PWCC Bid History

[bobbyw8469]

Originally Posted by Snapolit1

If I am looking for a higher end rare card, the chances are I will find it with PWCC or Probstein. That's the (disappointing) reality. Maybe add yepbg and 707. There are a lot of cool sellers out there with neat stuff, but on eBay the high end stuff tends to end up largely in a few places. As but one example off the top of my head, a Goudey Ruth in a grade above 4. Good luck finding that on ebay and not with one of these sellers. If there are 30 such Ruths sold a year on ebay PWCC probably sells 25 of them.

And the oddball sellers who have one for sale, the winning bidders turn around and consign the card with PWCC as soon as it gets in their hands. To me, that is a problem, and helps intensify the PWCC/Probstein phenomenon. No one wants to sell the cards themselves, because they feel like they are leaving money on the table. If some of these bidders would supports sellers other than those two guys.......I guess that's a pipe dream though.

[CMIZ5290]

Originally Posted by bobbyw8469

And the oddball sellers who have one for sale, the winning bidders turn around and consign the card with PWCC as soon as it gets in their hands. To me, that is a problem, and helps intensify the PWCC/Probstein phenomenon. No one wants to sell the cards themselves, because they feel like they are leaving money on the table. If some of these bidders would supports sellers other than those two guys.......I guess that's a pipe dream though.

This is a solid point....

[Batpig]

Originally Posted by CrackaJackKid

Batpig..your statement doesn't make any sense to me. It's like someone put you up to saying this to make PWCC look better. Laziness cause you don't wanna search for items from other buyers, yet you wait just for Brent and only Brent to post. It's all a game and anyone who denies it is apprently incahoots with PWCC.

Why doesn't it make sense? I am typically looking for a specific year and in high grade, and I don't have time to search for those items every night. I know that on a specific date, PWCC will put a large number of those items up so I can get the biggest bang for my time rather than constantly slogging through misleading listings and other wastes of time. To be clear, this is only how I do it on eBay. When the other large auction houses put things up outside of eBay, I go through those too. It's just my eBay bidding that is heavily slanted to PWCC. Just because YOU don't personally agree with how I spend my search time on eBay, doesn't mean there aren't a lot of other people like me.

[Peter_Spaeth]

I just set up automatic searches and let ebay do the work.

[bobbyw8469]

Originally Posted by Peter_Spaeth

I just set up automatic searches and let ebay do the work.

Ditto....in all honestly, I cringe a little bit when I see them sell something I want. I doubt I'm getting a deal is the major reason. It's never customer service issues.

[BeanTown]

Originally Posted by Peter_Spaeth

I just set up automatic searches and let ebay do the work.

Remember the old days where you could search another eBay bidders current bids. All you had to do was follow other bidders and let them do all the research.

[Peter_Spaeth]

Originally Posted by BeanTown

Remember the old days where you could search another eBay bidders current bids. All you had to do was follow other bidders and let them do all the research.

What I miss is not being able to track certain (alleged) card doctors' purchases. All those 5s and 6s that would magically reappear as 8s and 9s.

[Snapolit1]

Originally Posted by CMIZ5290

This is a solid point....

My answer to that is very simple . . . if you have a nice card to sell, give it to a great auction house that will market it and take no seller's commission. There are a bunch of great auction houses that get kudos here all the time. LOTG. Brokleman. Others. Don't sell on eBay. Negotiate with someone who actually does some work on your behalf.

[Edwolf1963]

Originally Posted by Peter_Spaeth

All those 5s and 6s that would magically reappear as 8s and 9s.

.. or all those 2's and 3 MK's that magically reappear as PHENOMINAL!, BREATH-TAKING! and STUPENDOUS! photoshopped raw cards on Battlefield0516's auctions

[Jeffrompa]

Originally Posted by Edwolf1963

.. or all those 2's and 3 MK's that magically reappear as PHENOMINAL!, BREATH-TAKING! and STUPENDOUS! photoshopped raw cards on Battlefield0516's auctions

Seems like a pattern .

[bobbyw8469]

Originally Posted by Edwolf1963

.. or all those 2's and 3 MK's that magically reappear as PHENOMINAL!, BREATH-TAKING! and STUPENDOUS! photoshopped raw cards on Battlefield0516's auctions

Or even more devious. Those SGC "A" cards that appear near mint!! That is like hitting the jackpot for battlefield!!

[Sean]

Originally Posted by bobbyw8469

Or even more devious. Those SGC "A" cards that appear near mint!! That is like hitting the jackpot for battlefield!!

She just sold that trimmed Cobb Green for $4,000.

She only got $3,000 for it back in January. The market for trimmed Cobb greens is exploding.

[BeanTown]

.

[T206Collector]

Here's a few rules I live by happily in my collecting life. To each their own:

SNIPING. If you are buying on ebay without using sniping software you are only helping the seller make more money. Raising the bids before the end only drives interest in the auction and causes eventual snipers to place higher snipes. If sniping was making ebay money they would offer the service.


