Did The Auction House Handle My Complaint Correctly?

[Buythatcard]

I have been doing business with a major Auction House for several years. In fact I have won items totaling $111,000. So, I would say that I have been a pretty decent customer of theirs.

Last week, I won a few graded cards, They arrived in the mail yesterday and one of slabs was broken on the back. It did not break during delivery because it was packed pretty well. I am pretty sure it was broken when they listed it.

Okay, it could happen so I contacted them and asked them what I should do with it. They said mail it back and they will have it reslabbed. They also mentioned that I would be responsible for the shipping costs back to them.

That's when I got all pissed. They sent the damaged merchandise but they expect me to pay for the shipping costs to return this item.

I told them that was a poor response and would probably take my business somewhere else if they don't resolve this.

Am I wrong?

[ullmandds]

I am with you... They should pay.

[seablaster]

Originally Posted by Buythatcard

Am I wrong?

No.

If I had spent that kind of coin with an auction house, I would expect exquisite service in all aspects.

[JollyElm]

They should do the right thing and pay for the shipping. This is beyond dispute. And if they need another reason to act properly, your second sentence says all they need to know: "In fact I have won items totaling $111,000."

[canjond]

Guess I'm in the minority here, but paying the shipping costs back doesn't offend me at all (and frankly, I'd expect to have to).

[t206hound]

Originally Posted by Buythatcard

I have been doing business with a major Auction House for several years. In fact I have won items totaling $111,000. So, I would say that I have been a pretty decent customer of theirs.



...



That's when I got all pissed. They sent the damaged merchandise but they expect me to pay for the shipping costs to return this item.



I told them that was a poor response and would probably take my business somewhere else if they don't resolve this.



Am I wrong?

Let's see... They brought in $20k in revenue from you and you need to handle shipping costs on a single card. Seems reasonable to me! (Not)

[Fred]

Howard,

Are you serious? You've spent over $100K with this house in the past few years and they're asking you to pay for shipping? hahahahahahaha... what a bunch of brainiacs.... that just blows my mind.

If I were at the auction house I'd be asking you to "please" send it back so that the card can be re-slabbed and sent directly to you from the TPG, free of charge. I'd also be thanking you for your business and continued support in my business. Ok, I'd be sucking up and kissing some $100K ass...

Direct them to this thread. Holy cow... do they know who they're dealing with? Ok, you wanna out the auction house? I'm sure if you write them a polite email and explain that you're a premium supporter of their business they will review their first response and apologize for even making that request.

[ibuysportsephemera]

Terrible customer service...even if you had only spent $100 with them in the past. Shame on them.

Jeff

[Sean1125]

They should have paid. If there is every a problem with a transaction good customer or not that cost is minimal. They have likely pulled home 20k in premiums from you, very disrespectful. This isn't so much a money ordeal as principals.

[Econteachert205]

Did you talk to someone with knowledge of your record as a customer, or just talk to some lower level person following s.o.p?

[Buythatcard]

I agree that it's totally principal at this point. Doesn't matter what you spend at the AH, all customers should be treated the same.

This same place has a very bad habit of overcharging on the S/H which I always go along with.

I will give them the benefit of the doubt and will not out them until they think over my response.

With so many excellent AH's out there, I really don't want to spend my money there anymore.

[Donscards]

Maybe you should have talked to someone higher up and yes, you shouldnt have to pay for return postage. I am wondering which auction house this is, I also buy from all the auction houses and there is one that is always high on shipping etc. Most others are very fair, Good Luck.

[irishdenny]

Staying oN Track with "Principels"...

If they "Might of "Even" of shipped it cracked? Return S/H/I Shouldn't Even be an Issue... And I admit, That I would of Politely offered to Pay for it ~ However, I Certainly Would of Expected Them to countered with, "No Sir, We will be more than Happy to take care of this for You... We Strive on Our Outstanding Customer Service, As You are One of Our Most Excellent Among Them!"

With That Said... I believe that they will see this thread & do the Right Thing!

[tschock]

There are only 3 options here. It was cracked before they shipped it. It was cracked during shipping. YOU cracked it after it arrived. The first 2 they should cover regardless. So are they really implying that YOU cracked it?

[baseball tourist]

Wouldn't the AH actually have made $40K in relation to your historical purchases (assuming approx 20% juice on your buys and another 20% from the consigner). Just saying.

Also saying that good customer service should be the focus of any successful business (especially a major AH) and a customer should not have to pay any assorted costs to have a damaged item repaired.

[t206hound]

Originally Posted by baseball tourist

Wouldn't the AH actually have made $40K in relation to your historical purchases (assuming approx 20% juice on your buys and another 20% from the consigner). Just saying.

I don't know of any AH that charges that much at both ends. I assume most net 15-25% combination from buyer and seller.

[baseball tourist]

Originally Posted by t206hound

I don't know of any AH that charges that much at both ends. I assume most net 15-25% combination from buyer and seller.

Here's a big AH that charges up to 34.5% combined:

[bobbyw8469]

Originally Posted by t206hound

I don't know of any AH that charges that much at both ends. I assume most net 15-25% combination from buyer and seller.

Huggins & Scott charges me 15% to sell and 17.5% to buy. Combined that is 32.5%. I think that is pretty much standard fare. If someone can steer me to someone just as good, yet cheaper, I am all ears!

[Rich Klein]

Name that auction house in question

Bobby: Have you looked into Leon's and Scott's (B&L) auction site --

Rich

[bobbyw8469]

Originally Posted by Rich Klein

Name that auction house in question

Bobby: Have you looked into Leon's and Scott's (B&L) auction site --

Rich

They are mostly prewar I thought. Most of my consignments are postwar.

[AustinMike]

Originally Posted by bobbyw8469

Huggins & Scott charges me 15% to sell and 17.5% to buy. Combined that is 32.5%. I think that is pretty much standard fare. If someone can steer me to someone just as good, yet cheaper, I am all ears!

Either you get a discount or they raised their buyer's premium. I won some items from their recent auction and paid 19.5% buyer's premium. Not complaining because I knew that going in, just pointing out that the combined rate could be as high as 34.5%.

[Exhibitman]

Try Love of the Game. Al is great to deal with. Ditto Lee at Sterling.

As for the AH that wants Howard to pay the shipping, out the bastards already.

FWIW I had a similar experience with Heritage--scratched slab--but they covered shipping and redoing the slab and returning it to me.

ETA: eBay is a completely different story. At least until their latest f*** the sellers rules kick in and force us to pay return shipping.

[bobbyw8469]

Originally Posted by AustinMike

Either you get a discount or they raised their buyer's premium. I won some items from their recent auction and paid 19.5% buyer's premium. Not complaining because I knew that going in, just pointing out that the combined rate could be as high as 34.5%.

You are right...I paid 19.5 was well.....I mispoke. So basically, they are getting 34.5%!!!!! Uggggggggggggggggggggggggh!

[jbsports33]

Talk to them in person with the card in hand at one of the next shows they will be setup at and see if you can work this out - over the phone never seems to work. This way you both can handle the complaint and just maybe the graders will be there as well and you will not have to ship the card back.

good luck