Deserving of a PSA 10?

[swarmee]

Originally Posted by irv

Can one not request the grade remain the same when submitting for a reholder/new flip or would the TPG's say the cards no longer meet the grade we gave them X number of years ago and need to be regraded?

Sure, you can ask for a reholder and the card should not be evaluated unless there is tampering or the grade is totally off so as to trigger a review.
I am talking about the Review process, where you pay PSA to review the card in the holder, with no minimum grade. If PSA now deems this card to be a PSA 7 instead of a 10, their guarantee states that they will reimburse the submitter the difference between what they paid and what a 7 sells for.
I was just spitballing anyways, because the person buying this will definitely overpay for the 10 on the flip for a set registry, and it will never be reviewed.

And Copa, if you submitted your cards 20 years ago, they may have been graded more leniently. But since you don't have a time machine, you get graded by today's current standards, just like the rest of us.

[Leon]

To me 9s and 10s always look the same. They probably look the same to graders too LOL..... Flip a coin.

[Peter_Spaeth]

Originally Posted by Leon

To me 9s and 10s always look the same. They probably look the same to graders too LOL..... Flip a coin.

Or check who submitted them. LOL.