If you've cracked it out already, it can't be submitted as a crossover -- the second TPG has no proof that it's the same card that the first TPG had graded. Also, when you submit for crossover, you can specify a minimum grade that you'll accept for the crossover -- if the second TPG doesn't feel it merits that grade then they won't crack it out of the first TPG's holder. (that's for PSA at least, I haven't looked into SGC policies for crossover.)

And as someone else mentioned, SGC doesn't use qualifiers -- they just knock down the overall grade, sometimes significantly.

I recently picked up a boatload of 1933 Goudeys including #198 Irving Burns.

I have seen plenty of 33 Goudey cards that have significant bleeding through the back, but nothing like this one...is there something more to this card?

Thanks - Rob

http://img375.imageshack.us/img375/4182/33goudey198.jpghttp://img573.imageshack.us/img573/6...dey198back.jpg

Just added these both this week. T202 is a nice looking card for a "1" (I think).

http://www.net54baseball.com/picture...pictureid=2831
http://www.net54baseball.com/picture...pictureid=2832

1940 PB HOFer
 

My latest addition............

The gold is a little out of register, but much nicer than much of the T205 project with a very respectable back.

Two to go...

http://i235.photobucket.com/albums/e...ery/adkins.jpg

Three recent N172 additions.
JimB

http://img689.imageshack.us/img689/4...eemansgc40.jpghttp://img263.imageshack.us/img263/9...arnessgc20.jpghttp://img576.imageshack.us/img576/7...drewssgc40.jpg

Rob, Your Burns looks very similar to my Harris, I believe it's just significant bleed as you mentioned.
RC
http://i172.photobucket.com/albums/w...DaveHarris.jpg

Wow
 

Wow...those Oj's are some of the nicest you'll ever see...beautiful!!!!!

Jim B
 

Jim B- those are great looking OJ's. They remind me of the grading discussion we had a little while back, concerning judging OJ's and other sepia cards by photo quality. Those would be at the top of the chart. regards

Jim - beautiful images!

Those are spectacular OJ's, as nice as they come, and of course it's disconcerting to see they received such low grades. One day the system will be improved.

Johnson upgrade?
 

Because who can turn down an upgrade to one's Johnson ?

http://i186.photobucket.com/albums/x...e/0c8f7a89.jpg

Sure, not everyone needs one, but ... :D

Thanks for the kind words guys. I completely agree with the grading comments. These are good examples to make the point.
JimB

Yes the TPGs are paper and cardboard stock graders, not card graders - a point that Barry has raised in the past. This is never more obvious than in the case of Old Judges.

3 more T206 HOFers
 

These put me about halfway there...

Well, 58 down and 86 to go. I was pretty happy to get this nice example of a very low population card.

open mouth
 

happy to get it

that is a nice T205 collins and I thought you got a quality buy on it. I had picked up a PSA 4 the week before or I would have chased it pretty hard... honestly the A would have fit my set better. I do think the Collins/Mouth Open is a great card for long-term appreciation. Great pickup, nice strong image.

Jim--Those are beautiful cards, congratulations. It's a great set, isn't it?

My recent pickups...

The snapshot at the end of the last post was of Dizzy Dean and Ty Cobb at a dinner together in later years.

Oops, one more....

I am excited to pick up what I would consider one of my holy grail cards, one I hadn't really anticipated owning due to its value, it also puts a "small" dent in the 1922 Zeenut set (I need 10 more for completion now)...

http://www.starsofthediamond.com/22zeethorpe.JPG

-Rhett

Rhett, in a word: "WOW"

Great Thorpe, Rhett. Congrats!!!

Thanks Larry!

Attachment 29097

Bill -

That Constellation Cut Plug tin is very cool!

More for the month
 

Another great mail day. Thanks to:
Legacy for the Mantle
Gary Chen for the Ruth
Joe's for the NY Giants
Giovanni's for the A's

Tony - that Bowman Mantle is one of my favorite cards in the hobby.

great looking card. nice pick up.

Mine too!
 

Thanks Joe. Yeah, it's by far my favorite post-war card. Never thought I'd own one but a trade and slight surface crease made it possible.

Finally got these...
 

...in from Shoeless Joe, who was kind enough to break his T205 Heritage set to part with them. Really nice pair of signed T205 HOFers, with a super clean Wheat signature.

Rhett: Wowzer!!!

Paul: Yep, Joe's good peeps!

December Pick Up
 

Congrats Rhett on the Zeenut progress & Thorpe !