SHILLING. If you are bidding in a blind auction (like ebay) you should assume you are always being "shilled." And real "shillers" in ebay don't bid things up in increments. They place "shill" snipes. Why would you shill in increments when you will be noticed by potential buyers (and potentially outed on Net54)?

Before you bid you should determine how much you want to pay for the item and then "set it and forget it." Shilling is an occupational hobby hazard. If you want to play in the auction house setting you'll be much happier paying what you want for an item without worrying that you could've had it cheaper but for some phantom shiller.

Just my 2 cents...

[x2drich2000]

Now that the bidding is over, I will admit to being the person who put in all those bids on the Siegle. I was not the consigner of this card, but wanted if for my personal collection. I have also never retracted a bid. For those that do not know me, I'm a bit obsessed with the e92 set (5 red crofts, 40 different nadja, a few blues, 2 menageries, a prizefighter, a blank back, etc). So figured this card would fit nicely into my collection. As for the other cards I was bidding on, the e93 Cobb is the last card I need for my set. The 3rd card ends tonight so I don't want to divulge it until after it ends, but would be happy to do so at that point.

So why did I bid like this? Quite frankly, to make people hesitant to bid given PWCC reputation for shill bidding. Had this been any other seller, I likely would have just put in a snipe and waited for the outcome. Does bidding like this work? Hard to say for sure, as it only takes one other person putting in a snipe to be outbid. I had a price in mind that I was willing to pay up to and set my final snipe to that amount. In this case, whoever won the card obviously still wanted it just a little more than me. However, as a few people such as Dan have mentioned, it put them off from the auction, so it did have at least some influence on some potential bidders.

DJ

[Leon]

I have a feeling more and more are playing some pseudo-games with PWCC and Probstein auctions hoping to scare others away. If I wanted something I would just bid what I want, as a snipe, and not think about it. Alas, no great looking T205 Cobby so I am safe....

Originally Posted by x2drich2000

Now that the bidding is over, I will admit to being the person who put in all those bids on the Siegle. I was not the consigner of this card, but wanted if for my personal collection. I have also never retracted a bid. For those that do not know me, I'm a bit obsessed with the e92 set (5 red crofts, 40 different nadja, a few blues, 2 menageries, a prizefighter, a blank back, etc). So figured this card would fit nicely into my collection. As for the other cards I was bidding on, the e93 Cobb is the last card I need for my set. The 3rd card ends tonight so I don't want to divulge it until after it ends, but would be happy to do so at that point.

So why did I bid like this? Quite frankly, to make people hesitant to bid given PWCC reputation for shill bidding. Had this been any other seller, I likely would have just put in a snipe and waited for the outcome. Does bidding like this work? Hard to say for sure, as it only takes one other person putting in a snipe to be outbid. I had a price in mind that I was willing to pay up to and set my final snipe to that amount. In this case, whoever won the card obviously still wanted it just a little more than me. However, as a few people such as Dan have mentioned, it put them off from the auction, so it did have at least some influence on some potential bidders.

DJ

[sushihotwings]

Originally Posted by x2drich2000

Now that the bidding is over, I will admit to being the person who put in all those bids on the Siegle. I was not the consigner of this card, but wanted if for my personal collection. I have also never retracted a bid. For those that do not know me, I'm a bit obsessed with the e92 set (5 red crofts, 40 different nadja, a few blues, 2 menageries, a prizefighter, a blank back, etc). So figured this card would fit nicely into my collection. As for the other cards I was bidding on, the e93 Cobb is the last card I need for my set. The 3rd card ends tonight so I don't want to divulge it until after it ends, but would be happy to do so at that point.

So why did I bid like this? Quite frankly, to make people hesitant to bid given PWCC reputation for shill bidding. Had this been any other seller, I likely would have just put in a snipe and waited for the outcome. Does bidding like this work? Hard to say for sure, as it only takes one other person putting in a snipe to be outbid. I had a price in mind that I was willing to pay up to and set my final snipe to that amount. In this case, whoever won the card obviously still wanted it just a little more than me. However, as a few people such as Dan have mentioned, it put them off from the auction, so it did have at least some influence on some potential bidders.

DJ

"Mic drop"

[Pat R]

Originally Posted by x2drich2000

Now that the bidding is over, I will admit to being the person who put in all those bids on the Siegle. I was not the consigner of this card, but wanted if for my personal collection. I have also never retracted a bid. For those that do not know me, I'm a bit obsessed with the e92 set (5 red crofts, 40 different nadja, a few blues, 2 menageries, a prizefighter, a blank back, etc). So figured this card would fit nicely into my collection.

DJ

It looks like the seigle might have been to the right of Crawford.
Crofts Cocoa Crawford.jpgSeigle crofts cocoa.jpg

[x2drich2000]

Pat, I believe you are right, at least for cocoa backs. I'll see if I have a chance to start a new thread later tonight with several other miscuts.

DJ

[Beastmode]

Originally Posted by Leon

I have a feeling more and more are playing some pseudo-games with PWCC and Probstein auctions hoping to scare others away. If I wanted something I would just bid what I want, as a snipe, and not think about it. Alas, no great looking T205 Cobby so I am safe....

