New cards for the Herpolshiemer Checklist (from the BAND-AID BOX COLLECTION)

[Atari]

I just went through the checklist here:
https://prewarcards.com/2016/09/08/1...and-checklist/

It would seem that the following cards in the 39 card Band-Aid Box Collection are new to the 1921 HERPOLSHEIMER checklist....

• Dave Davenport | P. | St. Louis Americans
• Jacques Fournier| 1st. B. | St. Louis Nationals
• Carl Weilman | P. | St. Louis Americans
• Charles Stengel | R.F. | Philadelphia Nationals

*UPDATE: See below. Now comparing what has been seen in the grading populations.


I don't know baseball or these cards anywhere near as well as you guys, so I might have missed a nickname or AKA of one of guys above (i.e. a Walter becomes a Wally, Urban as Red, etc.).

If anyone is interested, I'll try to get some scans up of these 4 cards in the next couple of days!

[Leon]

https://sports.ha.com/itm/baseball/1...umbnail-071515

Originally Posted by Atari

I just went through the checklist here:
https://prewarcards.com/2016/09/08/1...and-checklist/

It would seem that the following cards in the Band-Aid Box Collection are new to the checklist....

• Dave Davenport | P. | St. Louis Americans
• Jacques Fourner | 1st. B. | St. Louis Nationals
• Carl Weilman | P. | St. Louis Americans
• Charles Stengel | R.F. | Philadelphia Nationals

I don't know baseball or these cards anywhere near as well as you guys, so I might have missed a nickname or AKA of one of guys above (i.e. a Walter becomes a Wally, Urban as Red, etc.).

If anyone is interested, I'll try to get some scans up of these 4 cards in the next couple of days!

[nolemmings]

The checklist you cited is not necessarily accurate, as it appears to simply re-list the E121-80 cards. The Herpolsheimer cards were likely printed slightly earlier, and are more akin to the Holsum or Standard Biscuit cards from that period.

[Atari]

Originally Posted by Leon

https://sports.ha.com/itm/baseball/1...umbnail-071515

Thanks Leon! Someone here also said previously there was a Dave Davenport.... researching.

[nolemmings]

Davenport and Weilman appear in the SGC reports, and Fournier in the PSA pop reports.

[Atari]

Originally Posted by nolemmings

Davenport and Weilman appear in the SGC reports, and Fournier in the PSA pop reports.

I see Fournier in the 1916 set for Herpolsheimer at SGC, but not 1921. I see he's in PSA though. I'll use PSA POP to review the list again.

[Atari]

Originally Posted by nolemmings

Davenport and Weilman appear in the SGC reports, and Fournier in the PSA pop reports.

Ok when I look at it that way (checking population of SGC / PSA) I wind up with (8) 1921 Herpolsheimer cards that are in neither population:

• ARTHUR NEHF
• JOHNNY EVERS
• TRIS SPEAKER
• JACK MCINNIS
• HARRY HOOOPER
• CHARLES STENGEL
• WALTER SCHANGE
• GEORGE SISLER

SGC:
https://sgclegacy.com/PopulationReport.aspx?setid=13817

PSA:
https://www.psacard.com/pop/baseball...sheimers/40209

But as Leon pointed out above, SGC actually did grade a 1921 HERPOLSHIEMER's backed CHARLES STENGEL, but appears they have grouped it with the 1921 American Caramel Co. set (in error?)

https://sports.ha.com/itm/baseball/1...umbnail-071515

Of course Beckett may have graded some as well. Still working on it.

[Leon]

Since there is so much ambiguity in the way these are categorized it is going to be difficult to get a handle on the population.