Net54baseball.com Forums

Net54baseball.com Forums (http://www.net54baseball.com/index.php)
-   Net54baseball Sports (Primarily) Vintage Memorabilia Forum incl. Game Used (http://www.net54baseball.com/forumdisplay.php?f=5)
-   -   Hey, pennant guys (http://www.net54baseball.com/showthread.php?t=183684)

ooo-ribay 04-21-2025 12:47 PM

Super cool! I can’t make out the mark in the last picture… :confused:

aelefson 04-21-2025 01:00 PM

Thank you! It says American Knit Wear and Emblem Mfrs Emblematic Sports Wear. Did they make any other major league pennants?

Alan

bocca001 04-21-2025 02:57 PM

American Knitwear is Keezer manufacturing. You can look them up on Domer's pennant fever blog.

I know I have seen a copy of this pennant sell at least one other time. I don't believe it was autographed, but I'm not certain.

aelefson 04-21-2025 03:28 PM

Thank you! I thought the logo looked familiar. I have a vague memory of seeing another one too but I might have confused it with this one (this came from a Massachusetts Americana dealer's estate and he had it for sale at a few ephemera shows several years ago).

Alan

ooo-ribay 04-21-2025 05:54 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by bocca001 (Post 2511168)
American Knitwear is Keezer manufacturing. You can look them up on Domer's pennant fever blog.

I knew the graphics were Keezer but wasn’t sure the mark was. Pretty bizarre that they did a special run for a car dealer. I wonder if they did other special runs?

murphusa 04-22-2025 12:31 PM

In the process of cleaning things out and looking to sell my 300 or so Baseball Pennants from the 50's to current. Condition is mint/great to poor on others

What's the market these days?

UKCardGuy 04-22-2025 01:41 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by murphusa (Post 2511359)
In the process of cleaning things out and looking to sell my 300 or so Baseball Pennants from the 50's to current. Condition is mint/great to poor on others

What's the market these days?

You may not like the answer....but it depends on which pennants. Are you able to share some photos?

ooo-ribay 04-22-2025 02:54 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by murphusa (Post 2511359)
In the process of cleaning things out and looking to sell my 300 or so Baseball Pennants from the 50's to current. Condition is mint/great to poor on others

What's the market these days?

The market is “great to poor.” :p

Depends what you’ve got.

edtiques 04-22-2025 07:02 PM

Sorry, all set.

thetahat 04-23-2025 04:43 PM

Wasn’t this discussed here awhile back when it was sold on eBay?

https://sports.ha.com/itm/baseball-c...umbnail-071515

UKCardGuy 04-24-2025 03:05 PM

Yep, we did. [Sigh] Might have expected better from a big AH.

It was back in post 8214

perezfan 04-24-2025 06:33 PM

Not the first time for Heritage (and won't be the last).

bocca001 04-27-2025 08:34 AM

1 Attachment(s)
I'd like to find blue next.

Duluth Eskimo 04-27-2025 09:49 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by thetahat (Post 2511628)
Wasn’t this discussed here awhile back when it was sold on eBay?

https://sports.ha.com/itm/baseball-c...umbnail-071515

I emailed someone who is a good guy from there. Hopefully they will pull it. Pete Calderon (who I don’t know, but seems like a good guy) is also a member here so maybe he’ll see it and have it removed

thetahat 05-09-2025 05:16 PM

1 Attachment(s)
Recent arrival, my second version of this as I also have one in purple. Would love to know if an older ASG pennant is known to exist.

ooo-ribay 05-09-2025 08:48 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by thetahat (Post 2514744)
Recent arrival, my second version of this as I also have one in purple. Would love to know if an older ASG pennant is known to exist.

