Pie Traynor cards and memorabilia are awesome

[Chuck9788]

I really like my 1935 "Diamond Stars" Pie Traynor.

Do you have any Pie Traynor cards or memorabilia to share?

[Hankphenom]

Don't have any of his stuff, but when I was growing up, he was the third baseman on most "All-Time All-Stars" teams, as in the book "Big-Time Baseball."

[nolemmings]

Here's a sweetie pie:

[bn2cardz]

Pie Traynor with some children at the 1929 Spring Training.



https://www.flickr.com/photos/bn2cardz/35776108262/

[kcohen]

Originally Posted by Hankphenom

Don't have any of his stuff, but when I was growing up, he was the third baseman on most "All-Time All-Stars" teams, as in the book "Big-Time Baseball."

Hi Hank. Hope you are well. That's amazing, my mother bought that book for me in 1960 or so. I still have it and pull it out from time to time. I spent hours reading the anecdotes and factoids. I was just recounting the other day to someone that, as of the writing of that book, Nick Altrock was the only pitcher to be credited with a win without throwing a pitch. I never forgot reading that. I think it's been done since.

I apologize to the OP for taking the thread on a little detour.

[btcarfagno]

I recently sold a Pie Traynor side written game used bat. This is all the more rare because Traynor is infamous for never ordering bats of his own, instead he constantly "borrowed" bats from others. He bragged about never placing a bat order of his own over like the last 15 years of his career or something like that. So a sidewritten bat with his name is one of the only ones that can 100% be linked to him.











Also, and I say this as a lifetime Pittsburgh Pirates fan, Traynor is one of the least Hall Of Fame worthy players enshrined in Cooperstown.

Tom C

[John V]

I always dig out my personalized autograph for threads like these.

[nat]

I don't have any Traynor items, but I can talk about him a little bit.

IIRC he had a sterling defensive reputation, and was a big star in his day. History has not been so kind to him. Defensive measures are always dicey, and the older they are the dicier they get, but our best attempts to quantify his defense has it come out looking not good. A bunch of 100 RBI seasons probably helped his reputation, but having Paul (and to a lesser extent Lloyd) Waner in the line up probably helped with that. (Grantham too.)

[Mark]

Originally Posted by btcarfagno

I recently sold a Pie Traynor side written game used bat. This is all the more rare because Traynor is infamous for never ordering bats of his own, instead he constantly "borrowed" bats from others. He bragged about never placing a bat order of his own over like the last 15 years of his career or something like that. So a sidewritten bat with his name is one of the only ones that can 100% be linked to him.

Also, and I say this as a lifetime Pittsburgh Pirates fan, Traynor is one of the least Hall Of Fame worthy players enshrined in Cooperstown.

Tom C

I agree that the best bat is the side-written bat. Nothing like it. I have also heard that Pie didn't order bats for himself, but that claim is belied by the shipping records. He ordered at least 14 shipments, up to his later playing years. So, I must disagree with the claim that side-written bats are the ONLY bats that you can associate with old Pie. If you have a Traynor bat that matches his orders, then you have a pretty cool bat. (I'm keeping mine).

Also, you are wrong about Traynor not deserving his place in the Hall. In the pre-war era, clubs considered third base to be a key defensive position. It wasn't far behind ss. Traynor was one of the few who were good enough to excel at third AND to hit in the top of the order. As has been said here, the people who knew baseball during Pie Traynor's era considered him to be a great fielder and a great hitter for his position. He was considered to be the best third baseman ever. That counts for something.

I had the pleasure of talking to him 3 or 4 times when I was a little kid. I sat in the same row with him at the last game at Forbes and at game 3 of th 71 WS. He was a very genial and dignified man. He was the kind of man who makes you proud to be a Pirates fan.

[btcarfagno]

An outstanding argument can be made the Traynor wasn't even the best Pittsburgh Pirates third baseman of all time by the time of his retirement. Let alone of all 16 teams.

See also: Leach, Tommy.

Tom C