+1 The aggravated buyers on this forum could learn a lot from this. Find a value that you think is fair, set a snipe, then walk away.

Like others have said, assume you will be shilled on any platform, more so if you can't see the bidders and snipping is not allowed.

[Timbegs]

There are also people like me who bid differently every time motivated solely by my desire to land the card. Depending on the card, I DO like to find out where the topside is and then double it for my last second bid. So I'll one click up until I find the original bidders top. I'll click it up and then if I think the guys initial top bid is too high for me, I'll give up having only cost that guy more money especially if I was the only other serious bidder. In the end, that guy may pay much closer to his top side bid because of me.

Warm glass of milk and I still sleep fine. I also have never retracted a bid. Ever. I pay literally instantly and have been actually scolded for paying before invoice.

Now, I'll ask since I never really considered it - am I a jerk ebay bidder?

I really don't mean to be. I don't work for the auction house and am small time, nickel and dime.

[nolemmings]

I often will make a placeholder bid, usually well into the auction (sometimes the final day). This is for far less than what I would be willing to pay but enough to win at the time, so that in the unlikely event my snipe does not fire off, I still have a shot--I actually have failed to do this and watched an item or two go for less than what I would have initially bid. Two bids. Max. I also watch those items so that I receive outbid and "about to close" e-mails, just for reminder purposes.

[danmckee]

Just clicked on over a dozen PWCC auctions bid history ending tonight....

84%, 90% a few 100%

Sorry.... I ain't buying it!!!!

Just complete BULLSHIT to me!

I won't bid on any with stats like that, I guarantee there is shilling involved.

Painthistorian runs tons of auctions of coll stuff and doesn't have those numbers.

I just ain't buying it!!!!

[Rhotchkiss]

How can one tell on eBay how many bids a bidder has retracted (in general and in a specific auction) and how many times a bidder has bid? When I hit bid history, all I see is a string of single bids with f**s (1896) etc. Thanks!

[swarmee]

Click on the hyperlink for each of those bidder IDs.

[Leon]

Hey Dan
Tell us how ya really feel?

LL

Originally Posted by danmckee

Just clicked on over a dozen PWCC auctions bid history ending tonight....

84%, 90% a few 100%

Sorry.... I ain't buying it!!!!

Just complete BULLSHIT to me!

I won't bid on any with stats like that, I guarantee there is shilling involved.

Painthistorian runs tons of auctions of coll stuff and doesn't have those numbers.

I just ain't buying it!!!!

[x2drich2000]

Just as a follow up, I won the third card I was bidding on for a bit less than my max bid. The card was the W554 Gehrig.

DJ

[Mdmtx]

I was high bidder on the exhibit lot with yellowhorse and Ruth etc... from 5 seconds to 4 seconds. Then I wasn't high bidder anymore.

Mark

[Beastmode]

Originally Posted by danmckee

Just clicked on over a dozen PWCC auctions bid history ending tonight....

84%, 90% a few 100%

Sorry.... I ain't buying it!!!!

Just complete BULLSHIT to me!

I won't bid on any with stats like that, I guarantee there is shilling involved.

Painthistorian runs tons of auctions of coll stuff and doesn't have those numbers.

I just ain't buying it!!!!

Possibly the most egregious shameless plug I've ever seen on net54.

[RedsFan1941]

Originally Posted by Beastmode

Possibly the most egregious shameless plug I've ever seen on net54.

you must not read the board much

[bobbyw8469]

Originally Posted by RedsFan1941

you must not read the board much

LOL...Can I plug my stuff too? My auctions don't have those kinds of stats. They also don't go for those kinds of bloated figures either.

[bn2cardz]

Originally Posted by danmckee

Just clicked on over a dozen PWCC auctions bid history ending tonight....

84%, 90% a few 100%

Sorry.... I ain't buying it!!!!

Just complete BULLSHIT to me!

I won't bid on any with stats like that, I guarantee there is shilling involved.

Painthistorian runs tons of auctions of coll stuff and doesn't have those numbers.

I just ain't buying it!!!!

Originally Posted by bobbyw8469

LOL...Can I plug my stuff too? My auctions don't have those kinds of stats. They also don't go for those kinds of bloated figures either.

Are you two stating you think Dan Mckee is plugging his own auctions when he mentioned painthistorian? Because from my understanding that isn't his ebay id.

[bobbyw8469]

I wasn't insinuating anything. I know painhistorian. He has a lot of good stuff. I know a lot of sellers (me included) that has good stuff and we AREN'T Probstein or PWCC. I don't like that you are insinuating that I am insinuating.

[bn2cardz]

Originally Posted by bobbyw8469

I wasn't insinuating anything. I know painhistorian. He has a lot of good stuff. I know a lot of sellers (me included) that has good stuff and we AREN'T Probstein or PWCC. I don't like that you are insinuating that I am insinuating.

I am not insinuating, I am asking a clarifying question based on "Can I plug my stuff too" which makes it sound like you think someone "plugged" their stuff and you want to also. Also I am clarifying for those that didn't understand the comments like myself that painthistorian and Dan Mckee are not the same.