Whew! Withdrawals were starting to set in.

bocca001 05-10-2025 03:09 PM

1 Attachment(s)
I don't have an answer for you Greg, but I'll take this opportunity to show off the first all star pennants I have been able to add to my collection.

ser1979 05-12-2025 06:27 AM

Thoughts on this listing??? As a Tigers fan I've never seen this one before or style, I'm leaning towards fake.

https://www.ebay.com/itm/17708554510...Bk9SR4r6qsfYZQ

ooo-ribay 05-12-2025 01:55 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ser1979 (Post 2515107)
Thoughts on this listing??? As a Tigers fan I've never seen this one before or style, I'm leaning towards fake.

https://www.ebay.com/itm/17708554510...Bk9SR4r6qsfYZQ

If it's a fake, it's a pretty good fake. But, yeah, it looks "off."

UKCardGuy 05-12-2025 03:39 PM

1 Attachment(s)
I saw that when it came up. Looks fake to me too. A few things caught my eye:

1. If you look at the seam where the Black and Gold sections join, the stitching doesn't look right to me. Here's the stitching from an early 2 part Tigers pennant sold by Hunt vs this one on Ebay.

2. The material doesn't look right

3. I'll defer to others with more knowledge, but I believe "2-part" pennants were from the early 1900's up to about the late 1910s. I don't know that they were being used in the 1930s.

Plus the lettering looks off. The D in Detroit isn't right. That D was used in the Tigers logo in 1917....not 1935.

perezfan 05-12-2025 06:05 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by UKCardGuy (Post 2515235)
I saw that when it came up. Looks fake to me too. A few things caught my eye:

1. If you look at the seam where the Black and Gold sections join, the stitching doesn't look right to me. Here's the stitching from an early 2 part Tigers pennant sold by Hunt vs this one on Ebay.

2. The material doesn't look right

3. I'll defer to others with more knowledge, but I believe "2-part" pennants were from the early 1900's up to about the late 1910s. I don't know that they were being used in the 1930s.

Plus the lettering looks off. The D in Detroit isn't right. That D was used in the Tigers logo in 1917....not 1935.

I agree with all of this....

And wasn't this same pennant already discussed at length, either in this thread or another? We clearly deemed it to be a Franken-pennant. I believe that someone took an early Princeton Pennant and melded it with a Detroit City Souvenir Pennant.

Best to stay away from this one.

Fballguy 05-12-2025 07:41 PM

3 Attachment(s)
It's a cool looking pennant and if fake it a well done fake. But the stitching gives it away IMO. Here's are some similar Princeton graphics...not that pennant makers didn't re-use graphics.

Fballguy 05-12-2025 07:46 PM

1 Attachment(s)
Speaking of Princeton pennants...I can't resist picking them up, especially the early ones. There is absolutely zero demand and they are ridiculously cheap (as are most Ivy League). As Mike Wolfe would say..."You're making me buy it".

But this one...I'd probably pass on this one. What is that a werewolf? It looks like something you'd see on an early 70s blacklight poster. Too trippy for me.

Fballguy 05-12-2025 07:54 PM

2 Attachment(s)
Last post for the the night...

Researching pennants I came across this picture. I recognize the Harvard football pennant on the wall but can't make out the Yale. The Chicago pillow appears to be football as well, but I'm seeing baseball in the Yale pennant. A sliding runner maybe? Anyone recognize it?

PS...Indianapolis 500 there as well?

Domer05 05-12-2025 09:15 PM

1 Attachment(s)
Quote:

Originally Posted by perezfan (Post 2515268)
I agree with all of this....

And wasn't this same pennant already discussed at length, either in this thread or another? We clearly deemed it to be a Franken-pennant. I believe that someone took an early Princeton Pennant and melded it with a Detroit City Souvenir Pennant.

Best to stay away from this one.

Totally agree. I believe someone used a genuine ca. 1910s Princeton head-end, by Reproduction Co., I might add, and sewed it to the tail-end of a poorly made, contemporary "Detroit" pennant.

The Old English letter script is completely non-Repco, and Repco went out of business in 1935-36. Also, the apostrophe is backwards.... :rolleyes:

This was/is the genuine Repco two-piece pennant they were trying for....

ooo-ribay 05-13-2025 05:45 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Domer05 (Post 2515294)
Totally agree. I believe someone used a genuine ca. 1910s Princeton head-end, by Reproduction Co., I might add, and sewed it to the tail-end of a poorly made, contemporary "Detroit" pennant.

