them about the same, with a huge gap in bat in favor of Jeter and a huge gap in glove in favor of Larkin.

I still think the answer is the 2005 White Sox. Frank Thomas played 34 games but got hurt early and didn't appear in the postseason at all.

I know they got knocked out of the ALDS, but it's hard to leave the 2002 Oakland A's out for me. They should have won it all.

Someone mentioned the 2002 Angels. I'd say that if there's such as thing as a Hall of Fame closer, Francisco Rodríguez would at least have to be in the conversation. He's 4th all time in saves.