I would send it USPS Registered with insurance. You must use gummed brown paper tape on all seams of the box.
You could send it Priority but for me Registered is just a little "safer".

I don't get any of these POVs saying "use a purchase receipt" to prove the value of cards. Not only does the purchase price have nothing to do with what something's worth now, but naturally some people have had their cards for many, many years (or even since childhood), and would never have such a receipt.

I'm not sure what the best answer is for these insurance claims spots, but needing the proof of purchase is one of the worst. If the post office can't use info like VCP as a good enough indication of something's value, then they shouldn't offer insurance at all

I've always sent via Overnight Express via USPS insured with no problem, so like to PSA it goes to a PO Box or SGC to their office so not so many hands touch it. Though these days, might revert to Registered Mail as its seems "lost package" threads seem to be rising...

Also would be interested in hearing what company people are using for privat insurance? Chubb? I remember another that also does sportscards but can't remember name...

For those who may not have used "gummed brown paper tape" before, here is a link to Staples.com where it can be bought:

https://www.staples.com/Staples-Stan...product_468231

If you're in the store, ask (or look) for "water-activated" tape.

Lastly, be sure to cover all seams. To make it easy, think of taping the corners and edge of the box like you are wrapping a gift.

I agree here. I have exactly zero receipts for any of my cards. Of course I don't have any really large value cards for which I may have asked for a receipt but still. If the PO sells you insurance for a certain amount and they lose the damn package then they should suck it up and pay out. Whoa, I got a little heated there for a second. Sorry. :o

People who buy/sell anything of value really need to look into a 3rd party insurance policy like Collect Insure.

You’ll save so much money in the not so long run but not buying pointless insurance on packages every time

I’m working with them now on a quote. Seems like the best way to go about all of this. Looks like pretty decent insurance.

I filed a USPS claim 10/23/2020, up loaded the Ebay sale with the claim. In this case the box appeared to be compromised and the card was missing. When the opened damaged refused box was returned I gave it to the post office as advised per a USPS response letter.
So its been a month and the claim history still shows under review. The insured card was sold for $650.00 so no life changer, but a month seems long enough to find the missing card. I do have private insurance but don't feel they should pay for what the Postal insured should. Talking with another collector whom filed a claim said it took forever to get paid--I do know my Congressman but hesitate to get him involved over 650.00. My situation may be a cheap education because I have used priority mail in the past to send in valuable cards for grading, so in the future will go the registered mail route!

I had that years ago at UPS.

Two heavy items I figured would be cheaper that way.
One an old computer. old enough to be collectible, even in the horrible trash picked condition it was in. Missing drive, and a bit of hay where the drive should be.
The other a Victrola stand up model that had the base and record cabinet cut off. But it still worked.

I didn't want insurance.
Had to say what was in them.
Then open them up.
They rejected the computer since it wasn't in the original packaging.
Rejected the Victrola because "we don't accept antiques"
WT.... Neither had sold for more than their basic $100 coverage for loss. Which I don't believe they would have paid anyway.
Both were very well packed.

Took them to the post office, shipped no problem, and for less than UPS.

I sent some cards to sgc last month. They said they could not deliver because no one was there, held for pickup. Luckily the next day they were received.