The Old English letter script is completely non-Repco, and Repco went out of business in 1935-36. Also, the apostrophe is backwards.... :rolleyes:

This was/is the genuine Repco two-piece pennant they were trying for....

The “e” is ridiculously large and the font of “35” looks wrong as well. The whole right hand side might be homemade…

thetahat 05-15-2025 08:37 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ooo-ribay (Post 2515317)
The “e” is ridiculously large and the font of “35” looks wrong as well. The whole right hand side might be homemade…

FWIW … The Egner guide devotes a page to “pennants believed to be fake”, and of the 9 or 10 examples are three that are two-piece Tigers pennants, two dated 1935, but different designs.

Hankphenom 05-15-2025 09:01 AM

1 Attachment(s)
Quote:

Originally Posted by Fballguy (Post 2515283)
Last post for the the night...
Researching pennants I came across this picture. I recognize the Harvard football pennant on the wall but can't make out the Yale. The Chicago pillow appears to be football as well, but I'm seeing baseball in the Yale pennant. A sliding runner maybe? Anyone recognize it? PS...Indianapolis 500 there as well?

I have the Amherst version of the Chicago pillow, but no sports theme, just a leather insignia (for academics, maybe?) in the middle.

Chstrite 05-15-2025 07:58 PM

1966 All Star Pennant
 
1 Attachment(s)
NFS - Another All Star Pennant added to the collection. A few years ago I started chasing all the AS game pennants Brooks Robinson appeared in from 1960 - 1974. This is a variation pennant. I also have the one with the player names on it from 1966 with red letters white background. I was very surprised to learn about this variation. It is in great shape. Happy collecting.

ooo-ribay 05-15-2025 09:10 PM

1 Attachment(s)
Quote:

Originally Posted by Chstrite (Post 2516113)
NFS - Another All Star Pennant added to the collection. A few years ago I started chasing all the AS game pennants Brooks Robinson appeared in from 1960 - 1974. This is a variation pennant. I also have the one with the player names on it from 1966 with red letters white background. I was very surprised to learn about this variation. It is in great shape. Happy collecting.

Great pennant! The Giants have a Busch Stadium pennant, too. :p

perezfan 05-15-2025 10:12 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Chstrite (Post 2516113)
NFS - Another All Star Pennant added to the collection. A few years ago I started chasing all the AS game pennants Brooks Robinson appeared in from 1960 - 1974. This is a variation pennant. I also have the one with the player names on it from 1966 with red letters white background. I was very surprised to learn about this variation. It is in great shape. Happy collecting.

Beauty.... Congrats!

Did you ever find the super-tough 1964 ASG Pennant (played in NYC?) If not, there are two on eBay right now. I know you were looking for one a while back.

Chstrite 05-16-2025 05:03 PM

1964 AS pennant
 
Yes. Found one a while ago. Thanks for mentioning though.

ooo-ribay 05-18-2025 09:34 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ser1979 (Post 2515107)
Thoughts on this listing??? As a Tigers fan I've never seen this one before or style, I'm leaning towards fake.

https://www.ebay.com/itm/17708554510...Bk9SR4r6qsfYZQ

I think the market has spoken. $305, and probably not worth that.

thetahat 05-21-2025 04:20 PM

2 Attachment(s)
Recent acquisition. Do the Tigers collectors know anything about this? I can't find another example ...

Duluth Eskimo 05-21-2025 06:04 PM

That’s a pretty sweet banner. I’ve never seen that one or one that early like it.

ooo-ribay 05-21-2025 07:35 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by thetahat (Post 2517192)
Recent acquisition. Do the Tigers collectors know anything about this? I can't find another example ...

That’s sweet! Satin-like? How big is it?

thetahat 05-21-2025 07:39 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ooo-ribay (Post 2517218)
That’s sweet! Satin-like? How big is it?

