cards that exist but have never been seen.

[Archive]

Posted By: Wade

I was wondering what cards out there supposedly exist on checklists but you've never seen and want to? I collect Harry Wolter cards and he is listed on both the T5 Pinkerton checklist as well as the Texas Tommy checklist. I had never seen the All-Star issue either until Scott was nice enough to email me a scan. What cards have you been waiting for but haven't come along?
p.s Anyone that might have a scan of either of these cards please post it.

[Archive]

Posted By: jay behrens

Jim Thorpe Colgan

Jay

I've just reached Upper Lower Class. I am now officially a babe magnet for poor chicks.

[Archive]

Posted By: Kevin Cummings

Not cards, but I'd love to see the Cameo Pepsin Gum pins of Cap Anson, Candy LaChance, Bill Lange and Jake Stenzel.

[Archive]

Posted By: warshawlaw

Never even a scan...

[Archive]

Posted By: Paul

I think the T231 Carson Bigbee should be near the top of everyone's list.

[Archive]

Posted By: tbob

P-2 Sweet Caporal pin Mullin large letters black hat is in all the checklists but to date no one has ever acknowledged having one.

[Archive]

Posted By: Andy Baran

There is a picture of the Cameo Pepsin Anson from Rob Lifson's personal collection on page 144 of the new Smithsonian Baseball book. Included in the photo are lots of other HOFers from the Cameo pin set, as well as an uncataloged Cameo Pepsin of Sockalexis.

[Archive]

Posted By: Andy Baran

The card that I would most like to see is the 1913 Boston Garter Rabbit Maranville. I'd also like to see the Colgan Chips Jim Thorpe. There were 2 other cards that I had always wanted to see that were either shown or discovered in the past year for the first time:

1.) 1893 Just So Tobacco Cy Young - Photo of the card in the Smithsonian Baseball book

2.) W600 Jesse Burkett - existance was in question until it was auctioned in a large lot by Mastronet earlier this year

[Archive]

Posted By: Paul

How about almost every W503?

[Archive]

Posted By: Andy Cook

I have never been able to verify that there exists a W590 for Spencer after 10 years of searching. If anyone could supply a scan, it would be appreciated.
Thanks, Andy

[Archive]

Posted By: joe Maples

I have a Detroit checklist book and for the Tigers only Cobb and Dauss are listed. 2 poses of Cobb.

Joe

[Archive]

Posted By: david

not sure if one even exists but it is included on the original oj checklist as being available

[Archive]

Posted By: Harry Wallace (HW)

I am not too good at posting pictures. Hopefully this will come out OK.

Maranville is the bottom left.

[Archive]

Posted By: jay behrens

I would love to see that Sockalexis cameo. I would assume that is the only non-photograph item of his. I'm not aware of his image existing on anything other than photos of one type or another.

Jay

I've just reached Upper Lower Class. I am now officially a babe magnet for poor chicks.

[Archive]

Posted By: josh wolf

1)1916 Tango Eggs Wagner
2)1925 Holland Roger Peckinpaugh
3)1933 Butter Cream Ruth
4)1952 Wheaties Tin Tray George Kell
5)1963 Colt .45's John Bateman

[Archive]

Posted By: Andy Baran

Courtesy of Frank Ward's website:

[Archive]

Posted By: Jay Miller

David--Although it is theoretically possible that an N173 of McPhee exists(he was on the list of cards that could be ordered) this card is NOT included in the current Cartophilic Society checklist. If you have seen it in the SCD checklist I would view it as questionable.I believe they also list a horizontal version of Brouthers which I have never seen and is also not in the Cartophilic Society listing and which is the card I would love to see. I would also like to see the Kalamazoo Bats of Dave Orr which is listed but I have never seen it.

[Archive]

Posted By: david

jay
i was refering to the original checklist from goodwin that you could pick the cabinets from. i believe both lipset and the current standard catalog omit the mcphee in their listings.

