The Baseball Card HOF Official Ballot

[Archive]

Posted By: John(z28jd)

Welcome to the 1st annual Baseball Card Hall of Fame Ballot.Thanks to everyone who gave suggestions,and nominations.The cards are seperated into 4 different categories.Category 1)N cards 2)T cards 3)E cards and 4)others.Please send me one vote in each category by email( darealdrza@aol.com) and voting results will be announced next saturday to allow everyone to get in their votes.Please no multiple voting from seperate email addresses,and everyone please submit a vote,wont take long and its fun.So heres the ballots for each category in no particular order:


N cards: 1)N162 Anson 2)N172 O.J. Whitney/Dog 3)N690 Kalamazoo Bats Ewing 4)1869 Peck & Snyder Reds 5)N300 Nichols 6)1885 Hancock Clothing(1st minor league cards)
7)N172 Gibson,A's 8)N172 Delahanty 9)N184 Anson 10)N172 Ewing/Mascot 11)N172 Anson/uniform 12) 4 base hits King Kelly 13)N172 Radbourne,port 14)Kalamazoo Bats Ward


T cards: 1)T206 Johnson,port 2)T205 Cobb 3)T206 Wagner 4)T210-8 Joe Jackson 5)T206 Cy Young,port 6)T3 Speaker 7)T206 Cobb,red back. 8)T212 Cobb 9)T202 Jennings/Cobb steal/3rd 10)T206 Johnson,pitching 11)T4 Obak Weaver

E cards: 1)E90-2 Wagner 2)E92 Magee 3)E92 Oakes 4)E95 Cobb 5)E92 Mathewson 6)1914 Cracker Jack Joe Jackson 7)E90 G.Davis,batting 8)1914 C.J. Mathewson 9)E92 Wagner 1915 C.J. Joe Jackson 10)E90 Mathewson 11)E135 Collins Mccarthy Joe Jackson

others: 1)D304 Cobb 2)M101-5 Ruth 3)33 DeLong Gehrig 4)34 Goudey Gehrig #37 5)M116 Cobb 6)M101-4 Joe Jackson 7)1933 Goudey Lajoie 8) 33 Goudey Gehrig #61 9) 1941 Double Play #82 Williams/Cronin 10)33 Diamond Stars Lefty Grove 11)33 Goudey Gehringer 12)1936 world wide gum DiMaggio 13)33 Goudey Ruth #181 14) Fan Craze Lajoie 15)Alleghany Mathewson

Thats all of the choices,now think them over and then vote! Any cards you feel should be on here but arent let me know and they will be on the 2nd ballot

[Archive]

Posted By: Andy Baran

1.) N Cards: 1869 Peck & Snyder Cincinnati Reds

2.) T Cards: 1909 T204 Walter Johnson (Write in Vote)

3.) E Cards: 1903 E107 Breisch Williams Honus Wagner (Write in Vote)

4.) Other: M101-5 Sporting News Babe Ruth

[Archive]

Posted By: John(z28jd)

good idea Andy,write in votes will be allowed and if they dont win they will be added to the next list

[Archive]

Posted By: Jaime Leiderman

1.) N Cards: 1869 Peck & Snyder Cincinnati Reds

2.) T Cards: 1909 T206 Wagner

3.) E Cards: 1912 E300 Plow´s Candy Ty Cobb (Write in Vote)

4.) Other: Alleghany Mathewson

[Archive]

Posted By: Scott M

N172 Delahanty
T3 Speaker
E90-2 Wagner
Delong Gehrig

[Archive]

Posted By: John(z28jd)

Jay Miller just pointed out to me that the 1885 Hancock cloth cards should be listed under "others" not N card category as they are W cards.If youve never seen or heard of them they are really nice cards of 3 minor leaguers,all 3 are one-of-a-kind,as theyre the only known examples.Tho this is not a endorsement to get you to vote or not vote for them just making a correction with some extra information

[Archive]

Posted By: Jay Miller

John---As I mentioned in my email the Hancock Clothing cards should be in the Misc. category. They are W cards I believe.

N: N172 Anson in Uniform---the 19th century Wagner

T: T206 Wagner---The name card in the hobby

E: E135 Jackson---Great pose in black uniform

Misc: Hancock Clothing Card---First set of cards with photos, first minor league card( 1885 Syracuse Stars players)

[Archive]

Posted By: B Hodes

N card - Ewing w/Mascott
T Card - T202 Cobb/Jennings "Ty Cobb (photo by Conlon"
E card - 1914(15) Cracker Jack Joe Jackson
Misc. - Peck & Snyder Red Stockings*


* not sure if this is the right place for this. Also, I don't think that there even is an Allegheny(sp) Matty!

[Archive]

Posted By: David

Probably most of the cards deserve to eventually be in the 'HOF' (perhaps some by the veterans comittee, tho). My choices were the obvious ones.

4 base hits King Kelly
T206 Wagner
1914 Joe Jackson
1933 Goudey Lajoie

[Archive]

Posted By: John(z28jd)

according to brett domhue's website there is an alleghany mathewson and at least one other person mentioned it as their nomination

[Archive]

Posted By: Andy Baran

I don't own it (I was the underbidder when it sold in Lepset's auction), but here is the scan.

