OT: Postcard Classifications

[HOF Auto Rookies]

I know this probably has been discussed a little bit, but I'm just curious as to others' thoughts on postcards. Do you feel that they fall under the 'baseball card' category, or is it a category in itself?

I know many view it as they do, and don't. I personally feel that they don't, and I do not consider them 'baseball cards' for my collection.

[Leon]

As a type collector I have a broad definition of cards. I do think they are cards. Burdick even classified many of them and gave quite a bit of space to them in his venerable American Card Catalog. Here is a brief excerpt but there are several pages on them..

[Cardboard Junkie]

Even though Burdick was a founding "pioneer" of our hobby.....he still got a lot wrong. Dave.

[rhettyeakley]

Never really understood the argument against them.
They are made of paper... Check.
They are "cards" (it's even the in the name postcard)... Check
They are a reasonable size (smaller than a cabinet or a T3)... Check

I'm not seeing the problem, but I also don't care if others view them as cards as they probably don't view some other things as cards that obviously are!

[HOF Auto Rookies]

Originally Posted by rhettyeakley

Never really understood the argument against them.
They are made of paper... Check.
They are "cards" (it's even the in the name postcard)... Check
They are a reasonable size (smaller than a cabinet or a T3)... Check

I'm not seeing the problem, but I also don't care if others view them as cards as they probably don't view some other things as cards that obviously are!

Well, the intended purpose of postcards are different than just cards from packs.

[Leon]

Originally Posted by HOF Auto Rookies

Well, the intended purpose of postcards are different than just cards from packs.

How? There are quite a few postcard sets to be collected.

[glchen]

I said "yes," but has there ever been a prewar postcard set that advertised itself as something like "collect all 60!" or "collect 10 and return for a baseball" or had their "sets" numbered like is commonly seen for typical baseball "cards?"

[Leon]

Originally Posted by glchen

I said "yes," but has there ever been a prewar postcard set that advertised itself as something like "collect all 60!" or "collect 10 and return for a baseball" or had their "sets" numbered like is commonly seen for typical baseball "cards?"

[HOF Auto Rookies]

Originally Posted by Leon

Were postcards ever offered other than to send a message to someone, like Goudey's for example, in gum packs. I am very unfamiliar with postcards.

The example you gave, what did you get when you completed the set?

[Jaybird]

Originally Posted by HOF Auto Rookies

Well, the intended purpose of postcards are different than just cards from packs.

I also don't understand that argument. Lots of cards were sold as promotional tools. Same as postcards. Some cards were packaged with candy and gum, but some were not. Look at the M101-4, given out with boy's suits or whatnot.

I didn't vote because I'm not sure I really care what they are classified as and if it keeps some people away from them to not call them cards, I'm all for it. I also think that postcard collectors aren't as hung up on the condition and grading and registry, which I appreciate as well. I guess I'm happy to be a card AND a postcard collector. Call me what you will.

[Leon]

Originally Posted by HOF Auto Rookies

Were postcards ever offered other than to send a message to someone, like Goudey's for example, in gum packs. I am very unfamiliar with postcards.

The example you gave, what did you get when you completed the set?

I don't know if Postcards were offered for anything other than sending a message. After all, that is what a postcard does. I have seen a ton of postcard size cards that don't have a postcard back but are somewhat considered postcards. I think if we try to get too strict on a definition it's going to get into semantics....And all of this debate I am having isn't to feather my own nest. I don't even collect them per se'.


What do you get upon completion? You get the satisfaction of completing the set...just like with TOPPs etc.....

[HOF Auto Rookies]

Originally Posted by Leon

I don't know if Postcards were offered for anything other than sending a message. After all, that is what a postcard does. I have seen a ton of postcard size cards that don't have a postcard back but are somewhat considered postcards. I think if we try to get too strict on a definition it's going to get into semantics....And all of this debate I am having isn't to feather my own nest. I don't even collect them per se'.


What do you get upon completion? You get the satisfaction of completing the set...just like with TOPPs etc.....

I definitely understand. For my own sake of collecting purposes and goals they don't fit, I could care less what they are classified outside of it. I still think there are some very cool PC's.

I know with some promo's Topps had back in the day, you sent in so many pack wrappers or whatnot and could get like a glove or something.

[slidekellyslide]

Postcards are NOT cards, especially baseball themed postcards...do NOT collect them.

[Jaybird]

Originally Posted by slidekellyslide

Postcards are NOT cards, especially baseball themed postcards...do NOT collect them.

I agree. They really shouldn't be part of any self-respecting baseball card collector's collection. Rubbish I say!

[glchen]

Originally Posted by Leon

Interesting. Thanks for showing that, Leon.

[bcbgcbrcb]

Agree with Jason.

[E93]

Originally Posted by Leon

. I don't even collect them per se'.....

You don't collect baseball cards?
JimB

[Greenmonster]

Agree with Jason and Dan.

Jason made an great point on condition, postcard collectors aren't as concerned about condition and having a postcard graded by PSA or SGC is really a waste of $$$. If I buy a graded postcard I'll crack the slab and add the postcard to my collection. The grading companies don't understand the postcard collector and are really missing out on a huge (world wide) potential market for grading postcards if they were to do it correctly.

[Leon]

Originally Posted by E93

You don't collect baseball cards?
JimB

Actually I voted yes but they should, and do, have their own designation as other series do....

[bender07]

Originally Posted by Greenmonster

Agree with Jason and Dan.

Jason made an great point on condition, postcard collectors aren't as concerned about condition and having a postcard graded by PSA or SGC is really a waste of $$$. If I buy a graded postcard I'll crack the slab and add the postcard to my collection. The grading companies don't understand the postcard collector and are really missing out on a huge (world wide) potential market for grading postcards if they were to do it correctly.

Care to elaborate on that? I'm a new PC collector and interested in your perspective.

[Greenmonster]

Hi Mark...Postcard collecting is a world wide hobby, huge in Europe, Asia, and all over the world, the hobby dwarfs baseball card collecting. Of course I'm not talking about just baseball theme postcards but all other topics, many, such as artist signed are valued in the thousands of dollars. As far as I know there are no grading companies grading for this market. The baseball card grading companies apply the same grading conditions to the postcard as a baseball card without consideration to what the card was intended for...being mailed. They should consider grading a postcard as either "used" or "unused" and then provide a numeric grade for the condition. Much in the same way they grade Red Man or Zeenut cards with/without tabs/coupons. Currently a postcard that has been used is downgraded because it has been written on, that condition really means little to a postcard collector and in some cases makes the card more desirable.

[Bicem]

Real photo one off postcards, such as this, I would say are closer to photos than baseball cards. (not mine)



Postcards issued as part of a set and meant to be collected I would say are definitely baseball cards. (mine)

[rhettyeakley]

Here is one really tough type card that definitely is related to a product and it is even Baseball related (who can tell everyone how?)

Note this card has a T-card ACC designation... c.1906 T132 Pulliam Cigar

[insidethewrapper]

What is the best Postcard book and checklist relating to baseball on the market ?

[glynparson]

I mean the freaking word card is in the name I don't get the negative.

[h2oya311]

Originally Posted by slidekellyslide

Postcards are NOT cards, especially baseball themed postcards...do NOT collect them.

+1!! Stay away at all costs.!!