It’s about 40x28 inches. Yes it’s a satin-like fabric and the graphics are screened.

vintagesportscollector 05-21-2025 07:54 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by thetahat (Post 2517220)
It’s about 40x28 inches. Yes it’s a satin-like fabric and the graphics are screened.

That’s a gorgeous banner Greg. Sweet pick-up!

ooo-ribay 05-22-2025 05:44 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by thetahat (Post 2517220)
It’s about 40x28 inches. Yes it’s a satin-like fabric and the graphics are screened.

I think I missed the second picture, when I first saw your post. Is that stitch work to give it a “shimmering” effect? I’d love to know who made it.

Too bad you have no wall space! :p

thetahat 05-22-2025 06:24 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ooo-ribay (Post 2517270)
I think I missed the second picture, when I first saw your post. Is that stitch work to give it a “shimmering” effect? I’d love to know who made it.

Too bad you have no wall space! :p

Yeah that’s a deliberate pattern in the fabric.

It came with a thick dowel and a rope to hang, but the dowel was broken. Off to Michaels for a replacement. I’ll find room for it.

On this note … what other “banners” do you guys have? It seems to be that the Tigers, Dodgers, and Reds have a few of these so I’m figuring Mark S. and Bumpus Jones have pics to share?

ser1979 05-22-2025 11:36 AM

3 Attachment(s)
These are the only two Tiger banners I own. I was watching the 34 banner and doing some research. Best I can tell is it was sold by the old Hudson store which use to be downtown Detroit on Woodward Ave. Hudson's was a big supporter of the Tigers and would always hang banners on their building during the season and WS. There is a version of the 68 banner I have that's white that was sold by Hudson's after the Tigers won the WS.

ooo-ribay 05-22-2025 01:26 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ser1979 (Post 2517373)
These are the only two Tiger banners I own. I was watching the 34 banner and doing some research. Best I can tell is it was sold by the old Hudson store which use to be downtown Detroit on Woodward Ave. Hudson's was a big supporter of the Tigers and would always hang banners on their building during the season and WS. There is a version of the 68 banner I have that's white that was sold by Hudson's after the Tigers won the WS.

Did someone buy that 1934 banner????? That thing is 60 feet tall!!!!

thetahat 05-22-2025 06:18 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ooo-ribay (Post 2517404)
Did someone buy that 1934 banner????? That thing is 60 feet tall!!!!

That raises a question … what if that 1934 banner on the side of the building survived. Maybe it did. What would it fetch in auction? So big you literally can’t do anything with it …

thetahat 05-22-2025 06:19 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ser1979 (Post 2517373)
These are the only two Tiger banners I own. I was watching the 34 banner and doing some research. Best I can tell is it was sold by the old Hudson store which use to be downtown Detroit on Woodward Ave. Hudson's was a big supporter of the Tigers and would always hang banners on their building during the season and WS. There is a version of the 68 banner I have that's white that was sold by Hudson's after the Tigers won the WS.

Those are awesome, Stephen! Love the ‘35 especially.

ooo-ribay 05-22-2025 06:36 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by thetahat (Post 2517483)
That raises a question … what if that 1934 banner on the side of the building survived. Maybe it did. What would it fetch in auction? So big you literally can’t do anything with it …

Stephen said he was “watching it.” That made me think it was in an auction. :confused:

edit: I guess he meant your banner.

ser1979 05-23-2025 06:50 AM

1 Attachment(s)
On the topic of "Banners & where are they now"......

This banner hung in the Tigers hallway from the locker room to the field during the 84-championship season. There were rumors that the banner survived and was discovered when Tiger stadium was torn down but, I've never seen evidence of it.

ooo-ribay 05-23-2025 07:30 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ser1979 (Post 2517569)
On the topic of "Banners & where are they now"......

This banner hung in the Tigers hallway from the locker room to the field during the 84-championship season. There were rumors that the banner survived and was discovered when Tiger stadium was torn down but, I've never seen evidence of it.

