Results from resubmission this month...

[Archive]

Posted By: ScottIngold

40571909 1911 OLD MILL PEACHES GRAHAM BOSTON 4
40571910 1911 POLAR BEAR FRANK DELEHANTY DELAHANTY-LOUISVILLE Not Holdered, Evidence of Trimming

40571912 1911 PIEDMONT ROGER BRESNAHAN PORTRAIT 4
40571913 1911 SWEET CAPORAL CHARLIE HEMPHILL N/A 6
40571914 1911 SWEET CAPORAL RED KLEINOW BOSTON 5
40571915 1911 SWEET CAPORAL HARRY HOWELL PORTRAIT 6
40571917 1911 PIEDMONT TIM JORDAN BROOKLYN, BATTING 5
40571918 1911 HINDU VIVE LINDAMAN N/A 5
40571919 1911 PIEDMONT OTTO KNABE N/A 5
40571920 1911 PIEDMONT DODE PASKERT N/A 5
40571921 1911 SWEET CAPORAL HAL CHASE PORTRAIT-BLUE 4
40571922 1911 PIEDMONT LOU FIENE THROWING 2MC
40571923 1911 PIEDMONT GEORGE McQUILLAN BALL IN HAND 1
40571924 1911 SWEET CAPORAL JAKE PFEISTER PFIESTER, SEATED 4
40571925 1911 POLAR BEAR EDDIE PHELPS N/A 5
40571926 1911 PIEDMONT FRANK ARELLANES N/A 5MC

More later..... Off to work

[Archive]

Posted By: ScottIngold

Interesting that of the sgc's 3 went up a grade and 2 of the 3 psa's stayed the same. Only one of those got a bump.

Gai which i think gets unduly slammed did pretty well overall. Pretty much a wash.

Some times i think the back and forth regarding the grading co's is more for drama than anything else. All pretty much the same in the end. Kind of like all of us and politic's

[Archive]

Posted By: Jason L

all of these various cards were re-submitted to PSA? (and cracked out before-hand, sent in raw)

(I can be a bit thick, at times, admittedly)

[Archive]

Posted By: ScottIngold

Sorry for not saying. But yes, All cracked out first.

[Archive]

Posted By: ErlandStevens

There are 16 returns from PSA but only 14 flips. Delehanty (trimmed) and Lindaman (5) are the extras. Do you have the previous grades for these?

Thanks for making all this public.

[Archive]

Posted By: ScottIngold

Delehanty was deemed trimmed by Gai and Lindaman was an sgc 60. Just didn't have the flips anymore.

[Archive]

Posted By: ScottIngold

By the way Delehanty was an SGC 50 when i purchesed it last year.