Originally Posted by robertsmithnocure (Post 2143359)

These do not look like the same player to me.

Originally Posted by Directly (Post 2143308)

First let me say I'm the expert on this photo--not you or anyone else---years ago a very qualified expert studied this photo and confirmed Comiskey, he has more knowledge in his finger tip than several experts on here put together--so you were there is 1881 to see what Quinn or Comiskey looked like--no offense but you really don't know what your talking about --honestly after reading some of your opinion on another links where you really believe someone is someone without a ounce of documentation and doesn't even remotely look then --then you come on here and try to tell me something like he is too young or some other type of crap- --so you studied the my photo for what one hour, 3 days, one month, a year, five years --I have been studying and researching this photo for 30 years and only recently discovered its dated so PLEASE don't come on here an try to tell me anything--I have a note book full of research including correspondence with Comiskys descendance-- so best stick with the other thread and rant--thanks for your opinion because it doesn't really mean a hill of beans to me and no offense it never will-------you can go to the highest mountain top and tell everyone I said this, including Mr. King Expert--you know why --I really don't give XXXX

Originally Posted by Snowman (Post 2143374)

That is definitely not the same ear. It's a completely different shape.

Originally Posted by Directly (Post 2143328)

Nuts!--did i spell that to your satisfaction?

Originally Posted by Snowman (Post 2143381)

My bad. It sounds like you've got this one all sorted out already. Keep up the great work detective!

Originally Posted by BobC (Post 2143385)

LOL

Yes, thanks, but you have lived up to what you've been doing all along and answered not one single question, nor provided not one single piece of verifiable evidence to prove your claims.

Hey, at least answer my one question, are you ignorant or lazy?

Originally Posted by Directly (Post 2143343)

If you feel I'm arrogate- I am--reason--if I didn't know the photo was right I would be asking for opinion's saying Yes thanks your great, thanks for your opinion its wonderful, thank you may I have another.--this was all brought up by another member not me.

Originally Posted by BobC (Post 2143396)

Gee Directly, I would call you arrogant for sure, but what does it mean to be "arrogate"? Does that have something to do with you having a bad smelling personal aroma, or something like that? Never heard that one before.

Oh wait, is this possibly related to the issues I had brought to your attention before where I wondered if people would possibly begin to question your self-appointed expert status when it comes to nineteenth century photography because you can't seem to comprehend simple English grammar and spelling? Not sure because you still have refused to answer my question of whether you do that because you really are ignorant of the correct spelling and grammar used, or that you do know, but are just to lazy to go back and fix/correct what you've done. So once again, or you lazy or ignorant, there are no other options?

Originally Posted by Directly (Post 2143390)

Both--

Originally Posted by BobC (Post 2143401)

WOW, finally an honest answer!

Too bad no one can get a similar honest response from you to any of their questions to you looking for actual, verifiable proof or evidence to prove your claim that you are right and they are wrong. Nor any response to questions seeking information regarding the credentials of yourself as a self-appointed expert, or of any other expert you claimed to have consulted who supposedly agreed with you. Would also be nice to get a name of any so-called colloborating expert to actually prove you aren't just making that up.

Originally Posted by Directly (Post 2143403)

Why?--I think you spelled Colloborating incorrectly

Originally Posted by robertsmithnocure (Post 2143359)

These do not look like the same player to me.