That looks more like a giant sticker…kinda like the thing in tatters below it.

thetahat 05-24-2025 06:48 AM

1 Attachment(s)
This will have to do for now, next to the hot water heater. Probably better in a frame.

Hankphenom 05-25-2025 09:14 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by thetahat (Post 2517754)
This will have to do for now, next to the hot water heater. Probably better in a frame.

Amazing!

Domer05 05-26-2025 09:55 AM

Dodger "war towel" banners by Superior Hand Blocked Textile Co.
 
3 Attachment(s)
In the 1960s the Dodgers sold a series of banners branded as "war towels." These were sold at the stadium and available for purchase via the team's mail-order catalog for $1 each.

I always thought these banners were screen printed. They were not. Most likely they were manufactured by a company called Superior Hand Blocked Textile Co. As their name suggests, they printed these banners on 100% woven cotton twill using the hand block printing method. Hand block printing involves carving a design onto a block and stamping it onto the fabric.

Superior made others similar novelty items for the Dodgers; and, most likely, other teams. I believe they also manufactured a popular item known as the "crying towel" which featured crying mascots representing all of the AL and NL teams.

perezfan 05-26-2025 12:19 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Domer05 (Post 2518193)
In the 1960s the Dodgers sold a series of banners branded as "war towels." These were sold at the stadium and available for purchase via the team's mail-order catalog for $1 each.

I always thought these banners were screen printed. They were not. Most likely they were manufactured by a company called Superior Hand Blocked Textile Co. As their name suggests, they printed these banners on 100% woven cotton twill using the hand block printing method. Hand block printing involves carving a design onto a block and stamping it onto the fabric.

Superior made others similar novelty items for the Dodgers; and, most likely, other teams. I believe they also manufactured a popular item known as the "crying towel" which featured crying mascots representing all of the AL and NL teams.

Would love to find the "War Cry Towel". Just another item to add to the "They could never make it today" list.

ooo-ribay 05-26-2025 02:47 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by perezfan (Post 2518220)
Would love to find the "War Cry Towel". Just another item to add to the "They could never make it today" list.

I don’t believe there’s a Giants crying towel. Giants fans don’t cry.

rlevy 05-26-2025 05:55 PM

I used to have all 3 towels displayed along with my pennants. And it was ok until my granddaughters learned to read and I had to try and tell them why it was ok to use terms like "Moider", "Hang", "Poison" and "Kill" players on the other teams. So I sold the War Cry towel to a local collector who is trying to obtain every items ever offered in the Dodgers mail order catalogs. I thought that was nuts, but he actually has most of the items. The War Cry towel was one he was never able to find, so he was happy to get mine. Oddly, I still have the other 2 towels which are quite similar in word usage still on display, I just moved them into a corner.

Rick

ooo-ribay 05-26-2025 06:55 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by rlevy (Post 2518286)
I used to have all 3 towels displayed along with my pennants. And it was ok until my granddaughters learned to read and I had to try and tell them why it was ok to use terms like "Moider", "Hang", "Poison" and "Kill" players on the other teams. So I sold the War Cry towel to a local collector who is trying to obtain every items ever offered in the Dodgers mail order catalogs. I thought that was nuts, but he actually has most of the items. The War Cry towel was one he was never able to find, so he was happy to get mine. Oddly, I still have the other 2 towels which are quite similar in word usage still on display, I just moved them into a corner.

Rick

I like the idea of trying to get everything from a team’s mail order Golden Age, which for the Dodgers and Giants, I would put at 1958-68. I’ve seen 5 for $6 Weirdo bobbing heads in a Dodgers catalog. Worth $6-7000, today. Does your buddy have those?

rlevy 05-26-2025 07:41 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ooo-ribay (Post 2518298)
I like the idea of trying to get everything from a team’s mail order Golden Age, which for the Dodgers and Giants, I would put at 1958-68. I’ve seen 5 for $6 Weirdo bobbing heads in a Dodgers catalog. Worth $6-7000, today. Does your buddy have those?

