1952 Topps Set Break by burlssports ~ Break Complete

[ZenPop]

Originally Posted by mighty bombjack

Leon has got it there, as this is all about framing. If you are thinking "I'm going to try and get the Mantle," than it seems like gambling. But if you are thinking "I'm buying a random 1952 Topps card," than it is not.

It is fairly easy to correlate this to buying a pack of baseball cards (or, if you will, a pack of cigarettes in 1910 that have a card included). If you are buying it hoping for that long-shot autograph (or, say, a Mathewson in the other scenario), than you are gambling (and would be better off buying the desired card/cards on the secondary market). I know that many, or perhaps most, people buying packs and boxes these days are hoping for that huge hit, but there are still plenty of us that buy a pack of Topps knowing that we are getting ten baseball cards. Might be worth more than my initial outlay, likely worth less, but I'm happy either way because I went into the transaction looking to buy ten baseball cards.

EXACTLY THIS. EVERY SINGLE TIME you buy a pack of baseball cards, it's like a Set Break... except that THIS is more explicit. When you buy a pack of cards you know the price... but there could get 2 of the same crappy cards. The set break sets the ground rules in stone, INCLUDING the EXACT cards that will be distributed. ...plus... it's freaking fun!

If you don't like to join set breaks, don't join them. If you do, have at it. I've joined a couple... got not much to speak of... but I don't have any complaints. I knew EXACTLY what the odds were AND that I WAS going to get a card. As random as a card in a sealed pack.

People complaining sound a bit too much like Grandpa Simpson and the "Old Man Yells At Cloud" headline in the paper.