Finally found this Joe to complete my OJ sub-set :

a couple nice signed 33 upgrades. Still stuck at 174

Attachment 29120

Jim, congrats on some beautiful OJs, are you collecting a Western Association subset? If not, that would be a great start.

Jeremy, nice Werrick, I like the jersey modification/update to St. Paul. What subset does this complete for you?

Rhett, great card and congrats. Your tireless efforts no doubt helped you land that card.

Nice looking 53 Bowman Mantle Tony. Also one of my favorite post war cards.

Hey thanks for this one Steve :)

Re : Subset
 

Joe- Just emailed you... This is a OJ type Nashville subset representing players that played in Nashville in 1885 and 1886 and later played for teams represented in the OJ set from 1887-1890.

<a href="http://www.flickr.com/photos/calvindog/5264359772/" title="1910-11 Sporting Life M116 (Blue) by calvindog65, on Flickr"><img src="http://farm6.static.flickr.com/5285/5264359772_23650c15c2_b.jpg" width="450" height="738" alt="1910-11 Sporting Life M116 (Blue)" /></a>

Another sharp HOF portrait crossed off the list. Thank you Darrin...

<a href="http://s9.photobucket.com/albums/a95/andreatny/?action=view&amp;current=vicwillisportfront.jpg" target="_blank"><img src="http://i9.photobucket.com/albums/a95/andreatny/vicwillisportfront.jpg" border="0" alt="Photobucket"></a>

Damn, Jeff!! You too, Tony!:D

Some recent pickups....

Attachment 29183

Attachment 29184

Attachment 29185

My first Ramly.
1 down, 5 to go!

http://photos.imageevent.com/griffin.../Moran.tif.jpg

Wow Rhett and Anthony, fantastic!

Thank You for the trade, Jim:

Ferguson's
 

Thanks to Matt Goebel for these two......

R313 Berg
 

3 more newbies
 

Thanks to:
Greg Nazareth for the Wagner
Rick Probstein for the Dickey
Mike Denero for the Stengel

Houston Buffaloes
 

I picked up this lot of T210's on ebay. I really needed two of the Houston cards for my team set. I'm at 7 of 12 cards now. These are my first new additions since January. I was starting to get discouraged.

I also picked up this 1931 Houston Buffaloes team photo featuring Dizzy Dean and Joe Medwick. I wanted it for quite a while, but it wasn't for sale. When it finally came up for sale a fellow board member sent me a message letting me know and I was able to work out a deal.

gorgeous card Anthony!

Just got the Seitz this week but have to show where he goes in the collection. This my second full page in the set and my favorite.

Wow ! Congrats Robert !!
 

Nice looking stash - Robert ! I love that Houston panaramic and glad you did not give up on the T210-3's.... You will get all 12 of them in time, so forge ahead ! (It took me 7-8 years to get 17 Nashville players from Series 8)

Happy Holidays - JJ

.
 

Thanks for the kind words Jeremy. One of the cards in my team set (Bell) came directly from you, but besides that, your willingness to share your knowledge of the set as well as advice and encouragement has proved invaluable. You are an asset to the hobby.

Happy to get this one!
 

From Mile High. This card saw the inside of a box of Cracker Jacks and survived in great shape. Just a little brown sugar and popcorn DNA.
-Mike

one word:

YYYYYYYYYYYYYYYEEEEEEEEEEESSSSSSSSSSS

Attachment 29309

Another two E93 HOFers that will go toward my set courtesy of my wife and Santa. Now at 12/30.

http://www.net54baseball.com/picture...pictureid=2839

dj

A few odds and ends
 

Another Toona--thanks Scot
http://photos.imageevent.com/imoverh...14barry_at.jpg

A scarce '21 Standard Biscuit "80 photographs" back
http://photos.imageevent.com/imoverh...1SBPfeffer.jpg

A Henry Johnson Schang, in honor of Mr. C.risafulli
http://photos.imageevent.com/imoverh...son_Schang.jpg

1934 Al Demaree Die-Cut Lefty Grove...
 

A Christmas present from my wife... Another Grove card crossed off my list...

http://www.bandkgreen.net/lefty_grov...ee_die_cut.jpg

Very nice, Brad. I have never seen that one before, she really knows her cards.

This Just In
 

'34 Annis Furs Goslin PC and '31 W-UNC Bill Terry from the Matt Wieder collection via trade and a win from Mile High


http://i152.photobucket.com/albums/s...r/goslinAF.jpghttp://i152.photobucket.com/albums/s...1WUNCterry.jpghttp://i152.photobucket.com/albums/s...DBrouthers.jpg

AWESSOME Mail Day!
 

