The 1980's...

[Doug]

Originally Posted by JasonL

And there was no craze like the Mattingly rookies...

This was probably a regional thing, but there was a huge craze here over 1985 Topps Eric Davis rookies. I remember people thinking he was the next Willie Mays and they were going to make huge fortunes off of those cards. I hope they had a backup plan...

[k-dog]

Cool thread. I was not a collector until the early 90's, but here are a few of my favorite cards from each sport:

[David W]

Originally Posted by Doug

This was probably a regional thing, but there was a huge craze here over 1985 Topps Eric Davis rookies. I remember people thinking he was the next Willie Mays and they were going to make huge fortunes off of those cards. I hope they had a backup plan...

Our local card dealer "Snyders Coin Shop" had a sign on his marquee back in the day "Buying Eric Davis rookies $10".

The interesting thing was back in 87 or so when they were hot, people really only wanted Topps, now looking back Fleer and Donruss were a lot tougher to find.

[Doug]

I guess this excerpt from Wikipedia explains all of the hype back then, but the last sentence pretty much explains why not to "invest" in these hyped up rookies. Kinda like that Strasburg guy that's already been on the DL twice.

When Eric Davis first appeared in 1984, his physical talents gave him the potential to be one of the most exciting players in the game. He was a rare five-tool player with home run power as well as sheer speed on the basepaths. He made a habit of robbing home runs and elicited comparisons to Willie Mays.

Unfortunately, he was also highly injury-prone, never playing more than 135 games in any season.

[toppcat]

Originally Posted by David W

Our local card dealer "Snyders Coin Shop" had a sign on his marquee back in the day "Buying Eric Davis rookies $10".

The interesting thing was back in 87 or so when they were hot, people really only wanted Topps, now looking back Fleer and Donruss were a lot tougher to find.

When I was a weekend warrior in the late 80's and early 90's my partner and I sold a ton of Eric Davis Topps rookies in the $12-15 range, Topps Boggs rookies for about $30 and some others like unopened Donruss as Canseco after his 40/40 season enabled us to get a lot of $ for unopened packs, which we had hundreds of and had paid ten cents each for when they got blown out in discount stores after the season.

Everyone bitches about worthless, overproduced 80's cards today but if you had them at the right time you could do well. We had picked everything up at retail or cheaper as collectors at the time of issue and I remember we knew the runs for the Boggs rookie in '83 so picked up a zillion supermarket tray packs and always hit. All I can say is if you see a Tony Perez peeking thru a clear cello pack in 83 Topps, Wade Boggs will be under it!

[4815162342]

I collected Ryne Sandberg growing up in the 80's and 90's. In 1994, I had every card of his that was in Beckett, except for the Donruss Elite cards, which I would circle in every Beckett but know that I could never afford!

[jb217676]

Good stuff guys. Here are some other 'grails' from the '80's. If you had these, you ruled the schoolyard! (Back in the day, the McGriff RC was HUGE in Toronto!)

[FUBAR]

Jeff, your Canadian, you need the Leaf version of the Mcgriff!

[jb217676]

Originally Posted by FUBAR

Jeff, your Canadian, you need the Leaf version of the Mcgriff!

Jim, you were laughed at if you had a Leaf instead of a Donruss!

[19cbb]

Originally Posted by toppcat

All I can say is if you see a Tony Perez peeking thru a clear cello pack in 83 Topps, Wade Boggs will be under it!

Wish I knew that when I was 9!
Started collecting that year and I think that 83 Donruss Ty Cobb puzzle (Which I still have framed) got me into vintage baseball.

[Irwin Fletcher]

Great thread guys.

Growing up in the 1980s and a Yankees fan, the "holy grail" card for me was definitely the 1984 Donruss Mattingly RC. I remember the card was so expensive, though, that it was always out of my price range. When I got back into collecting last year, I eagerly snatched up an SGC 96 example for around $35.

Also, don't lump Tim Raines in with flameouts like Juan Samuel and Kal Daniels! Raines should be in the HOF.

Speaking of rookie card flameouts, anyone remember Ricky Jordan and Jerome Walton?

[jb217676]

I remember Ricky Jordan and Jerome Walton very well. I also remember Eric Anthony, another bust.

[Robextend]

Originally Posted by Irwin Fletcher

Speaking of rookie card flameouts, anyone remember Ricky Jordan and Jerome Walton?

Wow Jerome Walton...there is a name for you, Dwight Smith to a lesser extent too.

I remember 1987 Bo Jackson Donruss Rated Rookie cards going for a premium as well...

[JasonL]

I was speaking more about how the cards and interest in them seemed to flameout...sometimes that happens to solid players. I recall a ton of interest in his cards for awhile and then that seemed to really die back alot...that's what I was referring to, not his career. I share your opinion of him.

and don't forget Dave Magidan!

[David W]

Originally Posted by Robextend

Wow Jerome Walton...there is a name for you, Dwight Smith to a lesser extent too.

I remember 1987 Bo Jackson Donruss Rated Rookie cards going for a premium as well...

Somewhere I've still got my 1990 Fleer card orders written down. I used to be able to walk into a store, look at the top card on the pack, and know if Walton or Smith were in that pack.