Players in major pre-ww2 sets also found in Zeenut issues

[brianp-beme]

A little over a year ago there was a great thread about players that are found in both the T206 and Zeenut issues. In that thread Rhett Y. provided a detailed list of these cards, which I have pasted below.

Players in T206 also found in Zeenut issues:

Fred Abbott (1911)
Bill Abstein (14-15)
Frank Arellanes (11-14, 17, HRK)
Jap Barbeau (16)
Shad Barry (11)
Beals Becker (25)
Bill Bernhad (17)
Jack Bliss (13-14)
Roy Brashear (11-14, HRK)
Bill Burns (15, 17)
Frank Chance (16-17)
Chappy Charles (13-15)
Nig Clarke (13-15)
Bill Clymer (19)
Doc Crandall (16-25, 29)
Gavvy Cravath (21)
Sam Crawford (18, 20-21)
Art Devlin (14)
Jerry Downs (13-18)
Jean Dubuc (17-18)
Joe Dunn (18)
Ted Easterly (18)
Art Fromme (15-21)
Rube Geyer (14)
Dolly Gray (12-13)
Izzy Hoffman (11-13, HRK)
Del Howard (13-20, 23)
John Hummel (18)
Jack Knight (20-23, 26-27)
Harry Krause (13-17, 21, 23-29)
Lefty Leifield (13-14)
Bill Malrkey (12-15, HRK)
Dots Miller (22-23)
Rube Oldring (21)
Charley O'Leary (14)
Orval Overall (13)
Jack Powell (14)
Billy Purtell (15)
Jack Quinn (16-17)
Newt Randall (16)
George Schirm (13)
Frank Schulte (22 w/ 2 diff teams)
Jim Scott (19-24)
Bud Sharpe (12)
Hunky Shaw (11)
Tubby Spencer (13, 15-16, 19, 21-22, 25)
Oscar Stanage (21-22)
Dolly Stark (13)
George Stone (12, HRK)
George Stovall (17)
Gabby Street (33/36)
Jack Warhop (28)
Doc White (14-15)
Ed Willett (19 Willets)


In that thread Frank W. came up with an offshoot idea of creating a list of players in the classic 1933 Goudey set that are also seen in Zeenut issues. After a little bit of researching fun, I have compiled the below list. I may not have been as thorough as Rhett, but I think I got them all...let us know of any omissions/mistakes. I listed them in Goudey's numerical order.

Players in 1933 Goudey set and their corresponding Zeenut cards:

2 Dazzy Vance (1919)
5 Babe Herman (1925)
8 Roy Johnson (1927, 28)
25 Paul Waner (1923, 24, 25)
26 Chalmer Cissell (1927)
31 Tony Lazerri (1922, 25)
39 Mark Koenig (1937/38)
50 Ed Brandt (1925)
54 Ray Kremer (1914, 18-23)
58 Lefty O'Doul (1918, 21, 25-27, 33/36)
70 Floyd (Pete) Scott (1929, 33sepia)
75 Willie Kamm (1918-22, 33/36)
76 Mickey Cochrane (1924)
78 Jack Quinn (1916-17) -also in T206-
85 Heinie Sand (1918-22)
88 Russell Rollings (1929)
95 Alvin Crowder (1923)
98 Wally Berger (1928-29)
121 Walter Stewart (1933/36)
122 Alvin Crowder (as #95)
132 Jim Elliot (1926)
146 Walter Stewart (as #121)
148 Eddie Farrell (1931)
151 Jake Flowers (1925)
164 Lloyd Waner (1925-26)
177 Walter French (1930)
178 Jackie Warner (1924-25)
184 Charley Berry (1926)
190 John Schulte (1931)
193 Lynford Lary (1926-28)
194 Earl Averill (1926-28)
195 Evar Swanson (1926-28)
196 Leroy Mahaffey (1929)
206 Gus Suhr (1925-29)
216 Lefty Gomez (1929)
217 Frank Crosetti (1928-31)
224 Frank Demaree (1931-32)
226 Charley Root (1924)
232 Lefty O'Doul (as #58)


Players in 1934 Goudey set and their corresponding Zeenut cards:

2 Mickey Cochrane (1924) -also in 1933 Goudey-
5 Ed Brandt (1925) -also in 1933 Goudey-
11 Paul Waner (1923-25) -also in 1933 Goudey-
14 Willie Kamm (1918-22, 33/36) -also in 1933 Goudey-
28 Ed Coleman (1930-31)
35 Ernie Lombardi (1928-30)
47 John Frederick (1923-27, 37/38)
50 Walter Beck (1933/36, 37/38)
54 Wesley Schulmerich (1928-29)
56 Mark Koenig (1937/38) -also in 1933 Goudey-
60 Lynn Nelson (1933sepia)
68 Bob Johnson (1930, 32)
86 Lloyd Johnson (1932, 33/36)
91 Dolph Camilli (1928-32, 33sepia)
95 Myril Hoag (1930)



Enjoy,

Brian

[Matthew H]

Great list Brian! This is very useful. I hadn't seen Rhett's list before either, which is great as well.

I know that Myrill Hoag has a Zeenut, as well as a '34 Goudey... Maybe if others know of more we could expand to include '34 players and cards.

[brianp-beme]

Thanks Matt for the suggestion...ask and you will receive. I have added the 1934 Goudey players found in Zeenut issues to the original post.

I would like to thank the late Don McPherson and late Buck Barker for doing all the original mind-numbing research on players in the Zeenut issues that had major league careers. The articles originally appeared in a series of Old Judge Newsletters back in the 1980's. Without this list I could not/would not even attempt such an endeavor...they made it so easy for me.

Brian

[brianp-beme]

Thought I would re-post various threads I started or was involved in the distant past, not only because members who have joined within the last few years probably have not seen them and might find something of interest, but also to provide some positive contrast to most of the current threads.

Brian

[Leon]

A positive contrast is always appreciated.

Originally Posted by brianp-beme

Thought I would re-post various threads I started or was involved in the distant past, not only because members who have joined within the last few years probably have not seen them and might find something of interest, but also to provide some positive contrast to most of the current threads.

Brian