Thinking this should be re-slabbed

[bigtrain]

What do you think?

[ullmandds]

for what reason?

[peterose4hof]

Wrong name. In all fairness, the Mullen & Jones do look a lot alike.

[auggiedoggy]

Yes and it should be free.

After all, they got the name wrong, didn't they!

[tschock]

List it as a rare error, where they spelled "Jones" as "Muller".

Personally, I think it's cool and would keep it as is.

[Cardboard Junkie]

Reslab! Get it corrected. Dave.

[robw1959]

This card does have a couple of light scratches. While I agree with you that the appearance is better than a 2, SGC issues harsh technical grades for certain pet peeves they have, and one of them is paper loss. A few weeks ago an SGC rep told me that even if a card is otherwise an absolute gem-mint "10," if it has any paper loss on front (even border paper loss), the best grade it can receive is only a 3. Seriously.

[Leon]

Originally Posted by robw1959

This card does have a couple of light scratches. While I agree with you that the appearance is better than a 2, SGC issues harsh technical grades for certain pet peeves they have, and one of them is paper loss. A few weeks ago an SGC rep told me that even if a card is otherwise an absolute gem-mint "10," if it has any paper loss on front (even border paper loss), the best grade it can receive is only a 3. Seriously.

He isn't questioning the grade, which is probably correct. They put the wrong player name on the flip.

[t206fix]

Contact Earl at SGC. This has happened to me 3 times with cards I've purchased - If you send it to SGC, they will reslab it for free and ship it back to you for free.

[Bocabirdman]

So, my question is, is there a Jones with a Mullen flip?

[iwantitiwinit]

Too much hassle for a $20 card leave as is.

[bbsports]

The only error here is that the card was slabbed wrong. I'm sure that SGC will reslab the card free of charge.

[robw1959]

I get it now. Never even noticed the discrepancy and I'm the person who had it slabbed in the first place!

[bigtrain]

The Jones card is very similar and I really didn't notice until I had already bid. I still like it and will probably keep it as is. Learned a lesson to look more closely and not bid from the tiny picture on my phone.

[frankbmd]

Tom,

Leave it as it is and then when it's time to sell, you can list it as a Jones and Mullen card and double the number of potential buyers.

[t206hound]

Originally Posted by t206fix

Contact Earl at SGC. This has happened to me 3 times with cards I've purchased - If you send it to SGC, they will reslab it for free and ship it back to you for free.

Absolutely... I just sent them a card that had a mistake on the flip. I've done it in the past as well. No charge...