1915 Cracker Jack Advertising Card Joe Tinker Card?

[Qcards]

I posted these pictures quiet some time ago. I asked SGC if they would give them an "A" for authentic and they said no.

Not sure of the value but they are pretty cool. I am going to place them over a poster blow up as well, great idea !!

[gnaz01]

Originally Posted by Qcards

I posted these pictures quiet some time ago. I asked SGC if they would give them an "A" for authentic and they said no.

Not sure of the value but they are pretty cool. I am going to place them over a poster blow up as well, great idea !!

VERY COOL!!!!

[JamesGallo]

Neat pices and I have seen several over the years, but people seem to like to price them as cards and alough I had interest I was not going to pay the same money for pieces from an add.

If you REALLY wanted them slabbed Beckett might slab them as they have done a lot of authentic. PSA and SGC will not.

James G

[Rickyy]

I guess since it came from a poster vs a card is the reason that they won't grade it...(diff paper too)...but they do grade as "A" salesman sample cards from Topps and Bowman even if they are cut into indv pieces...

[Matt]

The TPGs grade the blank backed 'cards' cut from c1911 notebook covers; if they do that knowing they are cut from notebook covers, then I'd think they should grade these as well. However, my hunch is that they originally didn't know those were cut from notebook covers and started grading them thinking they were a UNC issue.

[ecRich]

I've got these two. The Baker of course is not on the only ad sheet that I have seen. Has anyone seen a second sheet with other cards?

[Marckus99]

First, they definately have value - not on the same level as the regular cards.
But then again - these are far, far more difficult to find than the average issued Cracker Jack cards.

Also, there IS another sheet, I have a card from the 1914 (Series 144) poster;
will get a scan out soon.

I think alot of collectors disregard these really tough cards ONLY because they are soo hard to find. IMO.

Mark

[Marckus99]

Schang, Archer, Barry & Wilson - all are NOT on the "Series 176" poster.

Note: Barry has "144" printed on back......

[Leon]

I don't see any harm in those being graded by a TPG if labeled correctly. If I saw them in an SGC, BVG or PSA holder that said "AUT- Ad cut out", I don't think I would have heartburn over it. Everything else gets slabbed nowadays.