| Runscott |
03-28-2013 04:19 PM |
Others have posted similar ideas. I guess the problem I have with this way of going about it, is that you might have a person who's 'next best' at a position during an early 'era', who might be better than the 'best' player of any other era. With this system, he has to wait. I'm just going through everyone's ideas - not making the rules based on my own preferences - but my personal opinion is that it should be the best players. For instance, if you end up with too many outfielders and 'not enough' third basemen - sobeit.
I think the real Hall made some error judgement regarding banning and the way they set up inducting players from previous eras. Fortunately, we have reviewable history to go on, and no Kennesaw Mountain Landis, so if we want Hal Chase and Joe Jackson, we can have them. And none of us were buddies with Phil Rizzuto...I hope.
I'll have the ideas processed and regurgitated in useable form, by next week.
|