Yes Rob, he has all the Weirdos and several walls displaying bobbleheads. It is interesting what he is missing, things like 12" cloth tall dolls, made in Japan, that came in sets of four. He has two, but missing the batter and catcher. He also needs the exceedingly rare 1963 Sandy Koufax Strike-out game, the top of which was made with thin cardboard and is almost always found in bad shape if at all. I have a really nice one which he wants, but I am holding on to it for now.

BTW, I have an extra 1965 Murder the Minnesota Twins banner if any one is looking for one. A little faded, which is pretty normal for these 1965 banners. The 1963 banner is much more available is great condition as there was a warehouse find of these about twenty-five years ago.

Rick

doug.goodman 05-27-2025 05:48 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ooo-ribay (Post 2518240)
I don’t believe there’s a Giants crying towel. Giants fans don’t cry.

Too used to misery, no more tears remaining.



Says the guy whose team doesn't have many problems winning their division, but after that they're Mendoza line level.

UKCardGuy 05-28-2025 09:52 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by rlevy (Post 2518300)
Yes Rob, he has all the Weirdos and several walls displaying bobbleheads. It is interesting what he is missing, things like 12" cloth tall dolls, made in Japan, that came in sets of four. He has two, but missing the batter and catcher. He also needs the exceedingly rare 1963 Sandy Koufax Strike-out game, the top of which was made with thin cardboard and is almost always found in bad shape if at all. I have a really nice one which he wants, but I am holding on to it for now.

BTW, I have an extra 1965 Murder the Minnesota Twins banner if any one is looking for one. A little faded, which is pretty normal for these 1965 banners. The 1963 banner is much more available is great condition as there was a warehouse find of these about twenty-five years ago.

Rick


Wow. You're friend has a pretty impressive collection. I struggle to find the mail order catalogs let alone all of the items sold in them.

ser1979 05-30-2025 12:53 PM

1 Attachment(s)
Anyone have any tricks or tips on how to get ink pen off a pennant?

ooo-ribay 05-30-2025 01:57 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ser1979 (Post 2519004)
Anyone have any tricks or tips on how to get ink pen off a pennant?

I would try a bleach pen.

Fballguy 05-30-2025 05:18 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ser1979 (Post 2519004)
Anyone have any tricks or tips on how to get ink pen off a pennant?

IMO...Your best bet would be to paint over it. Any attempt to erase or remove will likly make it look worse. You can get some fine tip brushes and antique white paint. Even if the white isn't perfect, it would look better than pen.

Fballguy 05-30-2025 05:18 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ser1979 (Post 2519004)
Anyone have any tricks or tips on how to get ink pen off a pennant?

IMO...Your best bet would be to paint over it. Any attempt to erase or remove will likely make it look worse. You can get some fine tip brushes and antique white paint. Even if the white isn't perfect, it would look better than pen.

UKCardGuy 05-30-2025 05:39 PM

1 Attachment(s)
Well, we seem to be on a real Tigers run on this thread lately. Here's another one that just arrived today.

The spine looks a bit wonky. I'm not sure if it's just poor quality control at the manufacturer or if sone's tried to reapply it. It's a fairly scarce pennant so there's not too many photos that I can compare it against.

I'd welcome you're thoughts?

Fballguy 05-30-2025 06:26 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by UKCardGuy (Post 2519046)
Well, we seem to be on a real Tigers run on this thread lately. Here's another one that just arrived today.

The spine looks a bit wonky. I'm not sure if it's just poor quality control at the manufacturer or if sone's tried to reapply it. It's a fairly scarce pennant so there's not too many photos that I can compare it against.

I'd welcome you're thoughts?

With pennants it's hard to say. They're largely uncharted territory (except for feltfootball.com, the largest pennant gallery in the known universe and, of course, pennantfever.weebly.com the ultimate encyclopedia of pennant history).