Thanks to:
Brian Dwyer for the National Games
Tom Car. for Mayo Pfeffer
Kevin Struss for OJ Pinkney
Levi Bleem for E120 Faber
Chris Buckler for Colgan's Collins

last one

christmas came early :)


Attachment 29379

Thanks to Andrew for the heads-up shortly after this appeared on eBay as a BIN. T206 Lajoie No. 26 for me.

http://imageevent.com/ineedanap/t206

Congrats Rob!

Nice group of Lajoie cards, Rob. I know the brown Lenox is nearly impossible, but the AB 460 seems to be tougher than one would think. Have you seen many of the AB 460?

What a great array of cards in this month's pickup thread! Gillette N172s and a Wilkinson M116 Cobb, a D304 Matty and an M110 Lajoie, and a Thorpe Zeenut no less. Lots of T210s (love that O.C. Jones) and all those pesky T206s, too.

Here is my second installment in this thread which includes some auction house winnings that have trickled in of late.

Always wanted a Ruth autograph and preferably on a card. Picked this up from an auction house that I had declared I would not patronize. Goes to show you what a slut I am, when it comes to cardboard anyway. Can anyone relate?

http://photos.imageevent.com/kawika_...h%20_auto_.jpg

Can't remember if I have posted these two cards which I won in the Legendary auction. I am still not quite over watching that lot of 19 Old Mill cabinets soar into the monetary cosmos a while back in Verkman's auction. This Wingo takes a little of the sting out.
Am pleased to add a Plow Boy as a type card to my collection.

http://photos.imageevent.com/kawika_...b%20Wingo1.jpg http://photos.imageevent.com/kawika_...20Overall1.jpg

This acrylic painting of Nap LaWolf was done by Arthur K Miller. It's approximately 14 inches tall. I purchased it online from an art gallery in San Francisco. I think I'm going to put a less ponderous frame on it.

http://photos.imageevent.com/kawika_...e/DSC03157.JPG

Big Thanks to Board member glchen for this handsome Exhibits Walter Johnson. Gary does a pono deal. That's Hawaiian. Google it. No r.

http://photos.imageevent.com/kawika_...Exh%20WaJo.jpg

Bought the Toleteros Artie Wilson off eBay about the time he passed away the other week. His son, also named Artie, is a local basketball legend here in Honolulu.
I couldn't believe my good luck in landing this T210 Yaeger via the BST from a good ol' boy in Tennessee.

http://photos.imageevent.com/kawika_...e%20Wilson.jpg http://photos.imageevent.com/kawika_...20Yaeger_1.jpg

Lastly, picked up this color postcard of Swayne Field which makes a nice companion for the black-and-white job I posted earlier in this thread.

http://photos.imageevent.com/kawika_...d%20Toledo.jpg

http://photos.imageevent.com/kawika_...oledo%20pc.jpg

Nope, that one's a toughie.

Happy with these pick-ups in December

David, some great pickups there! I love the cocky look to the Yeager card. Also, if you are gonna own only one Old Mill Cabinet the Ivy Wingo is arguably the best of the known subjects (the Lave Cross is the only other guy I think I might rather have) so you have a real gem there.
-Rhett

Here is my first Walter Johnson card. I didn't think the writing on the front detracted from the look of the card in any way. Almost looks like it was meant to be there!

Wheaties Martin and Ott

Great Pickups Mr. McDonald. Glad that the H801-7 Wingo went your way.

A couple of early Christmas presents to myself. A tough E121-80 (front and back) and some nice additions to my Naps collection (thanks to Mr. Dwyer).

http://www.net54baseball.com/picture...pictureid=2871
http://www.net54baseball.com/picture...pictureid=2868http://www.net54baseball.com/picture...pictureid=2870
http://www.net54baseball.com/picture...pictureid=2869

Thank You for the trade, Scott:

1937 Joe Dimaggio Boraxo Premium

Lovely Day...

Love the Ruth auto David!!!

Very nice DiMaggio premium, never seen that one before.

2 more
 

Thanks to Bob Warren for these beauties!

1927 NY Yankees - ink blotter
 

1927 NY Yankees - ink blotter

Shown recently but received today....Immediately my favorite card from this collecting niche, ink blotters.

With the help of three board members, I was able to add the Meyers Cycle 460.
Four people involved in one sale and two trades and it went as smooth as glass.
Thanks again fellas. Still need an EPDG and Sweet Cap fact. 42 and 42OS
http://photos.imageevent.com/mhgt/ch...%20of%2011.jpg