The best of the Veteran's Committee

[bn2cardz]

There are a a lot of threads that talk about the best players ever and the same names will always come up.

Then there are threads about the worst HOF and again the same names come up.

Typically people believe the Veteran's committee is what ha brought down the HOF standards.

I would like to see everyone's BEST veteran's committee vote in for each position (3 Pitchers). For the purpose of this thread, the players selected should have also been passed up by the BBWAA, so 19th century players like Roger Connor as well as Negro League players like Leon Day can't be selected

1st - Johnny Mize
2nd - Billy Herman
SS - Arky Vaughan
3rd - Home Run Baker
C - Ernie Lombardi
CF - Richie Ashburn
LF - Goose Goslin
RF - Sam Crawford
P - Addie Joss, Hal Newhouser, Stan Coveleski


Now if you want list the worst of the BBWAA (This doesn't mean they don't deserve to be there but based off the criteria who is the worst):
1st - Tony Perez
2nd - Roberto Alomar
SS - Rabbit Maranville
3rd - Pie Traynor
C - Carlton Fisk
CF - Kirby Puckett
LF - Lou Brock
RF - Dave Winfield
P - Catfish Hunter, Rollie Fingers, Herb Pennock