[Archive]

Posted By: john/z28jd

For Jay Behrens.If you want to see a Colgans Thorpe bad enough order than hall of fame set from Fritsch.Its a 7 card set about $10 delivered and it pictures that card along with his Wagner,Magie,Doyle/natl,and a Joe Jackson card and possibly one other i cant think of off the top of my head.I have the set somewhere in my room but i also have literally about 50 places it could be so if i ever stumble across it ill post it otherwise get the friggin set and see the card you want to see so much!

[Archive]

Posted By: Andy Baran

John is right.

http://www.fritschcards.com/reprints/1971_1990/1988Museum.html

[Archive]

Posted By: barrysloate

How about a card that probably doesn't exist but possibly could- an Old Mill cabinet of Joe Jackson, matching his T210 pose. I think only the lower series cards made it into cabinet form, and certainly not the series 8 cards.

[Archive]

Posted By: John S

E254 Getz Pittsburgh (listed by Lipset)

This card's existence is disputable, but I have always kept it on my checklist as it is the last card I need for my E254 Pirates set.

[Archive]

Posted By: Matt Goebel

Has anyone ever seen this?

[Archive]

Posted By: Bruce Babcock

Plow Boy tobacco Frank Chance. I know that there must be a few out there but have never even seen a photo or scan. Tango Egg Ty Cobb is another.

[Archive]

Posted By: Harry Wallace (HW)

Here you go Bruce:

[Archive]

Posted By: identify7

Id like to see an e107 Gochnauer, if anyone has one.

[Archive]

Posted By: Bruce Babcock

Thanks, Harry. I have the Tinker & the Evers. I'll keep looking for the elusive Chance. Now I know what I'm looking for.

[Archive]

Posted By: david

g and b comisky and kelly

[Archive]

Posted By: Bryan Long

Does this card exist? I think Lemk's book now say "now doubtful" or something like that. Anyone know or have one?

[Archive]

Posted By: barrysloate

Dunlap Detroit is not doubtful- it is non-existent. I recently checked SGC's set registry for N162 and even the people with a complete set of 8 are listed as 88.9% complete because they are missing the variation. I emailed them to change it but who knows if they will.

[Archive]

Posted By: Jerry Spillman

Tris Speaker Rose Co. postcard.

It is listed in an early 1970s postcard catalog but I've not seen one.

[Archive]

Posted By: Dan Koteles

is the Joe Kelley Victory tobbaco listed in the big Krause?

it is not in the large Beckett.

I have the Kelley.I just do not know how to scan here.

[Archive]

Posted By: Lobert Collector

Has anyone ever even SEEN one of these? Been looking for years. Please send a scan. Thanks, Bob

[Archive]

Posted By: Tim Newcomb

It's in all the checklists, but no one (except Jay M.) has ever seen one. Also the only portrait pose in the whole set, which is pretty suspicious.

Tim

[Archive]

Posted By: Bob Lemke

We have Joe K. in the Standard Catalog with Victory tobacco. We used to add about one Victory a year to the list of knowns, but have gone 0-fer-2005.

[Archive]

Posted By: Scot Reader (ebay: sreader3)

I believe all of the below T206 front/back combinations are thought possible in most checklists but that most do not exist. I would love to see any of them. Thanks, Scot

Any of these with any 350 back: Abbaticchio (Blue Sleeves), Latham, Overall (Hands at Waist), Schaefer (Washington), Tannehill (Chicago no L).

Any of these with any 460 back: Bender (With Trees), Fiene (Portrait), Fiene (Throwing).