The most prominent auction houses in the industry know basically jack sh*t about them, are regularly fooled by repros and act as if they're "little boy" every time they're confronted with the impossible mission of shipping one.

As Kyle has shown, there have been a littany of producers with varying degrees of artistic talent and quality control.

So...IMO...Anyone that says with certainty that your spine is fubar is likely FOS themselves.

It does look funky...wavy...and not Louvre ready. But...

Who cares?

It's a rare, beautiful pennant.

Again...Just IMO.

Domer05 05-30-2025 09:42 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by UKCardGuy (Post 2519046)
Well, we seem to be on a real Tigers run on this thread lately. Here's another one that just arrived today.

The spine looks a bit wonky. I'm not sure if it's just poor quality control at the manufacturer or if sone's tried to reapply it. It's a fairly scarce pennant so there's not too many photos that I can compare it against.

I'd welcome you're thoughts?

A agree with Rob. It's more likely this was just the result of poor quality control than some modern attempt to doctor the spine, or replace it.

It's also a cool design. Enjoy it!

Domer05 05-30-2025 10:17 PM

2 Attachment(s)
Quote:

Originally Posted by Fballguy (Post 2519043)
IMO...Your best bet would be to paint over it. Any attempt to erase or remove will likly make it look worse. You can get some fine tip brushes and antique white paint. Even if the white isn't perfect, it would look better than pen.

Yup, here too, I'm in agreement with Rob. Painting over it may just be your best bet.

I bought this 1959 WS champs pennant a few weeks ago. A previous owner (perhaps the 9-year-old kid that took it home from the Coliseum in 1960) doctored the artwork by outlining the stadium in black marker (and, enhancing three other secondary colors).

I tried to remove the black ink by rubbing a Q-tip soaked in rubbing alcohol over the black ink, which sat entirely atop the white underbase that Trench screened on to the pennant. Results were mixed. Yes, it gradually removed some of the black ink; and, it did not harm the white underbase at all. Problem was the red dye that the felt was made of: it had become very unstable over the years, and the alcohol was causing more of its removal than the black ink. So I quit.

And turned to Plan "B." Sharpie makes a product called a "paint pen." And, they sell one in white. It's basically a felt-tipped marker that permits a heavy paint (not ink) dispersion. The paint is oil based, which means it's opaque enough to mask the black ink I was trying to cover. At the same time, the paint wasn't so thin that it ran all over the place, ruining the art.

This was what I used: https://www.amazon.com/Sharpie-Oil-B...IMS99GTX&gQT=1

After four coats, leaving 20 minutes of drying time between applications, I was very pleased with the result....

Anyway, try the rubbing alcohol method first. It can't hurt the white underbase. If it works, awesome. If not, consider the paint pen method?

thetahat 05-31-2025 07:24 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by UKCardGuy (Post 2519046)
Well, we seem to be on a real Tigers run on this thread lately. Here's another one that just arrived today.

The spine looks a bit wonky. I'm not sure if it's just poor quality control at the manufacturer or if sone's tried to reapply it. It's a fairly scarce pennant so there's not too many photos that I can compare it against.

I'd welcome you're thoughts?

It looks legit to me. But generally speaking, hold up to a light and look for pre-existing stitch holes. Easiest way to tell if your pennant has been re-spined. I think you will find yours is okay. Something to look out for in Trench pennants since bugs and/or moths tend to enjoy their spines.

ooo-ribay 05-31-2025 08:12 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Fballguy (Post 2519043)
IMO...Your best bet would be to paint over it. Any attempt to erase or remove will likly make it look worse. You can get some fine tip brushes and antique white paint. Even if the white isn't perfect, it would look better than pen.

You convinced me. Strike my bleach pen idea from the record.

Fballguy 05-31-2025 09:32 AM

1 Attachment(s)
Quote:

Originally Posted by Domer05 (Post 2519086)
After four coats, leaving 20 minutes of drying time between applications, I was very pleased with the result....

Anyway, try the rubbing alcohol method first. It can't hurt the white underbase. If it works, awesome. If not, consider the paint pen method?

