Question: SMR Price for 1911 E94 George Close Sherry Magee In NM

[Archive]

Posted By: Seth Nagdeman

I listed a 1911 E94 George Close Candy Sherry Magee in an SGC 84 (http://www.19thcenturyonly.org/site/bid/bidplace.asp?itemid=4120). When writing the description I accessed the SMR online and they price a NM Magee E94 at $25,000. The auction went live today and a customer of 19thCenturyOnly emailed me to let me know that he thought the price might be a typo in the SMR online. I have contacted PSA, but do not yet have a reply. I was wondering if anyone can provide insight into whether the SMR online has an accurate price. Thank you in advance for your opinion.

Seth

[Archive]

Posted By: anthony

seth,
my 2007 scg has the card listed at $1500 for near mint. of course this book is almost a year old so maybe it is a type-o and should be at $2,500 and not $25k...although, it does say there is a premium 4-6x for the backs with an advertising back.
hope this helps

[Archive]

Posted By: DR

Sherry Magee PSA 5 9000 PSA 6 14000 PSA 7 25000 PSA 8 50000 PSA 9 100000 You are correct! However, not knowing this set intimately, from an outsiders view, it is odd that the Wagner is only $17,500 in PSA 7 and Cobb $25,000 in PSA 7. Is the Byrne and Magee super rare for some reason because these are both valued (in the SMR as PSA 7s) at $25,000. Best of luck with your auctions! Take care, DR

[Archive]

Posted By: Tom Nieves

Seth,

The SMR for an E94 Magee PSA 7 is 2200.

Tom

Edited: Yes, that is a typo in the online SMR.

[Archive]

Posted By: pat

easy solution.... you dont have to mention book/smr values in your listing. you can simply delete that line. problem solved.

[Archive]

Posted By: Seth Nagdeman

I took your suggestion and removed the SMR pricing information from the lot. If I get confirmation from PSA that the SMR value is $25,000 I will replace the information back into the description. Thank you.

Seth

[Archive]

Posted By: Dave F

Seth...just my opinion for what its worth...I would have to think its better not to have the SMR value listed at all on any lots. The guys going after these cards know what they are worth...and SMR is so off base anyway...if someone went by the SMR proposed values it could actually hurt you...just my two cents.

[Archive]

Posted By: Bob

Msgee is a very tough card in the set. Perhaps this is reflected in the SMR although 25k seems way too high. I am guessing closer to 7.5k for a 7.