Any of these with Broadleaf 350, Carolina Brights, Cycle 350, Sovereign 460 or Sweet Cap 460 Factory 30: Ames (Hands Above), Baker, Bender (Pit. No Trees), Berger, Bradley (Batting), M. Brown (Chi. on Shirt), Burch (Fielding) ,Cobb (Bat Off Shoulder), Conroy (With Bat), Crawford (With Bat), Dahlen (Brooklyn), Davis (Phil. Davis on Frt.), Donlin (With Bat), Doolan (Batting), Dougherty (Arm in Air), Downey (Batting), Doyle (With Bat), Elberfeld (Wash. Fielding), Griffith (Batting), Jennings (1 Hand Shows), Jennings (2 Hands Show), Johnson (Pitching), T. Jordan (Brook. Batting), Joss (Pitching), Konetchy (Glove Low), Lajoie (With Bat), Lake (St. Louis No Ball), Leach (Bending Over), Leifield (Batting), Magee (With Bat), Manning (Pitching), H. McIntyre (Bkln. & Chi.), McQuillan (Batting), Mullin (With Bat), Murphy (Batting), O’Leary (Hands on Kn.), Overall (Hand Face Hi), Pelty (Vertical), Pfeister (Throwing), Reulbach (No Glove), Rucker (Throwing), Seymour (Throwing), Snodgrass (Catching), Stahl (Glove Shows), Steinfeldt (With Bat), Street (Catching), J. Sweeney (New York), Tinker (Bat Off Shldr.), He. Wagner (Bat on Rt.), D. White (Pitching), Wilhelm (With Bat), Willetts, Willis (With Bat), Willis (Throwing), Wiltse (Pitching), C. Young (Glove Shows)

(A little less confident that the following don't exist, but haven't seen them and have looked hard)

Any of these with Old Mill: G. Brown (Chicago), M. Brown (Cubs on Shirt), Burch (Batting), Donlin (Fielding), Evers (Bat Cubs on Shirt), Pattee, Pelty (Horizontal), Powers, Reulbach (Glove Shows).

Any of these with Sweet Cap Factory 649 Overstrike: Abbaticchio (Brown Slvs.), Ames (Portrait), Ames (Hands at Chest), Ball (New York), Beaumont, Bell (Hands Above Head), Bender (Portrait), Bergen (Batting), Birmingham, Bowerman, Bradley (Portrait), Bridwell (Port. No Cap), M. Brown (Portrait), Camnitz (Arms Folded), Chance (Port. Red), Chase (Pink Background), Chase (White Cap), Chesbro, Cicotte, F. Clarke (Portrait), F. Clarke (Holding Bat), Cobb (Port. Green), Cobb (Bat On Shoulder), Conroy (Fielding), Covaleski, Crandall (Port. No Cap), Crawford (Throwing), Criger, Criss, Dahlen (Boston), H. Davis (H. on Front), Devlin, Donlin (Seated), Donohue, Donovan (Portrait), Dooin, Doolin, Dougherty (Portrait), L. Doyle (Throwing), Durham, Elberfeld (N.Y.), Evers (Portrait), Ferris, Flick, Ganley, Gibson, Hahn, Hemphill, Herzog (New York), B. Hinchman (Cleveland), Isbell, Jacklitsch, Jennings (Portrait), F. Jones (Portrait), F. Jones (Hands on Hips), T. Jordan (Portrait), Joss (Portrait), Karger, Keeler (Portrait), Keeler (Batting), Kleinow (With Bat), Kling, Konetchy (Glove High), Lajoie (Portrait), Leach (Portrait), Leifield (Pitching), Lindaman, Lobert, Lumley, Lundgren (Chicago), Magee (Potrait), Mathewson (Portrait), McGraw (Port. No Cap), McGraw (Finger in Air), Merkle (Portrait), Mullin (Throwing), Murphy (Throwing), Niles, Oldring (Fielding), Overall (Portrait), Parent, Powell, Rucker (Portrait), Schaefer (Detroit), Schulte (Front View), Seymour (Batting), A. Shaw (St. Louis), Shipke, F. Smith (F on Front), Spade, Spencer, Stahl (No Glove), Steinfeldt (Portrait), Stone, Stovall (Portrait), Sullivan, L. Tannehill (L on Front), Tenney, Tinker (Portrait), Tinker (Hands on Knees), Turner, Waddell (Portrait), Waddell (Throwing), Wallace, Walsh, Weimer, D. White (Portrait), Williams, Willis (Pittsburg), Wiltse (Port. No Cap), C. Young (Portrait), C. Young (Bare Hand).

Jennings (Portrait) with any Sweet Cap 150.

Demmitt (N.Y.), O'Hara (N.Y.) with Polar Bear.