What would you do?

[Archive]

Posted By: Evan

Although I have been an active collector in my chosen field for about a decade, I find myself in a situation I have never encountered. I would greatly appreciate the input of the members of this board. I am NOT looking to point fingers or suggest improprieties on the part of those involved, I am looking for advice and/or opinions on how to proceed. I was recently the winner of an autographed card, one that is the "jewel" of this particular set. It was authenticated by one of the two leading autograph authenticating companies. I was pleasantly surprised to be the high bidder since there is a fellow collector (with more means) that usually buys the best of the set. I contacted him after the sale to ask if he was aware of the sale and he informed me that he was. He explained that he had reason to question the background of the card. He suggested that I contact the seller and ask about the history. After speaking to the auction company, authenticating company and a few other contacts, I was able to ascertain the following; Years ago the card was authenticated by Company A. When the owner decided to sell, the card was sent back to Company A, who refused to recognize the signature as authentic. The sticker was removed and the loa was destroyed. Word is that money was exchanged. The card then went to Company B, who after examining the card, authenticated it. The auction company was contacted and they were forthcoming about the issue, regarding the removal of the sticker and loa.
My issue is that although autograph authenticating is subjective, and differences of opinion do occur, the situation was not disclosed in the items description. I can't say if I would have paid in the neighborhood of 10k if I had been privy to this info. Although my intention has always been to hand down my collection to my sons, I fear there will be a lingering doubt in my mind as to the authenticity. I have yet to pay for the card (I am not one to ever back out of a deal) and hope the learned members of this board can help me with this "real mess.