Pick one- #1 set OR only set

[camlov2]

I have been looking through a few of the current auctions and noticed a handful of PSA #1 sets on the current Legendary auction. A few of them are sets that I hadn't seen before, I checked and they are actually the only set of their kind on the registry. (I know other sets are possible that just haven't been graded)

My question is- Which would be more attractive to you as a collector?

1) To own the only complete set of a particular set of cards.
2) To own the top graded set of a particular set of cards.

To keep it fair we would have to assume the value of the two sets are equal.

ideas?

[Mollys Dad]

The ONLY one.

[HRBAKER]

If I have to pick one, the only one.
Not my way to collect though.

[39special]

The only one. It would be neat to show it off.

[B O'Brien]

Cards are like women, I'll take odd over pretty any day!
I know this is not as tough as the things most of you all have, but it is in my top 3 favorite cards.

Hope all is well,
Bob

[e107collector]

Great card Bob! I love Carolina Brights, one of the nicest backs in my opinion.

Tony

[JamesGallo]

It depends ....

I think I would rather have the only one if it was a rare set rather then the #1of a very common set.

To gather any truely rare set takes time and true interest, if you have the money you can go out and buy the best of a set.

James g

[terjung]

easy question...

The only one.

can I get a vote for E107?

[ls7plus]

If I was a set collector, E107 would get my vote, Brian! Seems like the last I heard on this board, someone was within six or ten cards or so away from the only complete set.

Larry

PS: Nice, tough card, Bob! It would fit in quite nicely with my little band of hall-of-famers.