Nice job Kyle! If only it was as easy as Photoshop. ;)

UKCardGuy 05-31-2025 05:27 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by thetahat (Post 2519103)
It looks legit to me. But generally speaking, hold up to a light and look for pre-existing stitch holes. Easiest way to tell if your pennant has been re-spined. I think you will find yours is okay. Something to look out for in Trench pennants since bugs and/or moths tend to enjoy their spines.

Thanks guys. No pre-existing stitch hole, so it's just sloppy manufacturing. Not sure who made these but I really like the design.

ser1979 06-02-2025 08:20 AM

1 Attachment(s)
Quote:

Originally Posted by UKCardGuy (Post 2519046)
Well, we seem to be on a real Tigers run on this thread lately. Here's another one that just arrived today.

The spine looks a bit wonky. I'm not sure if it's just poor quality control at the manufacturer or if sone's tried to reapply it. It's a fairly scarce pennant so there's not too many photos that I can compare it against.

I'd welcome you're thoughts?


Gary,

Love the pennant, I own the green version and yours is the first one I've seen surface in several years. Unfortunately, mine has the year wrote on it by whoever previously owned it. As far as the spine goes, I would agree with everyone else and say it just poor quality and the pennant is 100% legit.

bocca001 06-03-2025 09:25 PM

1 Attachment(s)
Someone posted this in a Houston Colt 45s/Astros Facebook group and I thought I'd share it here. Concession stand at a Colt 45s game. Image quality is not the best, but cool that it is in color. This guy has a ton of pennants. I think the post said it was from 1963.

ooo-ribay 06-04-2025 05:12 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by bocca001 (Post 2519894)
Someone posted this in a Houston Colt 45s/Astros Facebook group and I thought I'd share it here. Concession stand at a Colt 45s game. Image quality is not the best, but cool that it is in color. This guy has a ton of pennants. I think the post said it was from 1963.

If the upside down Giants pennant is a distress signal, they could use it now. :mad:

Domer05 06-04-2025 08:48 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by bocca001 (Post 2519894)
Someone posted this in a Houston Colt 45s/Astros Facebook group and I thought I'd share it here. Concession stand at a Colt 45s game. Image quality is not the best, but cool that it is in color. This guy has a ton of pennants. I think the post said it was from 1963.

Great photo. So this was pre-Astrodome? Colt .45 Stadium, I think it was called?

Are the arrows pointing to a Colt .45s Ladies Apron?

bocca001 06-04-2025 12:56 PM

I'm guessing the arrows were added digitally by a collector to point something out to another collector. Not sure if the guy who posted it has an unadulterated original. We were just talking about a dodgers collector who was trying to get everything listed in team catalogs. I guess a photo like this can help to serve the same purpose.

thetahat 06-04-2025 05:24 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Domer05 (Post 2519959)
Great photo. So this was pre-Astrodome? Colt .45 Stadium, I think it was called?

Are the arrows pointing to a Colt .45s Ladies Apron?

The navy blue Colts pennant is a toughie to find in good condition …

UKCardGuy 06-04-2025 06:18 PM

I love that all the pennants were sold on sticks. Makes it easy to wave in the stadium but we hardly ever see them that way as vintage items.

Vintagedeputy 06-07-2025 05:32 PM

Our local AA team, the Flying Squirrels is doing a throwback night to commemorate the old team in Richmond which was known as the Virginians. Here’s a video they made and early in the video you can see a vintage Virginians pennant.

https://www.facebook.com/share/v/1C8...ibextid=wwXIfr

thetahat 06-07-2025 08:11 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Vintagedeputy (Post 2520650)
Our local AA team, the Flying Squirrels is doing a throwback night to commemorate the old team in Richmond which was known as the Virginians. Here’s a video they made and early in the video you can see a vintage Virginians pennant.

https://www.facebook.com/share/v/1C8...ibextid=wwXIfr

Awesome looking pennant … love the ballpark, coached against VCU there ….


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 07:19 AM.