Top 3 wants...
1. E254 Colgan's Elmer Flick (Toledo)
2. E270 Colgan's Tin Top Walter Johnson
3. 1919 Zeenut Fatty Arbuckle devouring a baseball

honorable mention is the 1916 Zeenut Jimmy Claxton (toss up between Fatty and Jimmy)

1915 Zeenut Stan Coveleski

I'd love to have these for my type collection....but at my price...lol.

1. Kalamazoo Bats team or player card
2. Yoo Hoo card with Tab
3. 1955 Felin's Franks Card (any player)

Ricky Y

T3 Fred Clarke
T3 Nap LaJoie
T3 Mordecai Brown

None are that tough to acquire... I just always seem to be under-bidder. I like Turkey Reds, as they straddle the line between cards and memorabilia. Plus, they're stunning!

Well...

I added two to my wishlist thanks to a board member and an auction...N172 Whitney w/ dog and T205 Drum earlier this year so I guess that leaves...

Any Felin Frank
T205 Hobby no stats
Any Father and Son's Shoes Phillies

Glad I own a Joss already...and one of the very few PSA cards I own is a '58 Duren in PSA 8. Interesting to see some of the cards on other people's lists that I already own.

Joshua

Low grade with nice eye appeal works for me.

(1) 1925 Holland Creameries - Peckinpaugh.
(2) Any Walter Johnson card I don't have - e.g., E122, E123, E270, E271, etc., and especially M101-4 Indianapolis Brewing.
(3) Any N370 Lone Jack Cigs, for the type collection.

Val

This card has been on my list for over a year and half and it will complete my T205 Boston Rustlers set for the T205's. Seems like it is a tough common. :(

T205 Bayard H. Sharpe PSA 4 /SGC 5.0

1. 1928 PCL Exhibit Averill
2. 1926 Zeenut Averill
3. 1928 Zeenut Averill

Honorable Mention: E107 or W600 Harry Smith (distant relative of my wife)

They're not vintage, but ...

1970 Topps Cloth Sticker Tom Seaver
1973 Laughlin Standup Tom Seaver
1982 Fleer unissued proof Tom Seaver

1948/49 Leaf Tommy Henrich (PSA-1 or 2)
1940 Play Ball Joe DiMaggio (PSA-1)
1952 Berk Ross Mickey Mantle (PSA-1)