[Archive]

Posted By: Tom L.

I got distracted, so wasn't sure if this was for nominations or votes. Seems like you should have nominations first, as there are probably some great cards that people would not consider unless they saw them on a list. So I vote that we have nominations before votes. So here are some that weren't previously mentioned:

N: N300 Mayo Wilbert Robinson, Brouthers Baltimore
N142 Duke Cabinets Robinson, Delehanty
N162 Brouthers, Keefe, Kelly (screw Anson, the racist scumbag; sure, the others may have been also, but he wielded his power and undermined the game for 70 years)
Alpha Photo Engraving McGraw, Jennings, Kelly, Hanlon

T: T205 Joss
T206 Keeler, Joss, Matty, McGraw, and Waddell portraits
T206 Plank (figured it deserved a new entry)
T207 Buck Weaver
T4 Weaver Cabinet (or T212 if cabinets not allowed)
T210 Jackson

E: Any of Cobb reaching up for the ball with blue background (or does that only come in the News cards? if so, put it in the "other" category, and put one of the other non-red and non-orange Cobbs "glove outstretched above head" down here)
Any of Matty horizontal
E95 Bender, Plank
E107 (Breisch-Wiliiams) Joss, Hanlon, Keeler, McGraw, Chance, Young, Waddell, and Delehanty

Other: M116 Sporting Life McGraw
C46 Dunn, Kelly, McGinnity, Gandil
Baltimore News (E appearance) Cobb, Wagner
But if I had to select only one, it would be the 1914 Baltimore News Babe Ruth (Blue version)

Card I hate the most (compared to what it should be): E90-1 Joe Jackson lipstick card

[Archive]

Posted By: David

Jeez, I dunno Andy, it looks an awful lot like Kid Nichols to me.

[Archive]

Posted By: jeff

it's too hard to choose, so i'm only voting for cards I have owned (or do own) at some point ... maybe the next time we hold a poll i will have won the lottery and bought out tik&tik ... but for now:

1. N172 Ewing & Mascot
(with honorable mention to all cards picturing guys sliding (like McCarthy) or catching a ball hanging from a string (too many to count)).
2. t3 speaker
3. e90-2 wagner
4. delong gehrig

[Archive]

Posted By: Julie Vognar

N: Peck and Snyder Red Stockings
T: T4 Obak Weaver
E: E135 (Collins McCarthy) Jackson
other: Goudey '33 Ruth #181

Honorable mention: '52 Bowman Mantle

[Archive]

Posted By: John(z28jd)

We did have nominations all last week,and all of the ones on the list above,original post in this thread,were all of the cards i received nominations for.Those choices you mentioned will be included on the next ballot,but for now you would have to choose one from each category,either listed or as a write in vote if you want them to count.Thanks

[Archive]

Posted By: leon

1. Peck and Snyder-1869
2. Four Base Hits Kelly
3. Allegheny- Mathewson

[Archive]

Posted By: sonny

my votes

N172 Delahanty
T210 Joe Jackson
1914 Cracker Jack Mathewson

[Archive]

Posted By: Anonymous

N- N162 Anson
T- t206 Johnson portrait
E- E92 Nadja Oakes
Misc- Delong Gehrig

Jay

[Archive]

Posted By: brian parker

N series: N162 Kelly
E series: E92/E101/E102 etc. Mathewson
T series: T206 Keeler batting
Misc: 1933 Goudey Gehringer

Perhaps I should participate in the nominations next time around so that not so many of my choices are write-in.

Brian

[Archive]

Posted By: jay behrens

I am the anon poster

Jay

[Archive]

Posted By: Paul

My votes:

N: N172 Anson in uniform
T: T227 Ty Cobb (write in)
E: E-90-1 Joe Jackson (write in -- it's his rookie for God's sake, even older than the T-210 minor league card).
Miscellaneous: 1914 Baltimore Babe Ruth (write in)

[Archive]

Posted By: John(z28jd)

anyone else wanna get in their votes,either email me or post them here.Thanks

[Archive]

Posted By: Mike Williams

N - N162 Kelly
T - T227 Cobb
E - E92 (etc.) Mathewson or E93 (etc.) Cobb
M - M101-5 Ruth

[Archive]

Posted By: John(z28jd)

Last chance for votes,i know some people like brueso missed it because its been pushed to page 3 in less than 2 days,so ill give people one last chance before final results are announced

[Archive]

Posted By: petecld

N cards: 12) 4 base hits King Kelly

T cards: 2)T205 Cobb

E cards: 5)E92 Mathewson

others:
1)D304 Cobb
4)1934 Goudey Gehrig #37

[Archive]

Posted By: runscott

N cards: 4)1869 Peck & Snyder Reds
T cards: 3)T206 Wagner
E cards: 4)E95 Cobb
others: 4)34 Goudey Gehrig #37

I need more votes - hurry up and give us round 2!