PW HOF RC Question...

[Archive]

Posted By: Nickinvegas

I know this is a little off topic for a Pre-War board, but here goes:

What is the Toughest(rarity) Post war(HOF)Rookie card?

This topic was brought up the other night in the chat room and I keep on thinking about it(as opposed to thinking about something constructive(work,family, finance, religion ect.)

My guess is 1948 Leaf Larry Doby or Paige. I never see these cards.

Nick

[Archive]

Posted By: Halleygator

Since all I collect are HOF rookie cards ...

I can tell you personally that the one seen LEAST OFTEN is the Larry Doby 1948 Leaf card.

I think PSA has only graded about 32 of them total.

www.LewisBaseballCards.com

[img][/img]

[Archive]

Posted By: Jimmy Scott Elkins

a 1968 Kahn's Bench - especially with tab! I have hunted for a nice example with a tab for a long time and the only few I have ever seen are some FR - GD examples without tabs in major auction Kahn's lots (and only a couple of these)! If anyone has a nice one with tab (slabbed would be great as well), feel free to e-mail me at tycobb@optidynamic.com!

[Archive]

Posted By: Ryan Christoff

In order:

1. Luis Aparicio: 1953 Venezuelan card. Three years before he debuted in the Majors. One example known.

2. Hilton Smith: 1948-49 Toleteros. Puerto Rican issue.

3. Monte Irvin: 1948-49 El Indio. Cuban issue.

4. Leon Day: 1949-50 Toleteros. Puerto Rican issue.


-Ryan

[Archive]

Posted By: Marc S.

The 1972 Puerto Rican Mike Schmidt sticker, although not rare compared to other examples given here - is notoriously tough to find centered. Also, given the much more fragile nature of stickers - usually corners are a mess, too.

Here's one:

[Archive]

Posted By: hankron

If you're talking oddball stuff, the rarest post-war rookie card (as in, can't get any rarer) is the 1975 Hostess George Brett. Though the card was designed and the proofs exist, the actual finished card was never issued and does not exist.

[Archive]

Posted By: Paul

I'm not sure it's pre-war, or a "card", but George Kell's 1945 team issue with the A's is quite tough. So is the 1948 Safe-T card of Early Wynn with the Senators. That's Wynn's first card, but 9 years after his debut, so it's tough to call a rookie card. Of course, none of this compares in rarity to Ryan's psychotic stuff.